Most reviewed Fishing ponds in Columbus, United States to visit (Updated May, 2024)

Most reviewed Fishing ponds in Columbus

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Columbus through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 30 places from Fishing pond category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Columbus

Big Bone Lick State Historic Site

State park

Historic site with a museum housing fossilized bones, plus a campground, trails, mini-golf & more.

4.60 (2.6K reviews) (~191.72 km from centre)

Munroe Falls Metro Park

City park

Tree-covered 500-acre park with ponds & walking trails, plus swimming, sports fields & boating.

4.60 (1.1K reviews) (~185.7 km from centre)

Lake Isabella

Park

👍👍 This park has come along way in 35 years. Very pleasant visit.

4.40 (1K reviews) (~137.79 km from centre)

Burnet Woods

Park

Forested, 90-acre park with hiking trails, bird watching, a fishing lake & picnic sites.

4.50 (972 reviews) (~159.01 km from centre)

Roger A. Reynolds Municipal Park

Park

This 8-acre city park offers amenities including a swimming pool, a sledding area & a playground.

4.60 (706 reviews) (~16.47 km from centre)

Flat Fork Creek Park

Park

This 60-acre park features a lake, nature trails, a sledding hill, a mountain-biking course & more.

4.70 (630 reviews) (~245.15 km from centre)

Middlefork Reservoir

Park

4.40 (556 reviews) (~160.09 km from centre)

Yogi Bear's Jellystone Park

Campground

👍👍 We stayed in cabin LS-3. Cabins are small, but better than a tent. The fishing wasn't great. We didn't have much luck the week we were there, but the kiddos still had a good time. Pool is cold, but clean and well maintained. The grounds are well maintained. The bathrooms are exceptionally well clean...

4.40 (395 reviews) (~218.26 km from centre)

Camp Timber Lake

Campground

4.40 (340 reviews) (~231.12 km from centre)

BJ's Pay Lake

Fishing pond

$ $$$

4.50 (323 reviews) (~143.55 km from centre)

Willow Lake Park

Campground

👍 I've only been here a week an I have had a pretty good time so far. The people not only in the camp but the locals are overwhelming with kindness that will make the trip worth it. Now again the campground is well kept the noise is very calm,(kids are kids) an that being said the lady at the front of...

3.70 (318 reviews) (~168.61 km from centre)

Indian Springs Campground

Campground

😠 The campground was very loud. Quiet hours were not enforced. Our neighbors were out sitting around their campfire till all hours with music going. The campground was not maintained. The trash dumpsters had trash laying around on the ground from overflow. I would not stay here again.

3.50 (249 reviews) (~233.88 km from centre)

Furnace Run Metro Park

Park

👍👍 Wide, flat, easy trails, lots of picnic tables, and well marked trails. Lodge with bathrooms and drinking fountains. Big pond. Well shaded trail. We enjoyed walking along the creek and the many bridges.

4.70 (246 reviews) (~185.19 km from centre)

Lake Snowden Campground

Campground

4.00 (239 reviews) (~106.03 km from centre)

Hidden Lake

Park

👍👍 A hidden gem! We visited totally on a whim just because we saw the sign on our way to the Lake Erie Bluffs and we decided to check it out. What a pretty little lake! Nice wooded trail and picnic areas. Lots of people fishing and kayaking. And if you are into archwry there is a nice archery range too...

4.70 (192 reviews) (~247.72 km from centre)

Campbell Lakes Preserve

Park

👍 This is a fishing park and that's about it. We visit often simply because it's a close area to fish. Personally, I only do ok fishing here. I have caught a decent amount of little bluegill there and a couple of little bass. Now I know I've heard of others catching some larger bass, northern pike, an...

4.30 (184 reviews) (~173.18 km from centre)

Casterline's Pay Lake and Bar

Fishing pond

🫤 No common courtesy at all. The regulars are basically allowed to fish the whole lake and be in other people's way and just yelling at each other across the lake. I used to love coming here but recently I haven't had a good experience here because of the lack of fishing courtesy for others fishing he...

4.20 (184 reviews) (~169.88 km from centre)

Sky Lake RV & Fishing

Campground

😠 AVOID THIS CAMPGROUND IF YOU ARE A BIG RIG; NOT big rig friendly! We rented a PULL THROUGH spot as a stopover spot on our way through from Pennsylvania to Illinois. Perfect location and nice lake, but once you get past the nice drive in, you see how packed in they put these sites! Our site MIGHT hav...

4.10 (128 reviews) (~65.55 km from centre)

Nickel Valley Resorts

Restaurant

👍 Nice country bar. Friendly bar tender and owner. Has an outdoor pavilion and smoking is permitted as well outside. Drinks were a tad on the pricey side for being absolutely in the middle of nowhere. Stayed in one of the cabins after having a few drinks. The one we rented was around $150 and was very...

4.70 (111 reviews) (~77.48 km from centre)

Cast Away Lakes

Fishing store

3.90 (103 reviews) (~111.53 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed Fishing ponds in Columbus, United States