21
Amore Pizza
Italian restaurant
🫤 I ordered the 14" garbage pie expecting it to be a small version of the vegetable garbage pie because I am allergic to dairy. It was missing the spinach, broccoli, and eggplant. It had pepperoni and sausage. This was a phone order so I ate it, but I am disappointed. I will not be ordering from t...
$$ $$
4.40 (412 reviews)
(~7.37 km from centre)
22
Nunzios Pizza Town
Pizza restaurant
Time-tested pizza joint offering large slices & pies, plus pasta & calzones in an unfussy interior.
$$ $$
4.60 (399 reviews)
(~5.36 km from centre)
23
Joe's Pasta & Pizza of Bay Shore
Pizza restaurant
Family-run since 1973, this basic outpost for Italian staples offers weekly pasta & chicken nights.
$$ $$
4.30 (398 reviews)
(~5.32 km from centre)
24
Spassos Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Ordered the Spasso House Special pizza and had it delivered to Root + Branch Brewery. The pizza came hot, fresh and was delicious. It was enjoyed by many fine people that day!
$$ $$
4.50 (390 reviews)
(~5.63 km from centre)
25
The Pie at Salvatore's
Pizza restaurant
Hopping pizzeria with classic leather booths serving coal-fired Neapolitan pies & more. Cash only.
$$ $$
4.60 (387 reviews)
(~6.54 km from centre)
26
Mulberry Street Bay Shore
Restaurant
Stalwart restaurant offering brick-oven pizza, pasta dishes & sandwiches in low-key surroundings.
$$ $$
4.20 (371 reviews)
(~4.35 km from centre)
27
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
3.80 (369 reviews)
(~6.2 km from centre)
28
Albert's Pizza Shop
Pizza restaurant
Longtime parlor known for its upside-down square pizza also serves basic Italian pastas & heros.
$$ $$
4.30 (347 reviews)
(~7.7 km from centre)
29
Little Joe's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😐 This place was nice, the boys that worked there were also sweet. We ordered pizza, chicken parm, and eggplant with spaghetti’s. We also had our small puppy and they let us eat there with him. The only thing it was a little cold in there, but they eventually closed the door when we asked them too. Ba...
$$ $$
4.30 (346 reviews)
(~6.36 km from centre)
30
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
4.20 (335 reviews)
(~5.27 km from centre)
31
The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 It's not very common I give a place 5
five stars across the board but this place deserves it! The food was delicious and two specialty slices were only about nine dollars. The service was amazing from every staff member which made me super happy to experience. Finally, the atmosphere was very open a...
$$ $$
4.80 (333 reviews)
(~5.49 km from centre)
32
Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Italian fast-food chain offering thin-crust & stuffed pizza by the slice, plus pastas & salads.
$$ $$
4.10 (329 reviews)
(~3.6 km from centre)
33
The Pizzeria of Islip
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This pizzeria gives us one more reason to LOVE our town. Delicious, hot , fresh pizza. Before we left, they even asked if our two kids wanted to come behind the counter and help! These people know how to make excellent pizza , but also know excellent service and genuinely love what they do. We will...
$ $$$
4.70 (320 reviews)
(~9.35 km from centre)
34
Nonna Bella's
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The pizza was perfect. It has a nice crunch, the sauce was tasty, and the cheese melted perfectly. The best pizza I have had in a long time, im not from that area, so this pizza was really a treat. I am on a personal mission to find great pizza, and this place makes the cut!!
$ $$$
4.40 (310 reviews)
(~0.52 km from centre)
36
Valentinos' Peruvian Restaurant
Peruvian restaurant
😐 I used to go to this restaurant for years and stopped due to the service and the food not being consistent. I decided to give it another shot today and after all these years, no change. One of the servers was nice & friendly, however the other one had attitude.
The “coffee” was basically water and a...
$$ $$
3.70 (308 reviews)
(~6.19 km from centre)
37
Crispino's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Omg the best pizzas hands down! We aren’t locals in the area, we were just visiting, and we just walked in with 6 hungry kids and 3 adults.
The front desk girl was so sweet and kind, and everyone was very friendly even though we had loud and messy kids. I really appreciate their kindness and patienc...
$$ $$
4.50 (286 reviews)
(~1.78 km from centre)
39
Luigi's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 The one person behind the counter treated us like we were clearly in the wrong neighborhood. He was very short and barely looked Us in the eye and the service was nothing to be desired. Thankfully the pizza tasted good, although I literally had to go home and cook the sausage pizza over again in my...
$ $$$
4.30 (272 reviews)
(~5.47 km from centre)
40
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
3.80 (265 reviews)
(~5.35 km from centre)