Most reviewed Sports memorabilia stores in Chicago, United States to visit (Updated May, 2024)

Most reviewed Sports memorabilia stores in Chicago

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Chicago through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 12 places from Sports memorabilia store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Chicago

PGS Gold & Coin

Coin dealer

😠 Lowball offers below spot price when you want to sell. Walk away before you come within five feet of the front door and go somewhere else. Update to respond to the canned reply below from PGS: You don’t have any record of my visit because my profile doesn’t use my real name, and I left after declin...

4.80 (374 reviews) (~45.71 km from centre)

PGS Gold & Coin

Coin dealer

👍👍 I've been to PGS in Wheaton a few times now, for coins and jewelry. They've been very patient going through a large mixture of coins left by my parents, explaining valuations and pulling out the face value coins. Most recently I took a couple older watches and they spent quite a bit of effort to ge...

4.80 (285 reviews) (~42.99 km from centre)

PGS Gold & Coin

Coin dealer

😠 I was very disappointed with PGS Gold & Coin. I didn’t know the first thing about coins. I called the store and Estelle told me to send a copy of the coins I had to her e-mail address. I had to e-mail her a second time to ask if she received it. I realized I left off the mint and she told me my coin...

4.80 (239 reviews) (~40.59 km from centre)

Baseball Card Exchange

Sports memorabilia store

😠 Used them for the first time recently. Only spent about $100 on several "unopened" packs. I felt that it was easily apparent that at least half the packs had been opened and resealed. I have no confidence in their "authentication process". For example, in one "unopened" 1982 Fleer Baseball card pack...

4.00 (209 reviews) (~42.48 km from centre)

Closet Collectibles

Toy store

4.90 (198 reviews) (~48.96 km from centre)

PGS Gold & Coin

Coin dealer

👍👍 My sister and I liquidated a large and diverse collection of coins from a family estate. We read the positive reviews for the Villa Park PGS location (many specifically praising Jill Schumacher) and made an appointment. On 2 separate occasions, Jill spent hours sorting and pricing our coin collectio...

4.90 (183 reviews) (~30.05 km from centre)