Top rated Mexican restaurants in Garden City South, United States to elevate your visit (Updated May, 2024)

Top rated Mexican restaurants in Garden City South

Experience the best that Garden City South has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 116 places from Mexican restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Garden City South

Viva Tulum

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 What a great and welcome addition to Baldwin. Welcome! Had a great meal tonight during opening day. The food was delicious. The menu is extensive and the service was great. Loved it and will be back.

$$ $$

4.90 (55 reviews) (~8.33 km from centre)

TACO EL CHINGÓN #4

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 Amazing authentic Mexican food on Long Island! So glad this place opened up in the area. A recent trip to Mexico enlightened us to what real Mexican food is like. And we craved it. The food at Taco El Chingon fit the bill perfectly. We got two birria quesadillas and one torta cubana (not pictured he...

4.80 (108 reviews) (~4.59 km from centre)

Mercadito 2 Taqueria

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 I’m just a whitey but this seems to be authentic Mexican food. Excited it’s on LI. We need more of these places.

4.80 (43 reviews) (~3.38 km from centre)

El Nopal of Floral Park

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 My family and I love this place. We eat here all the time. Not only is the staff super friendly and accommodating, the food is super delicious. The authenticity put into each plate makes this restaurant stand out from the other Mexican restaurants in Floral Park. Will definitely be returning to try...

$ $$$

4.70 (316 reviews) (~4.1 km from centre)

Mala Madre Taqueria

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 Came here for dinner this weekend. The inside is industrial chic, think a nicer version of Chipotle (with a unique Mexican soda wall). We each ordered three tacos, which are prepared fresh in the kitchen to order. The flavor in the food is fantastic and it is marinated and seasoned very well. The ta...

$$ $$

4.70 (252 reviews) (~7.01 km from centre)

El Huaraches

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 As soon as we walked in, we were greeted with a warm welcome. The smiles of the staff and owner set the tone for what would be a great dining experience. The music, which I felt in my soul, added to the experience. Drinks were brought to the table, followed by elotes, Mexican street corn, and freshl...

$$ $$

4.70 (68 reviews) (~8.74 km from centre)

Taco Express Mexican Grill

Mexican restaurant

😐 Food was ok I liked the chicken birria (my first time trying), honey chicken bowl was good. Nachos was ok, very little bit in a big bowl. My family had steak birria they said was horrible compared to the ones they had before! Tacos was ok (good serving for price) Sodas were good. They had jarrit...

$ $$$

4.60 (714 reviews) (~5.15 km from centre)

Casa Margaritas Restaurant & Bar

Colombian restaurant

👍👍 My first visit here was amazing, the staff was very friendly and food was delicious! My favorite thing on the menu is the tamarind margarita, I will definitely be coming here again. 15/10!!! broke the darn scale!

$$ $$

4.60 (307 reviews) (~5.04 km from centre)

Guacamole Mexican Grill

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 Great food, Great staff.... We absolutely love the food here. The portions are great for the money. And now they are open 7 days a week... I would recommend this establishment to anyone looking for great authentic Mexican cuisine. And the dessert options are great too. Thanks guys for the consistenc...

$$ $$

4.60 (292 reviews) (~1.36 km from centre)

Tepache

Restaurant

👍👍 This restaurant donated a very generous gift certificate to St John's and I was the lucky winner. We will definitely return.

$$ $$

4.60 (177 reviews) (~4.68 km from centre)

Right Coast Taqueria Mineola

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 Oh my god! The Birria Tacos were SO AMAZING! The queso is out of this world! The staff was so kind and knowledgeable of the menu and the service was fantastic.

4.60 (78 reviews) (~5.53 km from centre)

TACOS Y MAS II INC

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 The food is PHENOMENAL! Wow. The owner or whoever was managing the front this morning made my experience so amazing. He gave me all these different sauces to try and the cilantro one I literally used every drop lmao. I love this place and will definitely be back!

$$ $$

4.60 (72 reviews) (~7.55 km from centre)

Charro Coliseum Tacos

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 I’m visiting from out of town. The tacos were delicious. I wish they were local.

$ $$$

4.60 (67 reviews) (~5.88 km from centre)

Besito

Mexican restaurant

Sophisticated spot serving inventive takes on Mexican classics in a dramatically decorated room.

$$ $$

4.50 (1.5K reviews) (~9.88 km from centre)

QDOBA Mexican Eats

Mexican restaurant

Simple Mexican counter-serve chain for burritos, tacos & more, including health-oriented options.

$ $$$

4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~8.88 km from centre)

Halal Mix

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 The food is amazingly fresh, tasty and the restaurant is the cleanest I’ve ever seen. I recommend the burrito bowl/salad bowl and quesadillas to everyone. You will not be disappointed. Nonetheless Philly steaks and shawarmas are surprisingly good too.

$ $$$

4.50 (289 reviews) (~4.94 km from centre)

Puerta Mexicana

Mexican restaurant

$$ $$

4.50 (282 reviews) (~8.17 km from centre)

Curbside Mexican Grill - South Hempstead

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 Found this place on Instagram and finally got to try it out and wow was I impressed with this place! A little hole in the wall type of place but the food is absolutely amazing! Everything that was ordered from the birria tacos to the birthday cake empanadas everything was full of flavor and I loved...

$$ $$

4.50 (231 reviews) (~4.83 km from centre)

Taquitos Grill

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 Went here for lunch since it’s close to my house and I know it will be quick, think I have ate from here once before but can’t remember it, so I went in hoping for the best and was delighted with everything, place was busy at lunchtime which is always a good sign, seems like a family run place, I ha...

$ $$$

4.50 (203 reviews) (~9.72 km from centre)

Tacos Mi Poblanita

Mexican restaurant

👍👍 I'm glad I don't live on long island anymore, I'd probably blow all my money at this place lol. Gotta say it's some of the best Mexican food I've had. Very quick service and good prices.

$ $$$

4.50 (186 reviews) (~6.12 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Mexican restaurants in Garden City South, United States