1
Magic Fountain
Ice cream shop
Landmark dessert spot dishing up housemade ice cream in traditional & custom flavors, plus cakes.
$ $$$
4.80 (906 reviews)
(~0.89 km from centre)
2
Love Lane Kitchen
American restaurant
Upscale comfort meals served in a quaint local cafe with house-roasted coffee plus beer & wine.
$$ $$
4.60 (1K reviews)
(~0.1 km from centre)
3
Jedediah Hawkins Inn
Hotel
Elegant rooms in an 1863 boutique hotel, plus an upscale New American eatery & a rustic speakeasy.
4.70 (380 reviews)
(~6.2 km from centre)
4
Barrow Food House
Restaurant
👍👍 Fried chicken thigh sandwich was unique, really enjoyed it. Started off with the butternut squash soup, which was perfect. Nice atmosphere in a cool town. Will be back!
$$ $$
4.70 (373 reviews)
(~9.57 km from centre)
5
North Fork Doughnut Company
Donut shop
👍👍 The OG, on Love Lane! As soon as you approach the store, the doughnut fragrance grabs you and says “try a doughnut (or two!).” So delicious and with the weekly specials there is always something new to try. The store staff are so helpful and friendly and the doughnuts…home run!!!! Love NoFoDoCo!
4.70 (373 reviews)
(~0.06 km from centre)
6
Twin Stills Moonshine
Bar
👍👍 As they say at Two Stills...”to hell with wine pour me some moonshine”... I went on a bus tour and when we stopped here I was a little nervous cause I am not a fan of moonshine ... but this place was not only unique but one of a kind. The moonshine selection was spectacular and as you continue takin...
$$ $$
4.80 (222 reviews)
(~6.8 km from centre)
7
Woodside Orchards- Aquebogue Tasting Room
Cider bar
👍 Super pleasant experience.
Clean and crisp tasting hard cider served in a tastefully appointed building.
It would be nice if they had a real bathroom rather than a port-a potty.
Their donuts are tasty as well.
They offer growlers as well.
If you are uncertain of what cider you’d like- order their ta...
4.60 (411 reviews)
(~8.6 km from centre)
8
Aqua by American Beech
Hotel
Upscale hotel offering contemporary quarters with canal or bay views, plus a private beach.
4.60 (365 reviews)
(~8.36 km from centre)
9
Croteaux Vineyards
Vineyard
👍 What a great little find in Peconic. A beautiful, quaint winery. They have small snacks and tons of Rose'. We had the still Jolie Rose'. Delicious! The staff is ready and waiting to help. Beautiful grounds. Quiet little spaces to get lost. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!
4.60 (354 reviews)
(~9.98 km from centre)
10
Modern Snack Bar
American restaurant
Veteran family-run restaurant offers vintage decor & homey American dishes such as mashed turnips.
$$ $$
4.50 (670 reviews)
(~8.94 km from centre)
11
Veterans Beach
Park
👍👍 I have loved this beach ever since I was a child. When it first opened up, the playground was rusted and rebuilt from the ground up. The snack bar was in the weathered red building right by the boardwalk back then. This beach holds a lot of memories for me. I recently visited again after five years...
4.70 (204 reviews)
(~1.48 km from centre)
12
The Watershed Kitchen and Bar
Restaurant
👍👍 DELISH FOOD!!! We were heading out to the Orient Point ferry to head to Mohegan Sun for a show. Found this place online and had to go! SOOOO HAPPY we did!! It was a DELISH LUNCH~ first course~ Pinot Grigio from a local winery~YAYYYY (forget which one 🤪). Then we split a lobster roll and shrimp taco...
4.70 (203 reviews)
(~7.15 km from centre)
13
Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca
Italian restaurant
Rustic trattoria specializing in organic wood-fired pizzas with artisan toppings & handmade pastas.
$$ $$
4.50 (490 reviews)
(~6.17 km from centre)
14
The Village Cheese Shop
Cheese shop
👍👍 A great store with a large variety of quality cheeses + friendly & knowledgeable staff.
👍😊👍
$$$ $
4.80 (154 reviews)
(~0.05 km from centre)
15
Red Rooster Bistro
Bistro
American bistro with busy rooster-themed decor offering old-fashioned, homestyle meals.
$$ $$
4.60 (270 reviews)
(~4.53 km from centre)
16
Osprey's Dominion
Winery
😠 The man inside serving the “testers” was terribly bothered to serve/help us. He literally flung the tray with the five wines and some of the wine spilled onto the tray. He was more interested in his regulars and spoke to them with respect. I was with my two grown daughters and my granddaughter.
We w...
4.60 (255 reviews)
(~9.21 km from centre)
17
Greenport Harbor Brewery and Restaurant
Brewery
👍 A great big brewery in the heart of Peconic. Great Pumpkin Ale. Food was tasty, good for a brewery. It was loud and crowded so be prepared for kids, dogs, etc. Not a quaint little joint. Order your food and drink and go sit with a buzzer. It was fun. Very good French Onion Soup. Tell 'em Barsnobs se...
4.50 (373 reviews)
(~8.71 km from centre)
18
Cutchogue Diner
American restaurant
👍👍 A step back in time to the 1940’s in a diner car, that’s what I remember them being called,and have a delightful breakfast or lunch. Really friendly staff. Food is very good. This place has a simple menu and do offer specials. Unlike the Greek diners of today with a menu that list over a hundred...
$ $$$
4.50 (372 reviews)
(~4.58 km from centre)
19
Pindar Vineyards
Vineyard
Winery with cellar & vineyard tours, plus a tasting room & live music in summer.
4.50 (351 reviews)
(~7.33 km from centre)
20
New Suffolk Beach
Public beach
😠 Best place in town to get parking tickets. Boat ramp always has a line and trailer parking is always full. Stay far away from this beach
4.70 (160 reviews)
(~5.26 km from centre)