Hidden gems - Consignment shops in New York City, United States not to miss (Updated April, 2024)

Hidden gems: Consignment shops in New York City

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York City. This list contains 25 places from Consignment shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York City

Bronze Robot Estate Sales

Estate liquidator

5.00 (20 reviews) (~12.81 km from centre)

Guten Parts + Storage

Auto parts store

👍👍 Guten P&S is one of the last remaining gems within a dying breed of independent providers of classic European car service and parts. They have developed themselves into being a staple within the Euro industry for being a source of parts, service, and assistance. Levent is a shining ambassador for t...

4.90 (97 reviews) (~23.73 km from centre)

Lucky Finds Boutique

Boutique

👍👍 Moved into RVC and so glad to have such a trendy consignment store down the block where I can find unique items at a very good price. I've seen the owner be very helpful to others as well, pulling together cool outfits. It's not just clothing, it's jewelry, shoes and some VERY nice designer handbag...

4.90 (50 reviews) (~30.08 km from centre)

Cash 4 Gold Trading Post

Pawn shop

4.90 (41 reviews) (~47.48 km from centre)

E Designer Resale

Consignment shop

👍👍 Bought a beautiful, almost new, Louis Vuitton! It was my first & I love it! The owner is quite lovely & was very helpful & courteous to me. I went in , wearing pajamas & got treated the same as the woman wearing the expensive coat. I had been eyeing the Louis for some time & am glad every time I see...

4.90 (10 reviews) (~8.82 km from centre)

Trilogy Consignment

Consignment shop

😠 I have never seen a business with a poorer business model. All the personnel seem to be on some kind of “high horse.” There’s a way to deal with the public, which they obviously haven’t learned yet. The person who “judges” your items to be left for consignment has an attitude and succeeds in making...

4.80 (61 reviews) (~37.68 km from centre)

LUXE Luxury Labels

Consignment shop

4.80 (11 reviews) (~47.52 km from centre)

Rons Buy Sell Trade Handbags Sneakers for Cash

Consignment shop

4.70 (94 reviews) (~12.86 km from centre)

Wow! That's Unusual!

Thrift store

4.70 (54 reviews) (~43.27 km from centre)

Cash 4 Gold Trading Post

Pawn shop

👍👍 Very reasonable and friendly. They give the best price in town. Definitely try them first and don’t confuse them with neighboring shops.

4.70 (47 reviews) (~48.44 km from centre)

Pearl St. Consignment and Custom Clothes

Consignment shop

👍👍 Lovers of '90s and early '00s fashion will love this shop. If you're a fan of "Clueless," Courtney Love, Gwen Stefani and other rock and pop divas, you'll be in heaven. Great selection of women's clothes (some men's too) as well as shoes (platforms galore) and some accessories. Excellent curation an...

4.70 (40 reviews) (~45.25 km from centre)

Style on Lafayette

Consignment shop

4.70 (29 reviews) (~43.16 km from centre)

HEADQUARTERS

Shoe store

👍👍 Probably the best store outside the city, had way more stock than any other shop with way better prices than anywhere I’ve seen. Plenty of size 14s in stock. Great music, good vibes, very knowledgeable. Copped a pair of Reimagined WC 3s, had to wear them out the store. Shoutout to HQ!

4.70 (29 reviews) (~38.71 km from centre)

Worth Repeating

Consignment shop

😐 A claustrophobic mess of a store. It’s like digging through the closet of your messiest hoarder sister who happens to like fashion. There are some finds to be made, for sure, but be prepared to try on clothes in the open because there is no dressing room. Owner even has trouble finding things! Not f...

4.70 (23 reviews) (~31.26 km from centre)

The Emperors Old Clothes

Consignment shop

4.70 (7 reviews) (~25.92 km from centre)

Gentlemen's Resale

Consignment shop

High-end consignment shop stocking designer clothing, shoes & accessories for men.

$$ $$

4.60 (81 reviews) (~3.5 km from centre)

Cottontails Children's Consignment

Consignment shop

👍👍 The best place for baby clothes and gear! Very well organized, great prices, friendly workers. There's a maternity section and I've seen really nice bassinets here, too. I've also found some of my favorite shoes for myself -- they have a great selection.

4.60 (77 reviews) (~49.12 km from centre)

Designer Exchange

Consignment shop

😠 Some prices were good and some you were better off buying new. Downfall was very racist. The owner told the Staff to follow me and my family and she said it loud enough for all to hear. It also is final sale. We left and went to the actual store where they were new and the prices were good.

4.60 (39 reviews) (~41.09 km from centre)

Erbys Elite Repeat

Consignment shop

4.60 (13 reviews) (~46.48 km from centre)

Gingerbread Consignment Shop

Consignment shop

4.60 (11 reviews) (~29.85 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Consignment shops in New York City, United States