Hidden gems - Consignment shops in Indianapolis, United States not to miss (Updated March, 2024)

Hidden gems: Consignment shops in Indianapolis

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Indianapolis. This list contains 91 places from Consignment shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Indianapolis

Prospect Jewelers

Jewelry designer

👍👍 They took care of some maintenance on my wedding rings. They look better than ever! Highly recommend.

5.00 (69 reviews) (~165.17 km from centre)

The Clothes Boutique

Consignment shop

5.00 (53 reviews) (~171.15 km from centre)

Traditional Arts Today

Non-profit organization

👍👍 This is a hidden gem in Ferdinand! The staff is the best - welcoming, friendly and willing to help with all your needs! They have the most unique gifts for every occasion. Be on the lookout for their classes too - my son participated in a Christmas ceramic class that he loved! I’d highly recommend!

5.00 (45 reviews) (~182.22 km from centre)

Jacob James

Fashion accessories store

👍👍 What an amazing store! The staff is attentive, kind and willing to go above and beyond for their clients needs. This stores concept is most certainly filling a void in this city! Thank you for offering such a fantastic store to Hyde Park! Ps. Don’t be intimidated by the parking! The meters allow yo...

5.00 (29 reviews) (~163.02 km from centre)

Renew Consignment

Consignment shop

👍👍 The owner and staff were so warm and welcoming. A beautiful space with lovely finds both modern and vintage. Was in town on a family getaway and it was the perfect stop on our trip. We slipped in just an hour before closing and everyone was so kind and not at all eager to rush us out even when we re...

5.00 (27 reviews) (~225.07 km from centre)

Renewed Designs

Boutique

👍👍 I visited Renewed Designs just yesterday and it’s beautiful! There are so many pieces to choose from. Anything from a variety of purses, jewelry, and clothing to purchase. I love the bench placed especially for husbands to wait while we ladies shop. Well worth the visit and I will definitely be goin...

5.00 (25 reviews) (~78.53 km from centre)

Style Threads Resale& Boutique

Clothing store

5.00 (21 reviews) (~19.48 km from centre)

Mood

Thrift store

👍👍 I've been into most of the local thrifty places, and Mood will absolutely be added to the rotation. This place is a gem. Incredibly curated selection of oddities, cute clothes, books and so much more. As if that's not enough, the prices are fantastic. It seems like vintage and thrift shop prices are...

5.00 (18 reviews) (~170.07 km from centre)

KidStuff Sale

Consignment shop

5.00 (13 reviews) (~157.98 km from centre)

Maggie's of Ohio

Consignment shop

5.00 (10 reviews) (~135.89 km from centre)

Recycled Westside

Consignment shop

5.00 (7 reviews) (~137.05 km from centre)

SL Consignment Gallery

Antique store

5.00 (7 reviews) (~229.6 km from centre)

Bradley’s Boutique & Haberdashery

Boutique

5.00 (6 reviews) (~240.91 km from centre)

Next Level Consignment

Consignment shop

👍👍 Always have the new stock and the best deals. I never leave empty handed. Love this place😍

5.00 (5 reviews) (~224.67 km from centre)

Hippies Closet

Clothing store

👍👍 I shop at hippies closet since years and every time I wear one of her item, I get so many compliments! Clothes and shoes are like new or new with tags. I also bought hats, purses and earrings… all for half of the price I would buy in a boutique! Highly recommend! Also the customer service is top not...

4.90 (76 reviews) (~20.38 km from centre)

David Fair on the Square & David Fair Interiors

Consignment shop

4.90 (57 reviews) (~169.46 km from centre)

Family Tree Consignment

Consignment shop

👍👍 This is a nice little shop. Prices aren't to bad. I found the cutest kitchen table and chairs for my kitchen here.

4.90 (46 reviews) (~206.38 km from centre)

Fraction Apparel & Home

Consignment shop

4.90 (45 reviews) (~136.62 km from centre)

Personal Touch Sewing & Dress Boutique

Clothing alteration service

4.90 (41 reviews) (~243.11 km from centre)

Bellazo

Clothing store

4.90 (40 reviews) (~117.87 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Consignment shops in Indianapolis, United States