Hidden gems - Thrift stores in West New York, United States not to miss (Updated May, 2024)

Hidden gems: Thrift stores in West New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in West New York. This list contains 32 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within West New York

Only Rare NYC

Ice cream shop

👍👍 The rolled ice cream here is awesome. They gotta step they spoon game up though, I need a stronger spoon than them flimsy plastic ones🤷🏽‍♂️👍🏾

5.00 (115 reviews) (~25.67 km from centre)

Second Chance Shoppe

Thrift store

5.00 (81 reviews) (~34.91 km from centre)

Not So Ordinary

Thrift store

👍👍 I stopped in last week with my mother, less so as customers, but more to ask questions about where to buy an item my mother was looking for, and generally, about ways to sell items she owns. The shop owner at Not So Ordinary, then took the time to stop and share a wealth of helpful information, writ...

5.00 (29 reviews) (~16.02 km from centre)

Unleashed Thrift

Thrift store

5.00 (15 reviews) (~11.77 km from centre)

Treasures Thrift Shop

Thrift store

5.00 (6 reviews) (~45.28 km from centre)

Underground Thrift Store

Thrift store

5.00 (6 reviews) (~9.67 km from centre)

The Vintage Living

Antique store

4.90 (76 reviews) (~35 km from centre)

Sunnyside Book and Media Swap, Public Library and Donation Center

Public library

👍👍 A concept difficult for some to understand: free books. This table is a labor of love. It’s a clean, friendly, well-lighted place, with books available for children as well as adults. It’s organized by a skeleton crew of volunteers, so the books are arranged mostly by size, but in general categories...

4.90 (45 reviews) (~8.59 km from centre)

Cash 4 Gold Trading Post

Pawn shop

4.90 (41 reviews) (~47 km from centre)

Upper EastSide Thrift shop

Thrift store

4.90 (30 reviews) (~5.19 km from centre)

Hope Thrift Shop for Long Island

Thrift store

👍👍 Cute little thrift store in the heart of oyster bay village! Staff was friendly and helpful. Everything is neatly organized and not overrun with products. Found some great finds like a crock pot, boots and firefighter toys for my son. They accept credit cards!

4.90 (18 reviews) (~41.34 km from centre)

The Emporium Metuchen

Boutique

👍👍 Beautiful, eclectic sharp well done Metuchen definitely needed this!💕

4.90 (14 reviews) (~40.64 km from centre)

Stray Vintage

Second hand store

Quirky selection of vintage jewelry, clothes & midcentury modern furniture, plus gifts & more.

4.80 (44 reviews) (~9 km from centre)

Wyckoff PTO Economy Shop

Thrift store

👍👍 The Economy Shop is a Win-Win for Everyone! You can find treasures at very reasonable prices and the proceeds benefit 7 schools. Volunteer and meet members of our community. Pay it Forward!

4.80 (24 reviews) (~28.77 km from centre)

St. Agnes Thrift Shop

Thrift store

4.80 (23 reviews) (~41.26 km from centre)

Tag Sale Warehouse

Thrift store

4.80 (15 reviews) (~32.79 km from centre)

Community Presbyterian Thrift

Thrift store

4.80 (5 reviews) (~31.08 km from centre)

Wow! That's Unusual!

Thrift store

4.70 (54 reviews) (~38.72 km from centre)

Cash 4 Gold Trading Post

Pawn shop

👍👍 Very reasonable and friendly. They give the best price in town. Definitely try them first and don’t confuse them with neighboring shops.

4.70 (47 reviews) (~48.98 km from centre)

thriftnicks

Thrift store

👍👍 Can’t think of a nicer guy in a business like this. The owner Nick helped me out tremendously for a bunch of things I needed and kept recommending more to really complete my trip. Prices are incredibly fair and if you talk to Nick you’ll get a couple cool stories from him as well. I’ve already recom...

4.60 (93 reviews) (~9.1 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Thrift stores in West New York, United States