Most reviewed American restaurants in Brooklyn, United States to visit (Updated March, 2024)

Most reviewed American restaurants in Brooklyn

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Brooklyn through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 20 places from American restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Brooklyn

Fireplace Restaurant

American restaurant

👍👍 OK I almost didn't go because of the negative reviews. I went and had a great time. Food was great and the service was great and the price was great. I'll definitely come back whenever I'm in town.

$$ $$

4.30 (1K reviews) (~23.55 km from centre)

Dobb's Country Kitchen

American restaurant

$ $$$

4.30 (1K reviews) (~24.49 km from centre)

Denny's

Diner

Casual diner chain dishing up classic American comfort fare, including all-day breakfast favorites.

$ $$$

3.80 (816 reviews) (~13.18 km from centre)

Twigs Restaurant & Cafe

Restaurant

Quaint, homey place since 1999 offering select American dishes, local craft beers & outdoor seating.

$$ $$

4.40 (806 reviews) (~26.38 km from centre)

Perkins Restaurant & Bakery

Restaurant

Kid-friendly chain known for baked goods, breakfasts & other standards in dinerlike digs.

$$ $$

4.00 (748 reviews) (~24.47 km from centre)

The Bluebird 2 Diner

American restaurant

👍 Solid breakfast at a great price. Very friendly waitress.

$ $$$

4.40 (610 reviews) (~20.41 km from centre)

Camelot

American restaurant

Quaint, medieval-themed inn with individually decorated quarters, plus a fine-dining restaurant & bar.

4.50 (602 reviews) (~27.65 km from centre)

D & H Penn Can Restaurant

American restaurant

👍👍 We have been stopping here since 1990 on our way to Lake Ontario to fish and explore.

$ $$$

4.50 (488 reviews) (~10.89 km from centre)

Finch Hill Restaurant and Dairy Bar

Italian restaurant

$ $$$

4.40 (351 reviews) (~25.64 km from centre)

Choconut Inn

Bar & grill

4.40 (341 reviews) (~29.91 km from centre)

Towne & Country Grille/Bakery

American restaurant

👍👍 What trendy little breakfast cafe! I loved it. You can get breakfast until 11am. They're only open for breakfast and lunch.. we got lunch. The pot roast grilled cheese and chicken tenders and fries. The pot roast was so juicy, and the the tenders were also really juicy and exactly what I was looking...

$$ $$

4.50 (283 reviews) (~26.57 km from centre)

Red Rock BBQ and Ice Cream

Barbecue restaurant

4.70 (246 reviews) (~25.5 km from centre)

Uptown Grill

American restaurant

🫤 Uptown Grill left a lot to be desired on my first, and what will probably be my only visit to this establishment located in Montrose. This review is for a weekend evening between the hours of 6-8 pm. The restaurant was not busy. During this visit we ordered mozzarella sticks as an appetizer, and w...

4.40 (230 reviews) (~10.87 km from centre)

Main St. Cafe

American restaurant

👍👍 Seat yourself establishment. The waitress recommended we sit by the windows overlooking the creek since we were first timers. Great view. Great food. Low prices. Small town. Street parking. Near susquehanna river. Good pie options. The other patrons talked to each other. Stop here if you're passing...

$ $$$

4.40 (195 reviews) (~27.49 km from centre)

Sunrise Cafe

American restaurant

👍👍 There aren’t enough good things to say about this place! We are so fortunate to have such quality cooking and service available to us here in our small town, and for such incredible prices. Sonya is an amazing cook, you can tell she cooks with love and uses locally sourced fresh ingredients. There’s...

$ $$$

4.70 (171 reviews) (~24.09 km from centre)

Missi's Place

American restaurant

👍 Small little place but pretty decent pizza. This is the first place in NEPA we've been that actually has Hawaiian Pizza (Canadian bacon and pineapple) on their menu. Coming from the west coast, this is a welcomed menu item. The waitress was friendly, the restaurant is small but clean, and the piz...

$ $$$

4.70 (89 reviews) (~27.16 km from centre)

Simpler Times

Beer store

👍 The service was friendly. It's great to have another place in town to grab a bite to eat with friends. The pretzel is HUGE! Just try it. Otherwise, the food is not spectacular but not terrible. I'd still eat here just becuase they are kind and I didn't feel out of place or like I was unwanted in...

4.90 (68 reviews) (~29.9 km from centre)

Rustic Roost Cafe

American restaurant

👍👍 This is my kind if place. Small town diner worth the added detour since the access to 81 is limited at this point. We stopped on for coffee and a snack. The pies are homemade and excellent!! I will make a reason to come here again someday, hopefully soon. 👍👍👍👍👍👍

4.90 (54 reviews) (~11.96 km from centre)

Orazzi's Blue Ridge Inn

American restaurant

👍👍 This place has been around since 1933 that should say enough but that's just the tip of the ice berg because as soon as you walk in you are family ... The food is outstanding as is the service so make sure you stop in you'll be happy you did !

4.60 (39 reviews) (~26.85 km from centre)

Amato's Burgers & Scoops

American restaurant

4.50 (35 reviews) (~10.69 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed American restaurants in Brooklyn, United States