Hidden gems: Ice cream shops in St. Marys

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in St. Marys. This list contains 95 places from Ice cream shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Cup & Cone image
1
Cup & Cone
Coffee shop
$ $$$
5.00 (73 reviews) (~202.53 km from centre)
The Bakery image
2
The Bakery
Bakery
👍👍 Delicious homemade baked goods, both traditional and innovative. Family-run friendly atmosphere. Awesome pizza. Ridiculous portions. 😋
5.00 (63 reviews) (~114.48 km from centre)
Goff Home Grocery image
3
Goff Home Grocery
Pizza takeaway
5.00 (49 reviews) (~147.6 km from centre)
Cracken's Grill image
4
Cracken's Grill
American restaurant
👍👍 Super clean shop & yummy food! Honey Mustard Chicken Sandwich wasn't just a Sysco chicken breast on a Sysco bun. The fried chicken was cooked fresh and seasoned well. The bun was a fluffy, tasty kaiser (I think?) with corn meal on top! Staff is super nice. Menu board is positioned a bit awkwardly, b...
$ $$$
5.00 (43 reviews) (~189.87 km from centre)
Pace e Bene, LLC image
5
Pace e Bene, LLC
Religious goods store
👍👍 Their gelatos and espressos are wonderful. An affogato tied the whole thing together, very yummy. Nice book store to sit and chill and get some work done or chat. Sometimes busy, often times chill. Lots of good books and catholic paraphernalia. But i wouldn’t let that stop you from the gelato/espres...
5.00 (38 reviews) (~226.9 km from centre)
The Farmacy Soda Fountain & Coffee House image
6
The Farmacy Soda Fountain & Coffee House
Coffee shop
👍👍 Amazing coffee & shakes! Fair prices & decked with vintage items. The owners (Brian & Lisa) are always friendly & quick!
$ $$$
5.00 (25 reviews) (~184.61 km from centre)
Buenissimo Paleteria Vi-Vi ice cream shop image
7
Buenissimo Paleteria Vi-Vi ice cream shop
Ice cream shop
5.00 (24 reviews) (~234.41 km from centre)
Montezuma Floral image
8
Montezuma Floral
Florist
5.00 (18 reviews) (~105.27 km from centre)
J & O Boba Tea image
9
J & O Boba Tea
Ice cream shop
5.00 (18 reviews) (~208.77 km from centre)
Down Home Creations image
10
Down Home Creations
Ice cream shop
5.00 (17 reviews) (~83.44 km from centre)
Rocky Rhoad's Ice Cream image
11
Rocky Rhoad's Ice Cream
Ice cream shop
5.00 (16 reviews) (~202.48 km from centre)
The 1854 image
12
The 1854
Ice cream shop
5.00 (13 reviews) (~175.99 km from centre)
Sweet Stop image
13
Sweet Stop
Ice cream shop
5.00 (9 reviews) (~249.36 km from centre)
The Main Scoop image
14
The Main Scoop
Ice cream shop
5.00 (9 reviews) (~158.25 km from centre)
Típico Helado 2 (Fremont) image
15
Típico Helado 2 (Fremont)
Ice cream shop
5.00 (7 reviews) (~231.11 km from centre)
La Michoacana Xtra image
16
La Michoacana Xtra
Ice cream shop
5.00 (6 reviews) (~106.69 km from centre)
The Milk House image
17
The Milk House
Ice cream shop
5.00 (6 reviews) (~146.97 km from centre)
Revel's Malt Shop image
18
Revel's Malt Shop
Ice cream shop
5.00 (6 reviews) (~139.89 km from centre)
Emma’s Ice Cream Shop image
19
Emma’s Ice Cream Shop
Ice cream shop
5.00 (5 reviews) (~175.58 km from centre)
Sky Kone image
20
Sky Kone
Ice cream shop
5.00 (5 reviews) (~49.15 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near St. Marys

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )