Hidden gems - Cottage rentals in New York City, United States not to miss (Updated April, 2024)

Hidden gems: Cottage rentals in New York City

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York City. This list contains 12 places from Cottage rental category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York City

The Hideaway Beach Rental

Vacation home rental agency

👍👍 I will not be able to say enough about The Hideaway. Absolutely loved it. The place was immaculate and private.. Comfortable and cozy. The patio was beautiful ! A stone's throw to the ocean and the Pier (only a 2 min walk to the sea wall). Has everything you need...better then a hotel!Thanks for the...

5.00 (31 reviews) (~224.14 km from centre)

Sylvania Tree Farm

Campground

👍👍 Our camping experience at Sylvania Tree Farm was absolutely superb. The campsite felt secluded, even though there were occupied sites nearby (far enough away that we couldn't hear the other groups and they were visually naturally blocked by trees). A huge perk of the site was the clean, well stock...

4.90 (66 reviews) (~123.91 km from centre)

GoshenSummerRentals.com

Cottage rental

4.90 (41 reviews) (~212.43 km from centre)

Lake View Lodge Vacation Rental

Cottage rental

👍👍 We had an awesome time at the lodge during our ski trip. It was very comfortable, with everything we needed for a weekend with friends and family. The Blue Mountain was great and just minutes away, and we had fun playing foosball and hanging out at night by the fire place. Will definitely be back so...

4.90 (9 reviews) (~136.13 km from centre)

Countryside Cottages

Cottage rental

👍👍 Price is reasonable. Quiet area, close to all the Malls and major roads. The Cabins have all what you need to cook and the too.s are spacious. I just love staying here it is so private

4.80 (110 reviews) (~113.14 km from centre)

The May Caper

Cottage rental

4.80 (5 reviews) (~217.44 km from centre)

J & S Reeve Cottages

Vacation home rental agency

👍👍 Everyone has certainly done justice to this great vacation spot. We would just like to add, for the vegetable lovers of the world, that there are almost as many farm stands nearby as there are wineries. Each has its own personality and the produce is fresh out of the local gardens. A real treat! Al...

4.70 (57 reviews) (~117.05 km from centre)

Thyme in the Country Cottages

Cottage rental

19th-century farmhouse B&B on 5-acre farm with a seasonal pool, WiFi & free farm-sourced breakfast.

4.70 (39 reviews) (~168.5 km from centre)

Sandy Hook Beach Cottages

Cottage rental

👍👍 Sandy Hook Beach Cottages were an amazing home away from home for me and my daughter! The cottages were clean and comfortable. The private beach was the perfect spot to enjoy the bay! Jenniffer and Dennis were wonderful hosts that made us feel like family in the cozy little community. Can't wait to...

4.70 (15 reviews) (~38.5 km from centre)

Oxoboxo Lake Cottage

Cottage rental

😠 I was very interested in inquiring about a vacation rental for my son and myself. However, the owner indicated we would not be able to preview as its private property. When I explained that my son is a big fisherman but also special needs and it would be great if I could preview the lake beforehan...

4.60 (20 reviews) (~169.98 km from centre)

Save River Cottage LLC

Cabin rental agency

4.60 (10 reviews) (~187.37 km from centre)

Beach Plum Farm Cottages

Cottage rental

😠 Farm to table dinner was horrible and extremely expensive. If you are not able to provide culinary meals please do not schedule sittings in October. Radishes seemed to be the primary food choice for 3 courses. The Meatball and pork were not cooked completely. Staff was pleasant. Just a bad expe...

4.50 (60 reviews) (~217.34 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Cottage rentals in New York City, United States