Hidden gems - Pubs in South Orange, United States not to miss (Updated April, 2024)

Hidden gems: Pubs in South Orange

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in South Orange. This list contains 39 places from Pub category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within South Orange

The Deep Inn

Bar

👍👍 I'm what one might call a connoisseur of dive bars. I have been to many of them. This is one of my favorites, and my very favorite in its immediate area. Just such a great vibe from the service to the decor.... Such nice people running this place. Highly recommended. If you go here, you're going t...

$ $$$

5.00 (69 reviews) (~9.3 km from centre)

The Canary

Pub

👍👍 Cozy and quietish when we started at about 4:30 p.m. (on a Wed.), perfect for catching up and chatting. Amazing bar service and super friendly bartender!! Excellent drinks!! Loved the fries! Got busier as night progressed with very friendly and cool crowd. Service continued to be great even now seat...

4.90 (105 reviews) (~27.15 km from centre)

The York

Pub

👍👍 This. THIS. This is what the East Village needs more of. Comfy vibes, amazing staff, cheap eats that don't sacrifice quality - and stiff drinks at a reasonable price. Vegetarian friendly too, which is rare for a smash burger menu. The perfect place to begin your night, to end it, or anytime in betwe...

4.90 (77 reviews) (~24.04 km from centre)

Smith's Tavern

Bar

👍👍 Love going to Smith's! Family run pub in Rockaway Borough, staff is always very friendly and welcoming. Great place to go after work to catch a few beers and friendly conversation that won't break the bank. Keep in mind it's cash only! We went on St. Paddy's this year and the Corned Beef was out...

$ $$$

4.80 (118 reviews) (~26.33 km from centre)

NY Beer Garden

Beer garden

👍👍 Flushing needed this! A beautiful place, brand new, great service, staff is welcoming, you have to give the place a few more days to have all beers available, but just now you have almost 20 different beers to choose from Food is delicious, fresh and tasty

$$ $$

4.80 (102 reviews) (~38.52 km from centre)

The Raven Pub NYC

Pub

😠 I have a question to the manager of this place, do you give customer service training to your employees? On Saturday June 17, 2023, I had a bad experience in that place with one of his collaborators (bartender) for the simple fact of asking him for some drinks for my table since he did not attend m...

4.80 (96 reviews) (~26.19 km from centre)

Mc Greevy’s

Bar

👍👍 Great people, wonderful bartenders, no food but you can bring in whatever you want from neighboring places. Clean and welcoming with a pool table and two dart boards.

4.80 (50 reviews) (~45.64 km from centre)

Sparta Pour House

Pub

4.80 (15 reviews) (~44.32 km from centre)

Mill Lane Tavern Inc

Bar

👍👍 the bartender Michelle is an excellent bartender. nice environment. Bridget’s secret blooming onion sauce is amazing. nice crowd

$ $$$

4.70 (144 reviews) (~26.82 km from centre)

Sundays Well

Gastropub

Bar bites, cocktails, beer & wine are served in a casual setting with late-night hours.

4.70 (138 reviews) (~23.74 km from centre)

Jalopy Tavern

Pub

This watering hole housed in a historic space offers a menu of elevated pub grub & weekend brunch.

$ $$$

4.70 (133 reviews) (~23.06 km from centre)

Third Floor Pocha (삼층포차)

Korean restaurant

👍👍 Always a great time here! Perfect for a group of friends or if you're out late catching up with an old buddy. Go for the drink specials for sure, and the food was fire. Definitely a nightlife vibe, and a hidden gem of the area. The entrance is right on Broad Ave, the door that says PMC and ITSHOW ra...

4.70 (103 reviews) (~24.86 km from centre)

Mama's Gastropub

Bar & grill

👍👍 Abosolute hidden gem! Wow, the food is fresh, and the chef makes phenomenal menu choices. The service staff is so very friendly.

$$ $$

4.70 (94 reviews) (~32.08 km from centre)

Ned Devine's Saloon

Pub

👍👍 Nice neighborhood bar with great staff and friendly customers. Sit at the bar and you won't go wrong.

$ $$$

4.70 (91 reviews) (~37.64 km from centre)

Uncle Lefty’s

American restaurant

👍👍 Love the updates that UL made to this space! Light and bright w new skylights. My favorite local chef, Jody Hunter, is at the helm making her signature delicious dishes. The Whipped Ricotta with Toasted Spice Oil, Pickled Onions, housemade Focaccia make me feel I am in Italy ❤️

4.70 (78 reviews) (~42.33 km from centre)

The Laurels Cafe and Bar

Bar

👍👍 I found this place through the app "Pulsd" where 2 people get 1 entree each and bottomless drinks for $39! I believe you can also find the same deal on Groupon. Reservations were easy to make by dming their instagram or through Resy. It wasn't pretty crowded on Saturday noon so we got to sit where w...

4.70 (72 reviews) (~23.52 km from centre)

The Beer Garage

Bar

👍👍 Wow just wow! This place is a hole in the wall in west village. So charming and the food is mind blowing. I got the oysters, cheese fries, Cobb salad and their Mac and cheese. Please try them all. You’ll thank me later :)

4.70 (66 reviews) (~25.14 km from centre)

The Gaf

Bar

Veteran watering hole offering sports on TV, darts & more in a relaxed, no-frills setup.

$ $$$

4.60 (143 reviews) (~26.58 km from centre)

McQ's Pub at Lake Lenape

Pub

👍👍 My first time ever coming here during my stay a few weeks ago in that general area my wife and I had no idea which door was the entrance as we went around in circles so one of the regulars noticed us and welcomed us into the establishment in an awkward but friendly fashion yielded by his friendly hu...

$ $$$

4.60 (142 reviews) (~48.24 km from centre)

Beer Street South

Bar

👍👍 This has what to me is the bar trifecta: amazing selection (both in breadth and quality), menu listed on Untappd, and offers small pours. Also thanks to the bartender for the good conversation, and when I closed out he surprised me by saying he covered my last drink.

4.60 (128 reviews) (~25.99 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Pubs in South Orange, United States