Hidden gems - Ice cream shops in New York, United States not to miss (Updated December, 2023)

Hidden gems: Ice cream shops in New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York. This list contains 186 places from Ice cream shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Bora Bora Smoothie Cafe - Staten Island Hylan Blvd

Cafe

👍👍 really calming atmosphere, foods to die for honestly amazing. Love the Turkey croffle.

$ $$$

5.00 (121 reviews) (~14.29 km from centre)

Only Rare NYC

Ice cream shop

👍👍 The rolled ice cream here is awesome. They gotta step they spoon game up though, I need a stronger spoon than them flimsy plastic ones🤷🏽‍♂️👍🏾

5.00 (114 reviews) (~17.82 km from centre)

US Mr Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

5.00 (109 reviews) (~81.38 km from centre)

Sweet Parlor Ice Cream Shop

Ice cream shop

$ $$$

5.00 (107 reviews) (~61.15 km from centre)

Robin’s Creamery

Ice cream shop

5.00 (95 reviews) (~49.54 km from centre)

Surreal Creamery

Ice cream shop

$$ $$

5.00 (91 reviews) (~47.67 km from centre)

Wandering Sweets

Ice cream shop

👍👍 I wish that there were more stars to give because this place deserves every single one that it can possibly receive. From the moment that we walked in, we were overwhelmed with the sense of sweetness in every way possible. The manager clearly loves what she does and how she does it and that love ref...

5.00 (84 reviews) (~63.03 km from centre)

Atelier BE Chocolat

Chocolate artisan

5.00 (77 reviews) (~79.59 km from centre)

Amai Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Amazing rolled ice cream! Amazing atmosphere. The fudge nut was spectacular. Highly recommend coming here with the family and having a good time and some good ice cream! 100% coming back

$$ $$

5.00 (65 reviews) (~26.3 km from centre)

The Sugar Shack Ice Cream LLC

Ice cream shop

5.00 (65 reviews) (~89.7 km from centre)

Team Dadzie Patisserie

Pastry shop

5.00 (56 reviews) (~26.14 km from centre)

ICE CAPPS

Ice cream shop

👍👍 After growing up in Brooklyn, and having had the best ices anywhere, either Ices Queen or a local pizza store, I was rarely disappointed. In Orange County, My go to ices became Ice cups from the supermarket, and I only liked the bottom. Colleen is the sweetest and so pretty, and what a wonderful Dad...

5.00 (48 reviews) (~89.11 km from centre)

SCOOP & COFFEE

Ice cream shop

👍👍 ice cream and coffee are great, environment is friendly and welcoming! definitely will go back!

5.00 (44 reviews) (~44.03 km from centre)

The Happy Birthday Kafe’ & Catering

Soul food restaurant

👍👍 I have no idea when this opened but all I can say is wow. If you’re ever in the mood for sweet fried snacks this is the place to go. We tried the fried Oreos and banana pudding. Holy moly. Can’t do this too much but definitely once in a while 😇most of their foods are some sort of fried sweet treat....

$ $$$

5.00 (36 reviews) (~29.22 km from centre)

Ant & Andy's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

5.00 (31 reviews) (~44.99 km from centre)

The Green House Cafe & Gallery

Deli

👍👍 Excellent family friendly place to get a delicious gourmet sandwich at a reasonable price. If you like value you will love this place. Expertly crafted gourmet sandwiches Salads and other goodies with quality ingredients and attention to detail to the T. A plus to Middletown and surrounding are...

$ $$$

5.00 (27 reviews) (~98.18 km from centre)

The One Bakery

Cake shop

👍👍 Ordered the fresh cream cake with strawberry filling for a birthday last week- compliments all around from the guests! The delivery driver through door dash was unresponsive but I called the shop and she had a back up plan in case the cake didn’t show! Really thankful for how helpful she was!

5.00 (26 reviews) (~28.82 km from centre)

Rebecca's Cupboard

Ice cream shop

5.00 (20 reviews) (~85.89 km from centre)

Häagen-Dazs

Ice cream shop

$$ $$

5.00 (12 reviews) (~22.27 km from centre)

Village Sundaes

Ice cream shop

👍👍 We live out of state, but were passing through town and decided to stop for ice cream. Everything was delicious and the sizing was very generous and the pricing was more than fair. Two of us are gluten free and all GF items were clearly labeled and they even had GF cones which made my daughter very...

5.00 (12 reviews) (~92.68 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Ice cream shops in New York, United States