Best places in Amityville, United States to visit (UPDATED April, 2024)

Breakfast restaurant

👍👍 I'm so glad I discovered this little restaurant. Environment is comfortable and clean with friendly staff and a chef that really seems to care about customers. The "What-a-jerk shrimp & grits" has the best carribean jerk flavor I've ever had. Seasoned just right with a hint of heat and a slice of ch...

4.80 (468 reviews)

Brownstones Coffee Amityville

Breakfast restaurant

👍👍 This place is great for breakfast and lunch. The weekends get super busy and the wait is insane but so worth it. I come here so often and I’ve been serve by every crew member and I can honestly say everyone is super nice and attentive. Amazing customer service and great food. 10/10

$$ $$

4.60 (970 reviews)

Vittorio's

Italian restaurant

Classy, intimate American-Italian spot & bar with steak deals & wine dinners from a vast list.

$$$ $

4.60 (730 reviews)

Park Avenue Grill

American restaurant

👍👍 This was our second time visiting the Park Avenue Grill. My wife discovered the restaurant while looking for gluten-free dining options. The menu offered for diners with a gluten sensitivity is the largest we've seen! This menu is in addition to their regular menu which is equally impressive. It's...

$$ $$

4.60 (531 reviews)

Amityville Apothecary

Metaphysical supply store

👍👍 We love this shop!!! Traveled from Kings Park to satisfy my daughter's crystal obsession and was so blown away at this beautiful and unique store. We had a long visit and felt right at home. Bought some amazing items and visited with a sweet Golden Retriever, the store's familiar. The staff was ul...

4.90 (157 reviews)

Small Craft Brewing Company

Brewery

👍👍 A bit of a hole in the wall of a local brewery, but don't let that fool you, they are delivering AAA quality. With a constant rotation of new and exciting beers (you have to try the Tsunamiii), there is always something I want to try and plenty of old reliable options to fall back on. Current favori...

4.90 (156 reviews)

B & B Fish and Clam

Seafood restaurant

Informal seafood eatery/retail market in a strip mall preparing classic meals to eat in or take out.

$$ $$

4.50 (751 reviews)

Peter's Diner

Diner

👍 I stopped here for lunch after walking around Amityville and it was really good. I had a gyro platter and chicken soup and a very friendly waitress. I think she said it was only her second day. Nice diner and I would definitely go back.

$$ $$

4.50 (708 reviews)

Amity Ales

Restaurant

Housemade beers & hearty American bites served in a relaxed space with reclaimed barnwood.

$$ $$

4.50 (654 reviews)

Carney's Irish Pub & Restaurant

Irish pub

👍👍 Came here a couple months ago, meant to leave a review and remembered just now. If anyone deserves a great review it is this place - warmest staff I have met in ages and fantastic food, especially the Irish egg rolls and "the quiet man" - an insanely delicious beef and cheese, mushroom and onion san...

$$ $$

4.50 (389 reviews)

The One Sushi

Sushi restaurant

👍👍 We went to eat here on Monday night. It was pretty cold inside so we opted to sit out on the patio where the landscaping was nice and when the sun was going down the solar lights came on, it was romantic. Our food was remarkable and the service was very kind. I got shrimp and steak hibachi, Ed got...

$$ $$

4.50 (387 reviews)

Liki Asian Fusion Restaurant

Sushi restaurant

Creative sushi & Pan-Asian dishes served in a contemporary setting with striking decor.

$$ $$

4.60 (242 reviews)

Sophia

Italian restaurant

Traditional Italian kitchen serving pasta, meat & seafood, plus global wines, in polished digs.

$$ $$

4.50 (354 reviews)

The Better Bagel

Bagel shop

🫤 Decent bagels, but the pickup system is so stupid. I don’t see the point of giving people an “estimated pickup time” if you’re not even gonna make my sandwich until I get there. I didn’t even get anything complicated just a regular BEC and a black iced coffee.

$ $$$

4.40 (412 reviews)

Toomey's Tavern

Bar

😠 Waited for 40 minutes for a table. No problem. Order food after 1 hour waiter told us food would be another 45 minutes. Ask for manager. She was rude and not really helpful by far the worse manager did finally got 14 dollars back for 2 drinks. Was told that we were getting free band. Never again.

$$ $$

4.40 (388 reviews)

ISLAND FLAVOR JERK CUISINE

Jamaican restaurant

😠 I cannot comment on service and atmosphere but i can comment on food. The 4.6 rating for the stew snapper is a LIE!!!!! I ordered stew snapper and upon opening the dish i was extremely excited the presentation was nice. But that first bite! Was definitely not what i expected. It was like bbq fish....

$$ $$

4.70 (129 reviews)