Most reviewed Pizza restaurants in Eatontown, United States to visit (Updated April, 2024)

Most reviewed Pizza restaurants in Eatontown

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Eatontown through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 31 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Eatontown

MJ's Restaurant Bar and Grill

Pizza restaurant

Specializing in pizza, this lively restaurant offers sporting events on TV along with a full bar.

$$ $$

4.20 (607 reviews) (~4.29 km from centre)

Maurizio Pizzeria & Italian Ristorante

Italian restaurant

Low-key local chain outlet with Italian fare & pizza with basic or gourmet toppings to stay or go.

$ $$$

4.10 (384 reviews) (~2.4 km from centre)

Rockafellers Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 What an awesome place! As soon as we came in we were attended. The waiter was so awesome, she brought out not one but two coloring books for the baby and also brought him some peaches. The food was absolutely amazing! 10/10 recommended 🫶🏼❤️

$ $$$

4.60 (370 reviews) (~4.75 km from centre)

Bom DMais Lanchonete e Pizzaria

Pizza restaurant

😐 The food is good, the juices are good but if you’re watching your sugar make sure to tell them not to add extra sugar to your juices because they add A LOT! i saw them make mine and i had to go home and dilute it with water because i would of been drinking diabetes. The staff is friendly but i just...

$ $$$

4.30 (345 reviews) (~4.3 km from centre)

Belo Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Bravo!!!! On point. A++ Superb thin crust pizza. Plain is excellent. The grilled chix with red peppers and balsamic glaze was the best specialty slice I've ever eaten. Hands down the most delicious scrumptious pizza from NYC to Florida and up down the eastern coastline. Much gratitude and appreciat...

$ $$$

4.70 (333 reviews) (~1.21 km from centre)

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 I cant really say how the food was. I ordered and was told 30- 40 mins but call and hr later was told the girl who took my order should have said longer. If that was the case why not call and tell me that. Think I'll just keep searching for another pizzeria. My stars do not reflect the quality of f...

$$ $$

4.30 (279 reviews) (~2.4 km from centre)

Illiano's Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Homestyle red-sauce Italian BYOB focusing on pizza & pasta, with outdoor seating & a broad menu.

$$ $$

4.40 (278 reviews) (~3.78 km from centre)

Luigi's Famous Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Family-owned pizzeria with a large menu of gourmet pizzas, burgers, salads, subs & Italian entrees.

$ $$$

4.40 (272 reviews) (~3.29 km from centre)

La Scarpetta Italian Grill & Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

😐 One year ago, I ordered the Mexican Pizza and it still haunts me to this day. I have nightmares about it and any conversation involving pizza gives me PTSD forever ruining what was once my favorite food. Three stars because the Clams Oreganato and Gnocchi Meat Sauce may have been good, but it was...

$$ $$

4.20 (236 reviews) (~2.96 km from centre)

Illiano's Café

Italian restaurant

Everyday pizzas, pastas & other Italian comfort food served in an easygoing environment. BYOB.

$$ $$

4.40 (231 reviews) (~2.35 km from centre)

Domino's Pizza

Pizza delivery

Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.

$ $$$

3.30 (224 reviews) (~0.32 km from centre)

Merendino's Pizza & Ristorante

Restaurant

👍👍 We order their Sicilian which was really good. The ingredients felt fresh and the crust was amazing. We also got the Garlic Knots, they were a little too oily and garlicky (which I don’t mind but if you don’t like a strong garlic taste these are not for you) Their regular pizza is good. Will be tryi...

$$ $$

4.10 (221 reviews) (~3.62 km from centre)

Nelly's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Pizza joint with a huge menu including many sandwiches, plus Texan & Mexican dishes.

$ $$$

3.30 (200 reviews) (~3.07 km from centre)

Pastosa Ravioli, 315 Highway 35, Eatontown, NJ 07724

Italian grocery store

👍👍 Never know what I'm in the mood to eat, but I always find something delicious. I love all the employees! Super friendly and make me feel special!

4.70 (198 reviews) (~1.67 km from centre)

Olivia's Trattoria & Artisan Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 “Sandwiches are disgusting - skip this place” FOOD was awful they overcooked the chicken so much it was like rock hard pieces, unedible. The portion size was a joke it was so small. Roll was 100% STALE Cheesesteaks and subs -terrible The fries were good and a big portion? MENU was not good and Ove...

$ $$$

4.60 (190 reviews) (~4.81 km from centre)

Olivia's II Pizza and Pasta

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 I went to see what new to me Olivia's 11 Italian restaurant was like. Walked, in very courteous, kind, staff employees, etc. Very nice, pleasant dining area. Excellent food, service, and Melissa was at time I went there. She was nice, made me feel home ,extremely friendly and courteous,...

$$ $$

4.70 (183 reviews) (~0.53 km from centre)

Gianni's Pizzeria Oakhurst

Pizza restaurant

Casual local chain with patio seating & a menu of pizza, pastas, sandwiches & Italian ices.

$ $$$

4.00 (162 reviews) (~4.09 km from centre)

Slices of Hope Pizza & Restaurant

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Every Saturday lunch is pizza. So glad we found this place. Pizza is great and the people there are nice every time we go there. And they have a great gluten free option for my daughter

$$ $$

4.40 (159 reviews) (~3.45 km from centre)

Lupo Pizzeria West Long Branch

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Stopped by this place cause I needed something to eat after school. And my god did I stop at the right place. The pizza is very good. The staff are very very accommodating and friendly and they even know their food is good. The buffalo chicken pizza is the best thing they serve!! Go there, you won’t...

4.60 (157 reviews) (~1.87 km from centre)

Brother's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 If I could rate them ZERO stars I absolutely would. I ordered a Large Pie with half pepperoni, and half onions and peppers AND WAS SURE TO SPECIFY THE FACT I WANTED IT EXTRA CRISPY, AND THE CRUST WELL DONE. Understandably, they are an oily combo, but this pizza was so OILY, that it was not to be dig...

$ $$$

3.90 (150 reviews) (~3.39 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed Pizza restaurants in Eatontown, United States