Most reviewed Thrift stores in New York, United States to visit (Updated December, 2023)

Most reviewed Thrift stores in New York

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of New York through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 114 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

MyUnique Thrift Bronx

Thrift store

3.90 (915 reviews) (~11.31 km from centre)

Red White & Blue Thrift

Thrift store

😠 Horrible Customer service from manager DANIELA. First I go there 15 minutes before they close and ask about a vintage beach cruiser that’s listed for 12.00 needs new tires rusty let’s just say a crazy DIY PROJECT. I wanted to purchase and was told the price was actually 124.99 so being that it’s in...

3.60 (663 reviews) (~88.49 km from centre)

MyUnique Thrift Union

Thrift store

😠 I’ve been visiting this thrift store at this location for nearly a decade and my last visit confirmed for me that I’ll never be visiting again. Whoever is in charge of pricing the inventory is out of their mind. More expensive than shopping retail. This store epitomizes corporate greed….

3.70 (658 reviews) (~30.53 km from centre)

MyUnique Thrift Elizabeth

Thrift store

Chain for used clothing, home goods, toys, books & electronics, in partnership with local charities.

3.90 (648 reviews) (~25.53 km from centre)

Savers

Thrift store

Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.

$ $$$

4.20 (582 reviews) (~28.08 km from centre)

MyUnique Thrift Paterson

Thrift store

😐 In the beginning MyUnique Thrift was a descent store with great prices, but In the last two years the quality has gone down and the prices have gone up. The staff and management do not care if the merchandise is dirty, broken or has missing parts. The product is placed on the shelf "as is" - the wor...

4.00 (559 reviews) (~22.9 km from centre)

Beacon's Closet

Second hand store

Trendy resale outfit for vintage & modern clothing & accessories from mass brands to top designers.

$ $$$

3.70 (554 reviews) (~6.71 km from centre)

Red White & Blue Thrift Store

Thrift store

3.80 (543 reviews) (~22.23 km from centre)

MyUnique Thrift South Plainfield

Thrift store

😠 A couple of occasions I have come here. They had a PlayStation two. I bought the PlayStation and they took it from me at the register and tried to make me pay for the controllers and power cords all separate. Now when you buy a gaming system everything comes with it. Apparently not here. They sell a...

3.90 (542 reviews) (~43.48 km from centre)

2nd Ave Thrift Superstore - Union, NJ

Thrift store

🫤 This is a prime example of what happens when a hedge fund owned for profit thrift store goes public on the US stock exchange. Now valued at 3 billion dollars, Savers, the parent company of 2nd Avenue has pretty much ruined this thrift store location. Constant empty racks, no more changing rooms, mos...

3.90 (478 reviews) (~29.66 km from centre)

Montclair Book Center

Book store

👍👍 Montclair is a very diverse and eccentric town. One of the places that adds to the charm is the Montclair Book Center. Since the new ownership took place (a little over a year ago), a majority of improvements have been made to enhance the bookreader and customer experience. The MBC transcends...

4.70 (469 reviews) (~21.81 km from centre)

Inspirations

Thrift store

😠 I drove a half hour to get to this stored arrived at 6:25 … it’s listed that they close at 7 pm … by 6:38 they said the store was closed and we couldn’t shop anymore …. If your store closes at 7 don’t alienate your customers and have them leave early …. Terrible experience and terrible customer se...

4.10 (463 reviews) (~33.15 km from centre)