Most reviewed places in Fire Island Pines

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Fire Island Pines through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. Ratings are based from 205 places in the village.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories



Heckscher State Park image
1
Heckscher State Park
State park
1,600-ac. park on a 19th-century estate offers multi-use trails, sports fields & boat launches.
4.50 (3.1K reviews) (~9.42 km from centre)
Fire Island National Seashore image
2
Fire Island National Seashore
Nature preserve
Picturesque seaside national park featuring a host of flora & fauna, plus camping.
4.80 (2.9K reviews) (~6.38 km from centre)
View image
3
View
Restaurant
Fish-focused menu in a bright dining room overlooking the bay, with happy hour & music on the deck.
$$$ $
4.20 (1K reviews) (~9.17 km from centre)
The Shed Restaurant - West Sayville NY image
4
The Shed Restaurant - West Sayville NY
Restaurant
👍 Had dinner here a few days ago. There's plenty of parking in the back. We came in through the door by the parking lot. The bar is really nice. We went to the hostess and were seated right away at a cute booth for 2. Pur waitress came over right away. We had drinks that were really nice and ordered a...
$$ $$
4.60 (982 reviews) (~7.53 km from centre)
The Snapper Inn image
5
The Snapper Inn
Seafood restaurant
Seafood spot family-run since 1929 offering deck seating on the water, Sunday brunch & live music.
$$$ $
4.40 (973 reviews) (~9.61 km from centre)
JT's Cafe image
6
JT's Cafe
Cafe
Comfort fare served all day in cozy digs with nautical accents, a full bar & outdoor picnic tables.
$$ $$
4.60 (781 reviews) (~9.74 km from centre)
Butera's image
7
Butera's
Italian restaurant
Bustling spot with a warm atmosphere serving generous portions of Italian favorites.
$$ $$
4.50 (754 reviews) (~7.88 km from centre)
Blackbirds' Grille image
8
Blackbirds' Grille
Restaurant
Homey option for Southern-Cajun eats & specials with added kick from an active bar & weekend music.
$$ $$
4.40 (740 reviews) (~9.19 km from centre)
Ricky Jewelry image
9
Ricky Jewelry
Jewelry store
👍👍 Ricky is AMAZING!! My husband and I have been going to him for YEARS!! He is honest and reasonable and always goes ABOVE and BEYOND for his customers! If you are looking for something specific he goes out of his way to get it for you. He is trustworthy and his jewelry is TOP NOTCH!! I can’t say enou...
4.90 (709 reviews) (~7.85 km from centre)
Corey Beach image
10
Corey Beach
Beach
Bustling beach with swimming & a seasonal lifeguard, plus a playground, gazebo & concessions.
4.40 (707 reviews) (~9.62 km from centre)
Satelite Pizza image
11
Satelite Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Awesome food love their Lasagna, their cheese burgers are delicious and very good Sicilian pizza. I’ve been going there for over 30 years one of my favorite restaurants. Finally opened the new side of the restaurant big improvement.
$$ $$
4.50 (628 reviews) (~9.18 km from centre)
Claws Seafood Market image
12
Claws Seafood Market
Seafood market
4.50 (575 reviews) (~7.48 km from centre)
George Martin's Strip Steak image
13
George Martin's Strip Steak
Steak house
Chophouse serving steaks & cocktails with a 1920s twist in a quaint turn-of-the-20th-century house.
$$$ $
4.70 (572 reviews) (~9.33 km from centre)
Flo's Luncheonette image
14
Flo's Luncheonette
Sandwich shop
Retro window-serve snack shack with picnic tables doling out burgers, dogs & shakes since 1926.
$ $$$
4.40 (562 reviews) (~9.74 km from centre)
Kingston's Clam Bar image
15
Kingston's Clam Bar
Seafood restaurant
Lobster rolls & other seafood treats offered in a classic dockside joint, open seasonally.
$$ $$
4.30 (544 reviews) (~6.58 km from centre)
SightMD Sayville image
16
SightMD Sayville
Ophthalmology clinic
4.70 (539 reviews) (~7.85 km from centre)
Wendy's image
17
Wendy's
Fast food restaurant
Fast-food burger chain serving sides such as chili & baked potatoes.
$ $$$
3.90 (536 reviews) (~9.07 km from centre)
The Cull House image
18
The Cull House
Restaurant
Casual, beachy fixture serving sea fare on paper plates amid nautical decor & a welcoming vibe.
$$ $$
4.40 (535 reviews) (~7.06 km from centre)
Five Points Cafe image
19
Five Points Cafe
Bar & grill
American restaurant with a warm rust-&-brown palette known for burgers made of freshly ground beef.
$$ $$
4.30 (530 reviews) (~7.93 km from centre)
The Fish Store image
20
The Fish Store
Seafood restaurant
Family-run fish specialist serves fresh catch & shellfish in cozy, casual digs with attached market.
$$ $$
4.40 (499 reviews) (~9.19 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories


Last updated:
( )