Top rated American restaurants in McHenry

Experience the best that McHenry has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 312 places from American restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Finger Foods image
1
Finger Foods
American restaurant
👍👍 I LOVE IT HERE, I just recently moved here this is now my go to spot!!! It was so good I had to come back to back!! Never a disservice, always great food. The vibes, the music, the taste, everything was there!I ended up paying no more than $20 each time.
$$ $$
4.90 (180 reviews) (~52.25 km from centre)
JJ's Diner & Deli image
2
JJ's Diner & Deli
American restaurant
👍👍 Little place off the beaten path with so many 5 star reviews, we had to try it. Its a historic building with a cool story the owner shared with us. Food is all fresh and super reasonably priced. We had 2 of the specials, the reuben and the steak & cheese. Each $8.99 including a choice of fries...
$ $$$
4.90 (90 reviews) (~74.9 km from centre)
Speals Off Wheels image
3
Speals Off Wheels
American restaurant
👍👍 You've got to stop here and try the food! The beer battered onion rings are awesome, everything comes in big portions, tastes great, like I said, you gotta stop and try it!!!
$$ $$
4.90 (56 reviews) (~93.12 km from centre)
Heidi's Bakery & Cafe image
4
Heidi's Bakery & Cafe
American restaurant
👍👍 A place that you have to stop in at if you are anywhere close! Thanks to all for being very accommodating to a big family group!
$ $$$
4.80 (288 reviews) (~25.65 km from centre)
Lot 12 Public House Inc. image
5
Lot 12 Public House Inc.
American restaurant
Refined, seasonal New American fare, plus selected wines, served in an elegant 1913 home.
$$$ $
4.80 (284 reviews) (~96.64 km from centre)
Guesthouse Lost River image
6
Guesthouse Lost River
Guest house
Lodge-like restaurant & inn featuring cozy, rustic rooms & suites with quilt-covered beds.
4.80 (179 reviews) (~82.9 km from centre)
Chuck Wagon Restaurant image
7
Chuck Wagon Restaurant
American restaurant
👍👍 If you like soup, salad, and sandwich, this is the place for you. Very good food, a hefty portion, and a good price. The ambience lives up to the name. It feels like you are eating at a chuckwagon. The simple atmosphere was refreshing from a cluttered world. The steak sandwich had a delicious smokey...
4.80 (126 reviews) (~55.52 km from centre)
Piccolo Paula’s Caffé image
8
Piccolo Paula’s Caffé
American restaurant
😐 3.5 stars here. while on a road trip through the area to do some genealogy for my wife's family we arrived in Parsons WV and came upon Paula's. so we chose to have our lunch there. unique, funky decor and very sweet folks running the place. Paula gave us all the details we needed on the menu and the...
$ $$$
4.80 (94 reviews) (~58.49 km from centre)
The Outpost River's Edge Eatery image
9
The Outpost River's Edge Eatery
American restaurant
4.80 (92 reviews) (~80.94 km from centre)
Jeff's Ultimate Grill image
10
Jeff's Ultimate Grill
American restaurant
👍👍 I recently had the pleasure of stopping at this very unique grill. Yeah it might be a little stand right off the highway but I had the best burger and pepper poppers in the area. I went with the Patty Melt which was perfect. Everything about it was amazing from the buttery, perfectly toasted Texas...
$ $$$
4.80 (89 reviews) (~85.95 km from centre)
Rt.250 Corner Cafe image
11
Rt.250 Corner Cafe
American restaurant
4.80 (73 reviews) (~95.75 km from centre)
The Grand Slam Grill image
12
The Grand Slam Grill
American restaurant
4.80 (57 reviews) (~59.12 km from centre)
Top Dawg, LLC image
13
Top Dawg, LLC
American restaurant
4.80 (41 reviews) (~38.16 km from centre)
By George image
14
By George
Greek restaurant
👍 Had chicken and shrimp, very good. Standard baked potato and honey glazed carrots. Loved the carrots. Service was great, prompt and attentive. Berkshire chop, delicious
$$ $$
4.70 (903 reviews) (~80.11 km from centre)
Dutchman's Daughter Restaurant image
15
Dutchman's Daughter Restaurant
American restaurant
😠 I was very disappointed with this restaurant. I did love the small town feel and appearance of it and I was excited to try the food. I had the a Italian chicken pasta salad which came with a ton of mozzarella cheese and garlic bread. So the pasta was really cold not even warm and the garlic bread w...
$ $$$
4.70 (743 reviews) (~73.08 km from centre)
The Kitchen On Main/Kitchen Wine Cellar/ Kitchen Pantry image
16
The Kitchen On Main/Kitchen Wine Cellar/ Kitchen Pantry
American restaurant
Comfy, minimalist BYOB space with an open kitchen, chef's counter & a varied international menu.
$$ $$
4.70 (522 reviews) (~76.73 km from centre)
Zala's Cafe image
17
Zala's Cafe
American restaurant
$$ $$
4.70 (353 reviews) (~84.27 km from centre)
McAteer's Restaurant image
18
McAteer's Restaurant
American restaurant
👍👍 Ate here a couple months back. The place may look like a bit of a dump on the surface, but trust me, it's not. Nothing mind-blowing, but a solid diner with tasty homestyle cooking, more-than-adequate portions, and friendly staff. Would recommend if you're in the area!
$ $$$
4.70 (345 reviews) (~70.06 km from centre)
Road Kill Cafe and Cabins image
19
Road Kill Cafe and Cabins
American restaurant
👍👍 Hi there. Me and some of my m/c brothers stop in to eat here Saturday. I have heard in the pass that their food is excellent. So I suggested we stop. I had a hot turkey sandwich with fries. It was excellent. Turkey taste like it was just cook. All my brothers love their food and also said everything...
$ $$$
4.70 (313 reviews) (~82.95 km from centre)
Donges Drive-In and Motel image
20
Donges Drive-In and Motel
American restaurant
👍👍 Stayed here & ate breakfast here on our GAP trail ride. As I ate my excellent Western omelet it occurred to me I can taste everything in it; might sound silly but I couldn’t remember ever having that thought before. The peppers, onions, and tomatoes were all flavorful and distinctly noticeable, and...
4.70 (296 reviews) (~39.89 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near McHenry

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )