Best places in Callicoon
Discover the best places in Callicoon, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. Please note that certain places categories are intentionally excluded to ensure a refined selection. Ratings are based from 18 places in the city.
Sort results by
Best Top rated Most reviewed Hidden gems Worst rated Recently discoveredSearch radius
Categories
2
The North Branch Inn
Inn
Country-chic quarters in an upscale inn on 7 lush acres, offering breakfast & a restaurant.
4.70 (177 reviews)
3
The Arnold House
Hotel
👍👍 We had our Wedding at the Arnold House in June 2023. We absolutely fell in love with this venue/inn. It has a Catskills weekend getaway camp feel which is exactly what we wanted for our wedding. Lots of lush greenery and grounds and gardens, the greenhouse is gorgeous and it feels so whimsical to be...
4.50 (358 reviews)
4
Rease's Cup
Breakfast restaurant
👍👍 Excellent breakfast. Good coffee. Casual contemporary vibe. Quite reasonable prices. Well worth the few minute detour off the main road. Highly recommended.
4.80 (127 reviews)
5
Callicoon Caffè
Diner
👍👍 Visiting from Florida. Good prices. Great service. Food was really good! Loved the atmosphere. Almost didn’t come because of a negative review but so glad we did. He was very wrong.
$ $$$
4.50 (241 reviews)
6
Rafter's Tavern
Bar & grill
👍👍 Great drinks. Great food. Great seeing friends and listening to Great 👍live music again!
$ $$$
4.60 (149 reviews)
7
The Cabin
Restaurant
👍 We went here for Father's day and everyone enjoyed the meal. There's a decking for outdoor eating and it was pretty peaceful back there. Everyone who had burgers enjoyed them. I'm a vegetarian and I had falafel, which was good but a bit too greasy. They also have a veggie burger, salads, and a coupl...
$ $$$
4.50 (173 reviews)
8
The Creek House Grill
Restaurant
👍👍 My sister and I came in for a quick bite before a concert we were seeing nearby at Bethel Woods. The atmosphere is so cozy and we were immediately greeted by a friendly bartender and hostess. We decided to sit outside which was lovely and our hostess asked if we were going to the concert. I thought...
4.70 (103 reviews)
10
The Cacklin' Hen
Restaurant
👍👍 It's a modern day Mayberry at the Cacklin' Hen. Starting from the quaint front porch with it's swinging screen door. Everyone, not just the staff was welcoming. You feel like you belong there. The colors are bright and cheerful, the decor is fun and quirky and the kitchen is in full view and all the...
4.90 (56 reviews)
11
Callicoon Hills
Hotel
😠 I booked this hotel in hopes of having a nice relaxing getaway with my puppy. But the result was quite the opposite. When I first arrived to the hotel, there was construction being done all around the property without any warning and the noise of the construction persisted throughout our stay. The o...
4.60 (77 reviews)
12
Peck's Market
Supermarket
😠 I've lived hee for 18+ years, and have found the staff here to be hit or miss. More miss than hit. Today I begrudgingly went in to buy three overpriced items, one being laundry pods. Using my debit crd I requested $10 cash back. When the cashier, in a rather unpleasant tone requested that in the...
4.30 (135 reviews)
13
Callicoon Brewing Company
Brewery
🫤 We give this 2 stars ONLY due to
The service which was outstanding. Would have given 1 star if not for her. Wait staff was friendly, professional and helpful. The food…well, let’s say we’ve had better meals at McDonald’s and that saying a lot because we do t really eat there unless we have to. The...
4.20 (152 reviews)
15
Callicoon Creamery
Ice cream shop
👍 Ice cream is mostly from Perry Premium Ice Cream - I’m not complaining. They have a pretty extensive food menu as well. And pleasantly surprised to find out bleeding hearts growing by the seating area!
$ $$$
4.50 (59 reviews)
16
The Kitchen Table Cafe
Cafe
😠 Walked in at 3:01 yesterday, as the website and sign on the door states they are open until 4pm. There were a bunch of people sitting down. We went up to the cash register to get a cup of coffee and she informed us that they were closed as of 3pm (1 minute prior to us walking in). The door was open,...
4.50 (59 reviews)
17
Conover Club
American restaurant
😐 Menu wasn't very appealing and service was just okay when I went. If you're staying for the night, it is probably worth the convenience, but would recommend driving to Callicoon proper for a dinner.
$$ $$
4.70 (43 reviews)
18
Ollie Grey’s
Restaurant
👍 Good place to get ice cream! There has been an ice cream stand here since I lived here in the 70's, and this is just as good as the previous ones.
4.70 (33 reviews)