Hidden gems - Pasta shops in Toms River, United States not to miss (Updated March, 2024)

Hidden gems: Pasta shops in Toms River

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Toms River. This list contains 17 places from Pasta shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Toms River

The Gourmet Deli

Deli

👍👍 I came here for the first time today. The folks were very friendly and helpful. Restaurant was quaint and clean. They had a nice variety of sandwiches and different plates. I got a pulled pork sandwich that was pretty good. Since it was my first visit, the owner also gave me some angel hair pasta sa...

$ $$$

4.90 (91 reviews) (~78.85 km from centre)

Mr. Pasta

Deli

👍👍 Delicious home made Italian dishes. Specials daily as well. Home made salads, high quality meats and cheeses. One of my favorites hands down. The owners are just wonderful too! Pick up something to go. This deli never ever disappoints!

4.90 (53 reviews) (~92.91 km from centre)

Sorrentino Pasta + Provisions

Pasta shop

👍👍 Overall: high-quality fresh pasta, bread, and deserts! Service: Friendly. For dine-in, grab an available table first and then order at the front. Food: definitely the best pasta place in Ambler. Their pasta always tastes great, made fresh everyday. It’s a bit saltier side. Their rosemary/garlic/po...

4.80 (123 reviews) (~90.08 km from centre)

Nostra Pizza & Italian Eatery

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Great food. New building. Red sauce is great. Pizza is great. Vodka pasta is great. Ceasar salad was ok. Wood fired oven is key, love it. Garlic knots are awesome!

$$ $$

4.70 (132 reviews) (~65.75 km from centre)

Felice on Hudson

Italian restaurant

👍👍 This is a 6! I’ve never felt so welcomed in a bar/restaurant. It was so great that I went 3 times in two weeks! The customer service was amazing!! Also the food was incredible, especially the warm salad and crispy bread. Thanks Lucca for making the experience first class…

$$ $$

4.70 (98 reviews) (~88.8 km from centre)

P&S Ravioli Company

Deli

👍👍 Don't be fooled by their name! They aren't just a ravioli store! They are the go to spot for lunch too. Their sandwiches are great. fresh cut meats and top notch bread. Plus they sell cold cuts. 🇮🇹

$$ $$

4.70 (83 reviews) (~76.09 km from centre)

Five Star Catering by Thomas

Deli

👍👍 In the top 3 if not the best Italian Sub I have ever had. Customer service is great. Both guys I met are great and have friendly personality. Overally great vibes from this place and delicious sandwiches.

$$ $$

4.70 (56 reviews) (~77.95 km from centre)

Hesstown Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 Food especially the pizza was way better because of me… I never relinquished my recipes for the pizza and i no longer work there because I was fired. Too many Chiefs and Not enough Indians. I was injured there also and found out they had no workman’s comp insurance also. Terrible experience and sad...

4.70 (37 reviews) (~90.74 km from centre)

Conte's Pasta Co. Inc.

Pasta shop

😠 We bought a quart size container of grated cheese and in 2 days it was riddled with mold. When we returned it the lady took it from us and CHARGED us for another one!! 2 days later, it turned moldy just like the first one. We're DONE, not buying ANYTHING from them again!

4.60 (121 reviews) (~81.43 km from centre)

Aleo Italian Specialties

Caterer

👍👍 The sandwiches are delicious! The staff is quick to take your order. Even the cashiers are very friendly. I'm sure I will like some of the other food items they have (when I get around to trying them). Who doesn't ❤️ good food and friendly service?

$$ $$

4.60 (107 reviews) (~42.61 km from centre)

Grazi's Kitchen

Italian restaurant

😠 Was so looking forward to trying this place went to their establishment and walked in - owner was rude and when I asked to order was advised they had to may catering orders to take a take out order. And got an offhand sorry. There was no indication when arriving they they we’re closed to walk-in...

$$$ $

4.60 (48 reviews) (~83.94 km from centre)

Mancino's Pizzeria & Pasta

Italian restaurant

👍 I love their Steak Roll (basically steak calzone) Subs are good. Pizza is really good, it has great crust and toppings (sausage and peppers) Their White Pie is also good. I got mine with Broccoli. The Broccoli pieces were big which I had no problem but if you prefer smaller maybe ask them to cut the...

$$ $$

4.60 (28 reviews) (~40.63 km from centre)

Raffetto's Fresh Pasta

Pasta shop

👍👍 The most amazing raviolis ever! Hand down... live in NJ, but go to Aurther ave in the BX to shop for food. But since someone turned me on to this spot on Houston in NYC I can't get my ravioli anywhere else. But now just found they have a spot in NJ... What no more trip into the bronx. I'm loving it.

4.60 (11 reviews) (~99.04 km from centre)

Sunday Gravy Company

Italian restaurant

4.60 (10 reviews) (~43.59 km from centre)

Pizza Twist

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 As the first paying customer at this Pizzatwist location I was a little nervous. But we were greeted with smiles. Ordering was simple. Got the vegan pizza. Came quickly and we are enjoying it as we speak! Our pizza was personally made by Jeremy. Great job!

$$ $$

4.50 (127 reviews) (~66.26 km from centre)

New Egypt Kitchen

Family restaurant

👍 First time trying New Egypt Kitchen. Turkey Club was very good with fries and delicious cokeslaw. The chicken cutlet was good. It was a bit of a surprise. Was not expecting it to be a sandwich.

4.50 (107 reviews) (~24.61 km from centre)

Westphilly pizza & grill

Pizza restaurant

$ $$$

4.50 (11 reviews) (~89.28 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Pasta shops in Toms River, United States