Hidden gems - Ice cream shops in Fort Myers, United States not to miss (Updated March, 2024)

Hidden gems: Ice cream shops in Fort Myers

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Fort Myers. This list contains 26 places from Ice cream shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Fort Myers

Gelato-go Fort Myers

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Wonderful little gem. Family owned. These folks really take pride it their product and they should. The gelato is just heavenly. They also have sandwiches. Mine was great. I was too full from my lunch and gelato to try the pastries but they also looked amazing!

$$ $$

5.00 (143 reviews) (~14.97 km from centre)

Lava Ice Shop

Ice cream shop

👍👍 My 2 teens and I discovered Lava Ice at the Wellen Park Welcome Center last Tuesday. We got to sample a few flavors before making our choices. Oh my goodness it was so good! My son got Lemon, my daughter got Cotton Candy, and I got Pina Colada! We had never had Italian Ice but we fell in love with i...

5.00 (95 reviews) (~45.99 km from centre)

Meli’s

Ice cream shop

5.00 (23 reviews) (~22.43 km from centre)

The Gelato Truck

Ice cream shop

5.00 (9 reviews) (~25.92 km from centre)

Pop Love Gelato

Ice cream shop

5.00 (6 reviews) (~55.13 km from centre)

Watson's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

4.90 (145 reviews) (~42.74 km from centre)

"Fresco " ice cream - Coffee Shop

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Punta Gorda, FL. Stopped by for the first time. Yummy 😋 Gelato and filled croissants, and more. Found out the owners are from Italy 🇮🇹 They also own the pizza restaurant next door. Cute house. I introduced myself since I used to live in Italy and have been to most cities in Italy 🇮🇹 I will definite...

4.90 (36 reviews) (~37.03 km from centre)

Groovy Smoothie

Açaí shop

4.80 (140 reviews) (~63.88 km from centre)

Pelican’s SnoBalls-Labelle

Ice cream shop

Chain doling out New Orleans-style shaved ice in a wide variety of classic & unique flavors.

$ $$$

4.80 (96 reviews) (~45.09 km from centre)

The Magic Bus on Sanibel

Ice cream shop

4.80 (16 reviews) (~25.88 km from centre)

Wonderland Cookie Dough & Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

😐 I was super craving cookie dough since I’ve never had edible cookie dough. First time here. I got 2 scoops of chocolate chip (pretty good, almost identical to real cookie dough). Also got 1 scoop of brownie batter (had a weird after taste, it’s ok, don’t super recommend). I also got a blondie, howev...

4.70 (148 reviews) (~5.67 km from centre)

Mitch's Cookies - Dessert Bar & Soda Fountain

Cookie shop

$ $$$

4.70 (104 reviews) (~57.29 km from centre)

Ohana Hawaiian Shaved Ice, Inc

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Great selection and great flavors. They really hook you up with the portion size too for the price. 👍

4.70 (55 reviews) (~52.11 km from centre)

Macy Lou's Country Store and Café

Coffee shop

👍👍 I had the special thus week of Macy Lous homemade meatloaf meal it came with mashed potatoes, green beans with pieces of bacon and cornbread. It was absolutely delicious! If you haven't tried her specials, you are truly missing out! I got one of her cinnamon rolls for dessert and it melted in my mou...

4.70 (23 reviews) (~65.4 km from centre)

La Michoacana Paleteria (La Original)

Ice cream shop

4.70 (21 reviews) (~88.09 km from centre)

Haven Fresh

Restaurant

👍👍 Very small inside. We are in our car. Excellent tacos. I got chorizo and chicken.

$ $$$

4.60 (121 reviews) (~80.22 km from centre)

ice cream Carrusel

Ice cream shop

😐 Little colorful ice cream shop located in a little shop next to a gas station, it offers more than 30 different flavors of ice cream and paletas. It's closed on Tuesday and sundays open at noon.

4.60 (82 reviews) (~16.99 km from centre)

GiGi’s Ice Cream of Punta Gorda

Ice cream shop

4.60 (67 reviews) (~37.19 km from centre)

Pinocchios Original Italian Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Really good gelato. Very impressed by the selection. Service was very good and free samples to make sure you like what you want.

$ $$$

4.60 (48 reviews) (~15.47 km from centre)

Meltz

Ice cream shop

$$ $$

4.60 (41 reviews) (~55.01 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Ice cream shops in Fort Myers, United States