Top rated Jewelry stores in Holtsville

Experience the best that Holtsville has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 65 places from Jewelry store category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Keepsake Diamonds Corp. image
1
Keepsake Diamonds Corp.
Jewelry store
👍👍 You cannot go wrong shopping at Keepsake. John, the owner, is so incredibly knowledgeable you’ll feel like you learn something new every time you visit there. He was able to fix my engagement ring…not only fix the problem with the setting but give me the proper setting I should have had all along. H...
5.00 (121 reviews) (~20.7 km from centre)
Starflower Jewelry image
2
Starflower Jewelry
Jeweler
👍👍 Absolutely 10 stars! The customer service Cait gives along with the entire team is astounding.. something you truly don’t see anymore. Pleasant atmosphere, honest, good prices, amazing work! My neckless in picture broke from only a month of wearing it. I walked in expecting it to be soldered back to...
5.00 (115 reviews) (~28.45 km from centre)
Guru's image
3
Guru's
Metaphysical supply store
5.00 (83 reviews) (~9.48 km from centre)
Amore Fine Jewelry image
4
Amore Fine Jewelry
Jewelry store
👍👍 Phil is the absolute best at what he does! I’ve purchased several pieces from him including my fiancés engagement ring and every time he knocks it out of the park. If you are looking for a great deal, great product and great service Amore is your place for all your jewelry needs!
5.00 (57 reviews) (~23.81 km from centre)
Ricky Jewelry image
5
Ricky Jewelry
Jewelry store
👍👍 Ricky is AMAZING!! My husband and I have been going to him for YEARS!! He is honest and reasonable and always goes ABOVE and BEYOND for his customers! If you are looking for something specific he goes out of his way to get it for you. He is trustworthy and his jewelry is TOP NOTCH!! I can’t say enou...
4.90 (709 reviews) (~9.47 km from centre)
Elegant Jewelry image
6
Elegant Jewelry
Jeweler
Long-running store providing jewelry, watches & custom designs, plus repair services & appraisals.
4.90 (565 reviews) (~4.6 km from centre)
Kay Cameron Jewelers image
7
Kay Cameron Jewelers
Jewelry store
Family-owned site with fashion-forward, designer jewelry collections, plus custom designs & repairs.
4.90 (397 reviews) (~9.43 km from centre)
The Gold Source Inc. image
8
The Gold Source Inc.
Jewelry store
👍👍 Stan is the MAN! I stumbled upon this jeweler online and I am so glad I went in! He helped me go through a few options and I landed a beautiful 14k solid cuban chain. Stan is extremely transparent and very patient with the customer, which is something I needed as I've never been to a jewler before!...
4.90 (63 reviews) (~23.66 km from centre)
L.I. Gold Mine Jewelers - Long Island, New York image
9
L.I. Gold Mine Jewelers - Long Island, New York
Jewelry store
👍👍 I visited LI Gold Mine just to look around and get some ideas for an engagement ring for my girlfriend. After talking to Serge and Marie for 10 minutes and looking at others positive reviews and experiences, I left the down payment for an engagement ring that same day! When my now Fiancée saw the cu...
4.90 (59 reviews) (~13.73 km from centre)
Zales Outlet image
10
Zales Outlet
Jewelry store
4.90 (40 reviews) (~29.93 km from centre)
Exotic Jewelry image
11
Exotic Jewelry
Jewelry store
👍👍 Igor is an amazing jeweler. He is very informative and wants to make sure you don’t overpay for jewelry. I brought a 2 pendant, a custom ring, and earrings all for under a price I paid for a ring elsewhere with higher cut diamonds. Loving my new jewelry and my new favorite place.
4.90 (34 reviews) (~12.84 km from centre)
Amulet Arts INC image
12
Amulet Arts INC
Body piercing shop
👍👍 This is by far the absolute best piercing experience I've ever had. I got my nose done a few months ago and the healing process has been insanely quick. This was my third time having to get it pierced so I would know. The actual piercing session was very fast, professional and super clean. Kaspa was...
4.80 (291 reviews) (~6.12 km from centre)
Willy Nilly Trading Company image
13
Willy Nilly Trading Company
Gift shop
👍👍 Willy Nilly is my go to for gifts, all year and especially at Christmas time!!
4.80 (157 reviews) (~20.38 km from centre)
Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop image
14
Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop
Flea market
👍👍 Fabulous people, Jay and Pat are like meeting up with old friends. Shop is jam packed of great finds and you won't leave empty handed and you'll get a great deal, too. Highly recommend.
4.80 (69 reviews) (~5.38 km from centre)
Funky Town Collectibles image
15
Funky Town Collectibles
Trading card store
👍👍 Friendly staff and really good prices. They are full of smiles and will give a good deal on anything you buy. A positive place. Highly recommended!
4.80 (43 reviews) (~6.35 km from centre)
Harborview Jewelers image
16
Harborview Jewelers
Jewelry store
😠 Had a restoration of a ring done at Harborview Jewelers. The result after spending $650? Incredibly sloppy prongs, a cockeyed center stone with a chipped girdle, and increased porosity in the gold from solder overflow. Not to mention the fact that the jeweler HEAT-SOLDERED the prongs around a rar...
4.80 (32 reviews) (~27.06 km from centre)
Ronny's Jewelry image
17
Ronny's Jewelry
Jewelry store
😠 Trusted this place a couple times thinking I was getting what I was told. Purchased a bracelet a while back and wanted to sale. I had it appraised by another jeweler who told me the diamonds in the bracelet were all cloudy and different not VS1 like Ronny stated. I tried to trade the piece in and wa...
4.70 (217 reviews) (~6.09 km from centre)
Ethan Jordan Jewelers image
18
Ethan Jordan Jewelers
Jewelry store
😠 Buyer beware for FAKES. Let me start off the by saying I am in no way trying to bash Ethan Jordon Jewlers. As you will see they currently have about 80 5 star reviews. I just want to explain what happened in our situation. My husband bought me a beautiful 925 white sapphire tennis bracelet For Chris...
4.70 (168 reviews) (~9.02 km from centre)
Argyle Jewelers image
19
Argyle Jewelers
Jewelry store
Family-owned retailer offering brandname & custom jewelry for adults & children since 1988.
4.70 (72 reviews) (~26.68 km from centre)
D'Ore Jewelry image
20
D'Ore Jewelry
Jewelry store
Shopping-center outpost for diamond, bridal & gemstone jewelry, plus watches, repairs & appraisals.
4.70 (60 reviews) (~19.25 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Holtsville

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )