1
Mama Tita's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This pizza was absolutely delicious. The garlic nuts were superb. Service was impeccable. I ordered the pie and they told me 15 minutes and it was ready the second I walked in. Excellent customer service and wonderful food make this one of the better pizzerias in the neighborhood. Definitely want to...
$$ $$
4.70 (144 reviews)
2
Mema's
Restaurant
🫤 This is a tough one, because on one hand the food did sort of get better. But the prices have gotten insane. I paid $22 for 2 plain slice 1 Chicken Parm and one Chicken Marsala. That's the same or more than a whole plain pie. I 100% get the Marsala slice being expensive, it's a serious sized, very...
$$ $$
4.60 (178 reviews)
3
Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍 A fine place for lunch! Don’t let the strip mall entry mislead you...inside a lovely dining experience in a relaxed and attentive environment. The food is home made, fresh and generous in portion size. The staff attentive (though sometimes too busy) and helpful. I hear that dinner is equally enjoya...
$$ $$
4.50 (375 reviews)
4
Filetto's Commack
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Just wanted to give a special shout out to Filetto's of Commack on Commack Road. We had a bridal shower there for my niece last Saturday afternoon and it was absolutely perfect in every way. First, planning with Vinny was great. He was so nice, patient with all my many questions, and was willing...
$$ $$
4.50 (177 reviews)
5
Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery
Pizza restaurant
😠 Where do I start let’s see! The person that answers the phone and takes the order seems to not like working there since he is rude and nasty even when placing the order. They told me it would be about an hour for delivery cause it’s a busy delivery day with one driver. Fine I said that’s ok and went...
$ $$$
4.50 (162 reviews)
6
La Scala Ristorante Pizzeria
Italian restaurant
Family-run Italian fixture delivers pasta, seafood & pizza-parlor staples in busy strip-mall digs.
$$ $$
4.40 (1.1K reviews)
7
GINOS OF COMMACK
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 I came here today for the vegan options. I asked if there was anything else besides a 12" pizza to order and the very patient and friendly staff provided me with other vegan options and helped me order a vegan eggplant parmigian that was delicious! I definitely plan on returning to try their vegan p...
$$ $$
4.40 (270 reviews)
8
Milano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 If you haven’t tried this restaurant yet, you should. Commack has a lot of Italian/pizza places, this one has definitely come to rank number one for my family. The deep dish is delicious. Enjoy.!
$ $$$
4.40 (147 reviews)
9
Henry's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 I got White, Regular, and Vodka slices. They were all good I liked the Regular the most. The crust is nice and crispy reminds me of a bread stick probably why they also offer sesame seeded crust. The garlic knots were great too alittle oily but really good.
Update:
Have had food from here multiple...
$$ $$
4.30 (216 reviews)
10
Prato 850
Italian restaurant
😠 Edit: Decided to give this place one more try a year after my last review and it took 1.5 hours for the food to come out. When it did eventually get to the table, the items did not match their menu description whatsoever (missing several menu ingredients). The food was good, but not worth the wait....
$$ $$
4.20 (678 reviews)
12
Mario's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Standard Italian eats, bacon-topped pizzas & other specialty pies stand out at this informal eatery.
$$ $$
4.20 (547 reviews)
13
Original Brooklyn Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
😠 Over priced pizza ! I got 2 slices and a drink paid almost 20.00 . the pizza bread was really soggy, the cheese tasted really weird. Not one person that touched my food had any gloves on. So much oil on the pizza I could only bare to eat 1 slice and will not touch the second piece !Not going back he...
$$ $$
4.10 (133 reviews)
14
Emilio's
Pizza restaurant
A mix of classic pastas, pizza & creative Italian entrees in an upbeat, modern strip-mall space.
$$ $$
4.00 (897 reviews)
15
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
3.80 (153 reviews)