Top rated Italian restaurants in Highland Park, United States to elevate your visit (Updated May, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Highland Park

Experience the best that Highland Park has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 20 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Highland Park

Lo Chiatto's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍 I didn't even know this place was there until a week ago. We decided to give it a shot based on the reviews. We were not disappointed. It isn't the best pizza we ever had but it's definitely a hidden gem for the area. The crust is great, sauce has good flavor, everything you want in a good pizza....

$ $$$

4.80 (132 reviews) (~4.43 km from centre)

Fresco Steak & Seafood Grill

Steak house

Eatery tucked away in a shopping plaza offering steak & seafood classics & a BYOB policy

$$ $$

4.50 (886 reviews) (~4.91 km from centre)

Edison Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

Longtime family-run spot with pizza, pasta & other hearty Italian classics in a brick-walled room.

$$ $$

4.50 (742 reviews) (~3.1 km from centre)

Catherine Lombardi

Italian restaurant

Upscale Italian restaurant with homey fare & 2 fireplaces plus a cozy red interior & lively bar.

$$$ $

4.40 (504 reviews) (~1.67 km from centre)

Maria's Pizza Milltown

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Today I picked up a party package from Maria's and I have to say that I couldn't have been more satisfied. Every dish was fresh and delicious. I appreciated that it wasn't salty which is something that happens often when I order out. We had never tried their food or pizza and I honestly was afraid b...

$ $$$

4.40 (395 reviews) (~4.86 km from centre)

Michelangelo's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Unpretentious eatery offering a classic menu of pizza, pasta & Italian entrees, plus cheesesteaks.

$$ $$

4.40 (227 reviews) (~3.95 km from centre)

Zia Lisa Pizzeria and Ristorante

Pizza restaurant

😠 Walked in and there was no variety of pizza whatsoever. There was one made that looked like it had been sitting for hours. Super disappointed. I cancelled my order because I'm not going to get sick. Waste of time. No drinks in the fridge. Place looks like it's not even in business.

$$ $$

4.40 (133 reviews) (~2.62 km from centre)

Cucina Mandreucci at Edison Pizza

Italian restaurant

👍👍 The best Italian around. Plenty of vegetarian options. They cater all of our parties and holidays. Very easy to have anything made to order. You can bring vegan pepperoni or cheese and they will add to your pizza. Great service Nice family business.

$$ $$

4.40 (31 reviews) (~3.09 km from centre)

Mancini Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Family-run spot for Italian classics like pasta, plus Brooklyn-style pies & cheesesteaks.

$$ $$

4.30 (921 reviews) (~4.75 km from centre)

Pasquale Brick Oven Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Just stopped in on my lunch break to get a few slices. Very rarely do I buy lunch but I was unable to get my lunch packed before leaving this morning. I work 8-8 as a Physical Therapist Assistant and I had $10 left until payday, so I thought. I went to run my card and to my surprise, it was declined...

$$ $$

4.30 (341 reviews) (~4.6 km from centre)

Dusals Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Casual, BYOB eatery featuring specialty pizzas, calzones, garlic knot sliders & other Italian meals.

$$ $$

4.30 (334 reviews) (~4.23 km from centre)

Victoria's Tratta Italiano

Italian restaurant

👍 Formerly knows as Panico’s. Insides has been remodeled and it looked modern and nice but not everything has been updated. The menu has been changed, unfortunately the new menu has fewer selections. The service was slow, maybe short staffed. We had eggplant rollatini and shrimp and calamari fra d...

4.30 (81 reviews) (~1.64 km from centre)

TA-TA'S Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Basic pizza parlor offering specialty pies, wings, subs & burgers, along with vegan offerings.

$ $$$

4.20 (151 reviews) (~2.52 km from centre)

Filippo's Famous Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Enduring counter serve doling out oversized thin-crust slices & pies, plus subs & pasta, since 1972.

$ $$$

4.10 (376 reviews) (~1.66 km from centre)

Frank's Pizza & Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Excellent. Food is awesome. Tops taste. Place gets packed. Update*** 3/19/23 pizza was tops as always. Take a looksie ***update*** 08/30/23 excellent pizza yet again

$$ $$

4.10 (189 reviews) (~4.59 km from centre)

Panico's Restaurant & Bar w/ Brick Oven Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Italian restaurant & bar specializing in brick-oven pizza, plus pasta dinners, sandwiches & salads.

$$ $$

4.00 (494 reviews) (~1.64 km from centre)

Nicola's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Every pizza place I’ve tried cannot get this right until this place comes along. Ordered a well done thin pizza. Got exactly just that. Also ordered chicken fingers which were perfect. Best honey mustard. Sauce was great, perfect thickness, cheese and seasoning was on point. I’m from NY and have had...

$ $$$

3.90 (151 reviews) (~3.87 km from centre)

Giovanneli's Pizza & Grill

Pizza restaurant

Unfussy counter-service shop serving pizza, wings, burgers & hearty sandwiches until 4 AM.

$ $$$

3.80 (383 reviews) (~2.13 km from centre)

Mozzarella Italian & Mexican Cucina

Italian restaurant

😠 0 stars for this place.Not worth the time, gas, money, or thought. I tried to have a nice dinner with my family for my brothers graduation. It took over 45 minutes to be seated even though I had a reservation, I watched as other tables were seated before my party of four. I had a reservation for 9 a...

$$ $$

3.80 (192 reviews) (~2.63 km from centre)

Sbarro

Pizza restaurant

Italian fast-food chain offering thin-crust pizza by the slice, plus pastas & salads.

$ $$$

2.70 (46 reviews) (~3.26 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Highland Park, United States