Top rated Italian restaurants in Newburgh

Experience the best that Newburgh has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 55 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Roths Pizzeria image
1
Roths Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
4.80 (61 reviews) (~24.14 km from centre)
Pangea Kitchen image
2
Pangea Kitchen
Italian restaurant
Popular outpost featuring Neapolitan-style pizza, familiar Thai dishes & cocktails at the counter.
$$ $$
4.70 (1.1K reviews) (~8.51 km from centre)
Steve's Una Pizza image
3
Steve's Una Pizza
Pizza delivery
Dinner-only takeout fixture serving classic thin-crust pizzas, plus hot wings & housemade meatballs.
$ $$$
4.70 (884 reviews) (~10.07 km from centre)
Mama T's Italian Steakhouse image
4
Mama T's Italian Steakhouse
Italian restaurant
👍👍 We loved this place!! You will need a reservation which was easily made with a phone call during their business hours. We had a group of ten and we were well taken care of by our attentive and knowledgeable server who made some great recommendations. I had a delicious and perfectly cooked steak with...
$$ $$
4.70 (532 reviews) (~55.3 km from centre)
The Slice image
5
The Slice
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Awesome pizza the cheese that is used is amazing so many options but the traditional cheese, sausage, pepperoni tend to be what all of my family gets. The sauce is always perfect never overly heavy and never dried out. We go here once a week and everyone loves it kids and adults both!! It is cash on...
$ $$$
4.70 (339 reviews) (~11.22 km from centre)
Nicole's Restaurant image
6
Nicole's Restaurant
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.70 (222 reviews) (~93.13 km from centre)
Di Maggio's Italian Pizza image
7
Di Maggio's Italian Pizza
Pizza restaurant
4.70 (170 reviews) (~43.17 km from centre)
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Forget Me Not image
8
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Forget Me Not
Pizza restaurant
Thin-crust pies & burgers, plus house brews & wine, in casual saloonlike surroundings.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.4K reviews) (~11.5 km from centre)
Little Italy Restaurant image
9
Little Italy Restaurant
Italian restaurant
👍👍 This place!! From the outside I thought, “Hmmm, I will give it a try.” I am so glad I made that decision! My waitress Danielle was so friendly and very attentive. I had the lasagna and a side salad with the homemade Italian dressing. The dressing was so light and delicious. The lasagna was hand...
$$ $$
4.60 (832 reviews) (~17.01 km from centre)
Sauced image
10
Sauced
Italian restaurant
Romantic restaurant in a converted house offering Italian cuisine, a bar & seasonal patio seating.
$$ $$
4.60 (443 reviews) (~14.29 km from centre)
Di Maggio's Pizza image
11
Di Maggio's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 My wife and I both had the Pete salad. It's very good, my wife always gets it. I usually get lasagna that's very tasty as well. The service is great, waitresses are very friendly and cheerful, prompt and attentive. The food is always fresh and good. The place is starting to show its age, however. T...
$$ $$
4.60 (363 reviews) (~69.07 km from centre)
Covert Una Pizza image
12
Covert Una Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The best strom in town! Cozy dining area and great staff. If you haven't already, most definately give this locally owned spot a try. You're gonna love it!!
$ $$$
4.60 (273 reviews) (~9.7 km from centre)
Mimmo's Pizza Eldorado image
13
Mimmo's Pizza Eldorado
Pizza restaurant
😠 Ordered some wings they came very uncooked and looked like someone had ate a few. Then call and send that set of wings back to get a cooked set these came burnt!
$$ $$
4.60 (268 reviews) (~91.74 km from centre)
Kellyo's Pizza image
14
Kellyo's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 I don't get the hype. The pizza was bland, toppings are far from fresh (canned), wings were terrible, and the "breadsticks" (which are Bosco sticks) were about the better thing (which ain't saying much) we had from here. Their marinara tastes like tomato soup. I don't know where all these other r...
4.60 (126 reviews) (~60.77 km from centre)
Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano image
15
Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano
Italian restaurant
Chain outpost serving a large menu of Italian fare plus specialty cocktails in a laid-back setting.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.3K reviews) (~6.84 km from centre)
Procopio's Pizza & Pasta image
16
Procopio's Pizza & Pasta
Pizza restaurant
😐 This review is based solely on the 7" Procopios Deluxe. I found the deep dish crust to be somewhat lacking, the air pockets were flat and elongated suggesting to me it gets rolled with a rolling pin. It was somewhat flavorless also. However, it had good crisp. Did not seem wood fired, I suspect an o...
$$ $$
4.50 (761 reviews) (~82.46 km from centre)
Angelo's image
17
Angelo's
Italian restaurant
Old-school Italian cuisine with surroundings to match, plus wine & patio seating.
$$ $$
4.50 (713 reviews) (~14.93 km from centre)
Milanos Italian Cuisine image
18
Milanos Italian Cuisine
Italian restaurant
Unassuming family-owned establishment serving Italian standards including pizza & baked ziti.
$$ $$
4.50 (309 reviews) (~14.79 km from centre)
Noble Roman's image
19
Noble Roman's
Italian restaurant
Counter-serve pizza chain offering classic pies, sandwiches, pastas & wings, geared for takeout.
4.50 (189 reviews) (~7.71 km from centre)
Donut Depot image
20
Donut Depot
Donut shop
👍👍 I absolutely loved there glazed twist donuts! They were soft, fresh, and insanely good! As a small business, I know everyone would appreciate these yummy donuts if they knew donut depot existed! Keep up the great work
$ $$$
4.50 (59 reviews) (~37.01 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Newburgh

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )