Top rated Bagel shops in Highland Park

Experience the best that Highland Park has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 356 places from Bagel shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Jersey Joe's Bagels & Deli image
1
Jersey Joe's Bagels & Deli
Bagel shop
👍👍 Been coming to Jersey Joes Bagels for a few weeks. Decided to take 4 bagels to go for a road trip. Wanted to try something different and Joe had me try a new bagel. Didn’t like it but I tried paying for the extra one. He kindly grabbed 3 more bagels and added it to my bag. The customer service goes...
5.00 (185 reviews) (~22.43 km from centre)
Bagel & Grill - Food · Smoke · Lotto image
2
Bagel & Grill - Food · Smoke · Lotto
Convenience store
👍👍 I went to this store for a bagel and I saw the option of Indian style omelette and bhurji on the menu. I decided to give it a try and now this place is my go-to breakfast spot on my commute. Not only was it quick but it lived up to my expectations of taste.
4.90 (35 reviews) (~3.46 km from centre)
Craft Bagel Co. image
3
Craft Bagel Co.
Bagel shop
👍👍 Limited street parking but turnover is quick. There are no seats. Service is quick and friendly. They have a clear system, easy to order. Online / phone orders are one side of the wall to the left of the entrance as soon as you walk in. Many bagels to choose from. Prices are posted clearly and re...
$ $$$
4.80 (159 reviews) (~20.97 km from centre)
Sunrise Creek Bagels & Deli image
4
Sunrise Creek Bagels & Deli
Bagel shop
$ $$$
4.80 (91 reviews) (~13.42 km from centre)
Old Time Bagels image
5
Old Time Bagels
Bagel shop
4.80 (72 reviews) (~21.6 km from centre)
Tommy's Bagels image
6
Tommy's Bagels
Bagel shop
😐 What is happening to my "go to" bagel place? On my last four visits the bagels are getting cake like and burned. I am not talking crispy they are truly way over cooked. Maybe a new baker or oven issues? Anyway Please fix so I can enjoy my favorite bagel once again!
$ $$$
4.70 (236 reviews) (~27.77 km from centre)
Lords Bagels image
7
Lords Bagels
Bagel shop
👍👍 Found them by chance on google maps after landing early at the airport. We were hungry and this was the closest from the car rental place. It’s a typical mom and pop joint that serves bagels and all your other stuff for breakfast that you can think of. We just had toasted onion bagels with butter wi...
$ $$$
4.70 (205 reviews) (~27.95 km from centre)
Bagel Garden image
8
Bagel Garden
Bagel shop
$ $$$
4.60 (505 reviews) (~23.88 km from centre)
Kosher Bagels Supreme image
9
Kosher Bagels Supreme
Bagel shop
👍👍 One of the best bagels in north jersey. My only complaint is that they need more spice on the everything bagel. But other than that, this is an excellent crispy outside to doughy inside ratio.
$ $$$
4.60 (442 reviews) (~24.81 km from centre)
Hightstown Hot Bagels image
10
Hightstown Hot Bagels
Bagel shop
👍👍 The best of the best. Just amazing service, bagels and the cream cheese is out of this world
$ $$$
4.60 (271 reviews) (~26.35 km from centre)
Manhattan Bagel image
11
Manhattan Bagel
Bagel shop
Counter-serve chain specializing in NYC-style bagels & coffee, plus salads, soups & sandwiches.
$ $$$
4.60 (261 reviews) (~11.45 km from centre)
Mikey Bagels image
12
Mikey Bagels
Bagel shop
$ $$$
4.60 (193 reviews) (~15.34 km from centre)
Holmdel Bagel Market image
13
Holmdel Bagel Market
Bagel shop
👍👍 All I can say is WOW. Visiting NJ recently and I wanted a real bagel. This place was recommended by my sister in the area and she was right. The egg on a bagel sandwich was more than delicious. So fresh and such a generous portion. The young woman at the counter was phenomenal! Smiling, efficient,...
$ $$$
4.60 (172 reviews) (~25.52 km from centre)
COPACABANA Coffee & Bagels image
14
COPACABANA Coffee & Bagels
Cafe
👍👍 WOW. Such a hidden gem! The owners are so kind and the bagels taste so fresh and fluffy. The veggie cream cheese was so good and the drinks were so fresh. The fresh orange juice was incredible, too. My friends and I are so glad we stopped by! Will totally be back. The menu is so big there’s so much...
$$ $$
4.60 (89 reviews) (~17.49 km from centre)
Crazy bagels image
15
Crazy bagels
Bagel shop
👍👍 Honestly I been here a couple of times and can’t stop going. The bagels are so fresh and there’s a variety of dinners to choose from. This place will not let you down and is definitely a 10/10!
4.60 (60 reviews) (~8.73 km from centre)
Bagel Factory Cafe - Aberdeen image
16
Bagel Factory Cafe - Aberdeen
Bagel shop
$ $$$
4.60 (51 reviews) (~20.13 km from centre)
Bagel Nosh image
17
Bagel Nosh
Bagel shop
Quaint, mom-&-pop counter serve offering a range of housemade bagels & schmears, plus sandwiches.
$ $$$
4.50 (422 reviews) (~1.64 km from centre)
Bagel Boys & Deli image
18
Bagel Boys & Deli
Bagel shop
😠 Been gettin bagels here on a weekly basis. Today got my usual order and found a roach in my 2nd sandwich. Hoping there was none in my first one.
$ $$$
4.50 (329 reviews) (~7.69 km from centre)
Roc's Café image
19
Roc's Café
Cafe
👍👍 Can’t get enough of this place. The iced latte is always robust and tasty. Whenever I get breakfast or lunch it’s always top tier, you can’t wrong. For 14$ the salmon is reasonably priced for the amount of food you get. The fruit tart and tres ledge cake is also worth trying, along with all the othe...
4.50 (295 reviews) (~27.79 km from centre)
Bagels & Beans image
20
Bagels & Beans
Bagel shop
👍 As a first time person here- it was hard to navigate around the place to order. It’s not a place that accommodates to new comers. I felt like everyone knew what they want, there’s no menus, no pricing, just a bagel shop, chips, and spreads all displayed. They did have some advertising in the front...
$ $$$
4.50 (270 reviews) (~24.14 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Highland Park

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )