1
Big Mouth's Deli & Catering
Deli
👍👍 Just tried this place out for lunch today. I was in the mood for a sandwich and suggested Subway, but my wife said that the West Milford Mom’s Facebook page is always raving about this place!! Turns out that the food was wonderful, generous portions and the pricing is on point. Friendly service and...
4.90 (109 reviews)
2
Cibo e Vino Ristorante
Restaurant
👍👍 We had the best fried calamari, shrimp scampi and chicken parm along with the best service. The restaurant was cozy and the host was hospitable. Thanks for a lovely evening, we will definitely be back soon!
4.80 (52 reviews)
3
Amore Italian pizza Westmilford
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 We went on Friday. The chicken and veal frances, and the veal parm were FANTASTIC!
So good we got a pie and meatballs Saturday.
Be prepared, you’ll pay for a meal, but get TWO! Insane amount of food for the price.
You need to get here!
$$ $$
4.70 (37 reviews)
4
Momento Restaurant
Northern Italian restaurant
Classy bistro offering elevated Italian pasta, meat & seafood dishes, plus outdoor seating.
$$ $$
4.60 (290 reviews)
5
D'Boathaus
Restaurant
👍👍 We had the steamed clams and fried Sriracha honey cauliflower.. the cauliflower was phenomenal ..had the perfect mixture of sweet and heat.. seriously delicious..the steamers had chorizo and tomatoes... which combined were the perfect little bites.. we had the pleasure of meeting Brent who is busy...
4.60 (86 reviews)
6
Paul's Place
American restaurant
👍 If your a hot dog fan, this is a great little local stop. Good mix of foods and great service.
Bring cash.
$ $$$
4.50 (490 reviews)
7
The Vreeland Store
Bar
😠 Stopped here for the “seafood festival”, which had maybe 5 items on the menu with seafood in them. Sat down at 1 after being passed around from employee to employee trying to find a table and was served 3 drinks each between two people by 230. Food never arrived because we were told “ people just ke...
4.50 (412 reviews)
8
West Milford Thai Restaurant
Restaurant
👍👍 Amazing surprise to find this place! The food is amazing and very fresh great prices! Tried once a Thai restaurant in Bloomingdale and I was disappointed but now this restaurant nested in west Milford is the real thing I enjoyed the chef special “Spicy Duck Curry “ I was happy very tastefu...
$$ $$
4.50 (247 reviews)
9
Bagel Town Cafe
Bagel shop
👍👍 Definitively worth a stop in! The bagels don’t disappoint.. The coffee was always fresh the few times I came here while on vacation.
$ $$$
4.50 (164 reviews)
10
Grasshopper Irish Pub
Irish restaurant
Festive game-day hangout with a wraparound bar & patio serving a wide menu of pub grub & Irish eats.
$$ $$
4.40 (1.3K reviews)
11
Frank's Pizza (West Milford)
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Yummy!!! Quick stop for a couple slices of pizza and it was wonderful! So many different choices to choose from!! I had the white slice, my partner had the grandma slice and a plain. Deliciously cheesy! Clean & bright & friendly atmosphere! Thank you !! 🍕
$ $$$
4.40 (385 reviews)
12
Utopia Deli & Catering
Deli
😠 Ordered a #12 Turkey Avocado Wrap. Absolutely awful. Not one thing that was slightly good about it. Took two bites and right into garbage. Definitely will not come back & definitely not worth the $9 unfortunately.
$ $$$
4.40 (269 reviews)
13
Guisseppe's Restaurant
Restaurant
👍👍 Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. If you are craving Italian food, come to Guisseppe’s Restaurant. They really make sure that you have a great experience. I will definitely come back!
$$ $$
4.40 (224 reviews)
14
Country Cottage
American restaurant
👍👍 Love dining at the Country Cottage. The food and drinks are delicious. The owers/ cooks come to your table to greet you as well as to check on your meal. It is cozy and clean. Love it.
$$ $$
4.40 (221 reviews)
15
Old School Pub & Grill
Bar & grill
🫤 Only got to see the parking lot, and it was decent. My friends who went ahead got turned around cause there was no indoor seating or sumthin' for food cause of covid. I was heartbroken after slaving, picking apples all day down the road. Real old school pubs don't care about covid restrictions. Rena...
$$ $$
4.40 (151 reviews)
16
Macopin Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Food is great and the people that work there are amazing. They always throw in freebies and remember regular customers, which we are always so impressed by. Tonight, my husband picked up dinner and when he got home we realized a side of onion rings was missing. They had thrown in some other free ite...
$ $$$
4.40 (128 reviews)
17
Pop's Bagelry
Cafe
👍👍 Took the kids here for lunch today to try it out. They made the most out of the old bank space. Clean and inviting! Food was great. Sandwiches were all made to order off menu and fresh. Heroes are probably 12", fresh bread, and well made. All the chicken whether grilled or cutlet was perfectly cooke...
$ $$$
4.40 (70 reviews)
18
Paradise Restaurant & Bar
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Excellent selection of food and it sure is delicious.
The sweet tai chili wings were like none other ! Seriously 10/10
For an entree I got a shrimp parm that was perfect as well.
$$ $$
4.40 (60 reviews)
19
Vesuvio Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😐 Small pizza shop where if you blink you could miss it, but it's definitely worth the stop. Slices are really good quality and better than many of the more well know places in the area. Menu is a little limited and it's definitely a place where you are taking the food to go as seating is sparce. Over...
$$ $$
4.30 (268 reviews)
20
Mamma Mia’s Too!
Restaurant
👍👍 We just tried this place for the first time and it is excellent!! I am very picky with my pizza and this was definitely 5 star food and service!! From the door we were greeted and treated with great attention. Kids got a personal pepperoni pizza, my wife and Son split fried calamari, then my wife an...
$$ $$
4.30 (111 reviews)