Top rated places in Old Bethpage

Experience the best that Old Bethpage has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. Ratings are based from 37 places in the city.

Sort results by

Best  
πŸ”₯
Top rated  
πŸ†
Most reviewed  
🀩
Hidden gems  
πŸ’Ž
Worst rated  
🀬
Recently discovered  
πŸ†•

Search radius



The Officiants at Church of Ancient Ways image
1
The Officiants at Church of Ancient Ways
Wedding service
πŸ‘πŸ‘ On December 3, 2023, my daughter was married by Pastor April from the Church of Ancient Ways and I cannot say enough about how much she added to the ceremony. She flawlessly guided the proceedings without ever putting the spotlight on herself. Pastor April is the consummate professional with a beaut...
5.00 (105 reviews)
Bethpage Equestrian Center image
2
Bethpage Equestrian Center
Horseback riding service
4.90 (76 reviews)
Pure Barre image
3
Pure Barre
Physical fitness program
4.90 (61 reviews)
Anthony Defranco Salon image
4
Anthony Defranco Salon
Beauty salon
πŸ‘πŸ‘ Just amazing. The owner, Anthony, cut and styled my hair. He listened carefully to my styling request, hair concerns, evaluated the cut insofar as my lifestyle and styling abilities, reviewed my pics and advised the pros and cons of each. He did this before my hair was washed, after the wet cut, a...
4.90 (61 reviews)
Radiance Body Lab image
5
Radiance Body Lab
Medical spa
πŸ‘πŸ‘ One night scrolling instagram. I came across an ad for the Radiance body spa. Absolutely intrigued in non invasive treatments. I came in for my first treatment of Cavitation on my stomach and was hooked feeling slimmer and toner is a great feeling. Katherine has been amazing in making the session co...
4.90 (53 reviews)
Restoration Farm image
6
Restoration Farm
Farmers' market
4.90 (48 reviews)
Bethpage Black Course image
7
Bethpage Black Course
Golf course
This historical 18-hole golf course, 1 of 5 at Bethpage State Park, is open to the public.
4.80 (702 reviews)
Museum of American Armor image
8
Museum of American Armor
Museum
πŸ‘πŸ‘ Great place.. my six-year-old loves it. He loves anything to do with the military. You can see old school tanks up front and vehicles that are still working and operating it's pretty cool. Plus there's plenty of retired vets there to give you the information and history on some of the vehicles .What...
4.80 (346 reviews)
Page Barber Shop image
9
Page Barber Shop
Barber shop
4.80 (193 reviews)
Bethpage State Park image
10
Bethpage State Park
State park
Large park featuring 5 golf courses, hiking & biking trails & picnic facilities.
4.70 (2.5K reviews)
Villa Monte image
11
Villa Monte
Pizza restaurant
Unassuming mom-&-pop restaurant offering creative thin-crust pizzas & hearty Italian dishes.
$$ $$
4.70 (627 reviews)
Bethpage State Park Playground image
12
Bethpage State Park Playground
Playground
πŸ‘πŸ‘ I love walking on the trails here it's a great place espe
4.70 (228 reviews)
Bethpage Polo Field image
13
Bethpage Polo Field
Athletic field
πŸ‘πŸ‘ If you haven't been, it's a MUST DO!! Polo matches start 4pm & are about 2hrs. So much fun! Check out Meadow Brook Polo Clubs website for more detailed info πŸ₯‚
4.70 (70 reviews)
Bethpage State Park Bicycle Path image
14
Bethpage State Park Bicycle Path
State park
πŸ‘πŸ‘ I did 18 miles on this beautifully paved wooded trail last weekend. There are so much to see on the path from forest to streams and lakes.
4.70 (60 reviews)
Old Bethpage Village Restoration image
15
Old Bethpage Village Restoration
History museum
209-acre living history museum featuring a restored 19th-century village with 18 historic buildings.
4.60 (784 reviews)
Pete The Greek - Old Bethpage image
16
Pete The Greek - Old Bethpage
Greek restaurant
Low-key eatery in a shopping strip offering standard Greek dishes such as gyros & hummus plates.
$$ $$
4.60 (450 reviews)
Bottle Values image
17
Bottle Values
Wine store
4.60 (333 reviews)
The Shed Restaurant- Plainview image
18
The Shed Restaurant- Plainview
Restaurant
πŸ‘πŸ‘ Finally made it to The Shed Plainview today for brunch. Restaurant was buzzing and busy (inside and out on patio). We were offered a choice so we decided to sit outside and were seated immediately. Our server Enhri was polite, friendly and offered suggestions since we had trouble deciding what to c...
$$ $$
4.60 (319 reviews)
Happy Color Nail & Spa image
19
Happy Color Nail & Spa
Nail salon
🫀 First off- I use to love coming here because of the color options,cleanliness, and convenience from my job. But the longer I came here, the more I had not too great experiences. Some days they take card tips and some days they don’t. They will literally follow you to your car as if I wasn’t going to...
4.60 (230 reviews)
Long Island Fair Exhibition Hall image
20
Long Island Fair Exhibition Hall
Historical place
πŸ‘πŸ‘ I have been here before for the Long Island fair and also the restored village. But I especially love the patriotic horse display of the organization that provides entertainment in many public places. My friend Sue and I enjoyed the many other shows. I have loved horses since childhood! The ground...
4.60 (132 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )