Top rated Trading card stores in Rochester, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Trading card stores in Rochester

Experience the best that Rochester has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 16 places from Trading card store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Rochester

Hidden Treasures

Trading card store

👍👍 I visited this place trying to find my Grandson a new toy and ended up finding more than what I was looking for. Not only did I find him something but, I found a few items for myself as well. The store is very clean, organized, and the staff was very helpful & friendly. The name suits itself, you...

5.00 (179 reviews) (~99.42 km from centre)

Mitch's Sports Cards & Collectibles

Trading card store

👍👍 By far my favorite place for all things sports cards! Incredible selections and prices, and Mitch is one of the most knowledgeable and friendly guys around! Highly recommend and will continue to bring my business here! I suggest you do to!

5.00 (34 reviews) (~56.95 km from centre)

Primetime Sportscards & Collectibles

Trading card store

4.90 (237 reviews) (~43.28 km from centre)

Planet Chaos

Comic book store

4.90 (196 reviews) (~53.11 km from centre)

Gemini Games

Game store

4.90 (142 reviews) (~83.62 km from centre)

Seven Out Cards & Collectibles

Collectibles store

4.90 (42 reviews) (~96.16 km from centre)

Kowabunga Comics

Comic book store

👍👍 Excellent local comic book shop that also teaches you how to play card games like Pokémon. I've come here at random times the past couple of years and the staff has always been inviting and helpful. The selection of new and back issues are amazing! This is a great place- I highly recommend it!

4.80 (378 reviews) (~46.17 km from centre)

Top Cut Comics

Comic book store

😠 I canceled my subscription box after 3 weeks. It seems like fine place to go for games and trading cards, but I cannot recommend it as a comic shop. A little bit of behind the scenes customer service and some common sense could turn this place right around, but they're either unwilling or unable to...

4.70 (617 reviews) (~83.33 km from centre)

GAME ON

Video game store

4.70 (143 reviews) (~93.85 km from centre)

Kryptonite Kollectibles

Game store

😠 Years ago I would order products for when they came out, they would never arrive on time. Someone at the store even told me a product hadn't come out yet that was supposed to release on my birthday I saw it at other stores, and it had released on time. I was told by the staff repeatedly it was pushe...

4.60 (397 reviews) (~63.74 km from centre)

WaxPax Records & Toys

Toy store

👍 Great store! The selection of toys was HUGE and they were all very reasonably priced :) the store did smell like weed, but it could’ve been something else. Overall, a very pleasant experience! Keep up the good work!

4.60 (102 reviews) (~83.43 km from centre)

Forever After Antiques and Collectibles

Collectibles store

4.60 (63 reviews) (~83.31 km from centre)

Pastimes Comics & Games

Game store

👍👍 Pastimes Comics & Games is a game and hobby store located next to the AMC theatres in the Golf Mills Mall. It is fairly large with about half of the space allocated to tables. There are a large amount of tables and weekly playing opportunities available throughout the week for various games. I even...

4.50 (527 reviews) (~83.25 km from centre)

Robin's Nest

Trading card store

4.40 (150 reviews) (~85.17 km from centre)

Everything Games

Game store

😠 They just recently moved to a bigger spot in the same strip mall, it's a large location with lots of room, has so much potential but sadly the staff at the site are very abrasive. I've been here a handful of times, and each time I feel weird vibes from the staff. They make you feel like your wastin...

4.20 (778 reviews) (~63.97 km from centre)

Pink Bunny Games

Game store

🫤 Lady was super friendly. Unfortunately this store sold extensive counterfeit Pokémon merchandise. Figures, plush, pin, patches... It sucks to see a store care so much about MTG then just rip-off their Pokémon enthusiasts.

4.20 (349 reviews) (~34.95 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Trading card stores in Rochester, United States