Top rated Diamond dealers in Milwaukee, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Diamond dealers in Milwaukee

Experience the best that Milwaukee has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 27 places from Diamond dealer category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Milwaukee

The Jewelry Center

Jewelry store

👍👍 The staff is amazing. We were able to design our own rings. They did it on our schedule (3 weeks) and stayed as close to our budget as they could. I highly recommend The Jewelry Center.

5.00 (934 reviews) (~16.52 km from centre)

The Jewelry Center

Jewelry store

👍👍 Had a watch repaired at The Jewelry Center and they did a Excellent job of repairing it. Plus they have Fabulous Jewelry. I was like a kid in a Candy Store. And Mike the Store Manager was nice and quoted me a decent price for a Blue Topaz Necklace. Jewelry Lovers Kind Of Store.

4.90 (2.7K reviews) (~10.93 km from centre)

Kesslers Diamonds - Greenfield

Jewelry store

👍👍 Since buying our engagement & wedding bands 20 years ago, I've had many complimentary services from the Greenfield location, including resizing my ring smaller well over a decade ago to now just this month again resizing it a whole size up to fit over my knuckle. I was in shock at how brand new my...

4.90 (1.7K reviews) (~11.5 km from centre)

Kesslers Diamonds - Germantown

Jewelry store

👍👍 I cannot recommend Kesslers enough! Sure their guarantee is great - best I’ve ever seen - but what really makes them stand out is their people! Their attention to detail is unmatched and they will always go above and beyond to make sure we are beyond satisfied everything we walk out their door! If I...

4.90 (1.2K reviews) (~23.79 km from centre)

Kesslers Diamonds - Brookfield

Jewelry store

4.90 (1K reviews) (~16.69 km from centre)

Kesslers Diamonds Downtown Milwaukee

Jewelry store

👍👍 My husband and I have had nothing but a wonderful experience working with everyone at Kesslers. We purchased both my engagement ring and wedding band here. Customers are always greeted warmly with a smile when you come in and their so helpful with any and all questions! Highly recommend!

4.90 (299 reviews) (~1.48 km from centre)

Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers

Jewelry store

Enduring full-service jewelry shop featuring engagement rings, fine watches & designer collections.

4.90 (271 reviews) (~9.37 km from centre)

J.P. Haase Jewelers

Jewelry store

Classic, long-running showroom for engagement rings, fine jewelry & custom design work.

4.90 (221 reviews) (~10.39 km from centre)

Harry Glinberg Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 Harry, the owner of the store was down to earth and his team was very accommodating. Glinberg Jewelers will be my first stop for anything jewelry related going forward. Thank you!

4.90 (142 reviews) (~10.85 km from centre)

Lampone Jewelers Inc

Jeweler

👍👍 It was AMAZING! I got my wife's engagement ring here and I tell everyone I know to go to Lampone. They worked with me to create a custom ring and in the end it came back better than I thought! It's a great local spot to go for all of your jewelry needs.

4.90 (60 reviews) (~14.08 km from centre)

Kloiber Jewelers

Jeweler

Store selling fashion & wedding jewelry since 1926. Design & repair services are also available.

4.90 (56 reviews) (~1.7 km from centre)

Diamonds Direct Milwaukee

Jewelry store

Upscale boutique providing designer jewelry, including custom engagement rings & loose diamonds.

4.90 (45 reviews) (~10.71 km from centre)

Jared

Jewelry store

Chain retailer offering a huge selection of fine jewelry, including diamond wedding rings & watches.

$$$ $

4.80 (915 reviews) (~15.45 km from centre)

International Gold & Silver Buyers

Jewelry buyer

😠 The guy was a completely rude and unprofessional as soon as I walked in I was greeted with “what’d you want” I asked him if he buys used jewelry (because that’s what it says on the sign) which he replied it depends what do you have and before he even looked at what I said he said nope don’t want it...

4.80 (303 reviews) (~5.42 km from centre)

Sullivan Jewelers

Jewelry store

Diamond wedding rings, brand-name watches & other fine accessories, plus custom design & repairs.

4.80 (95 reviews) (~16.91 km from centre)

Cival Collective

Jewelry store

👍👍 I went shopping with a girlfriend after getting brunch in Walker’s Point. We had an amazing shopping experience at this amazing boutique. From the moment we walked in, the staff was accommodating and followed safety protocols. There are so many unique treasures to find and so reasonably/fair priced...

4.80 (61 reviews) (~1.32 km from centre)

Mid Continental Gems

Jeweler

👍👍 Mid Continental Gems worked with my fiancé to customize the most perfect engagement ring! Great customer service and above exceptional quality for jewelry. Very friendly and welcoming environment- they ensure that you are positively happy with your jewelry.

4.80 (38 reviews) (~13.63 km from centre)

Robert Haack Diamond Importers

Jeweler

👍👍 This is the only place I would sell my jewelry. They are fair and honest. You don’t have to waste your time running around for quotes. They are always going to give you market value. PLUS, amazing customer service, beverages, snacks, and when I was done. A gift! Thank you Dawn and Becky.

4.70 (330 reviews) (~10.9 km from centre)

JRS Jewelry Repair Shop

Gold dealer

👍👍 As a younger person the opportunity or need to sell precious jewelry has only presented itself 3 times. The first was over a decade ago here at JRSi entered intimidated, and naïve without a clue what a good price would be & left not knowing if I had gotten a fair deal yet satisfied that I was treate...

4.70 (86 reviews) (~6.88 km from centre)

Tobin Jewelers - New Berlin

Jewelry store

👍👍 I went to Tobin for an engagement ring not knowing much about diamonds and settings. The person who helped me, I would later find out he was the owner, literally spent hours helping me pick the right ring. I had gone to 2 other stores before and felt like they didn't have time for me. I had such a g...

4.70 (56 reviews) (~16.24 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Diamond dealers in Milwaukee, United States