Hidden gems: Pizza delivery services in New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York. This list contains 55 places from Pizza delivery service category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Categories


Leonardo’s Pizza image
1
Leonardo’s Pizza
Pizza delivery
$$ $$
5.00 (58 reviews)
Serra Provisions image
2
Serra Provisions
Italian grocery store
👍👍 Super quality food! Have ordered from Serra Provisions twice now and everything is high quality with attention to details. You can really tell that the person that made this put a lot of loving care in making the food. Ordered the clam pizza and eating it is like a dream- the crust is thin, but chew...
4.90 (121 reviews)
Pizza Fenice image
3
Pizza Fenice
Pizza restaurant
$$ $$
4.90 (119 reviews)
Tommy B's Slice Shop image
4
Tommy B's Slice Shop
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This place made my day. I was having a really bad week and stopped in the lot, the open sign was off but a woman stuck her head out to tell me they were still doing slices! I whipped around and bought a slice and she and the chef gave me two slices for free as they were about to close. You have no i...
4.90 (75 reviews)
The Pizza Shoppe image
5
The Pizza Shoppe
Pizza restaurant
$$ $$
4.90 (69 reviews)
Six South Pizza, LLC image
6
Six South Pizza, LLC
Pizza delivery
👍👍 I have to be the pickiest pizza eater on the planet. I was stunned the first time I had their pizza it was incredible! Without a doubt the best pizza around and I have tried everyone's. The dough is amazing and the sauce is top notch. Can't wait to try everything on the menu. Would highly reccommend...
4.90 (58 reviews)
The Pacific Street Pizza Co. image
7
The Pacific Street Pizza Co.
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Amazing restaurant and the staff were very nice! Me and my friend came for the first time today and they were very friendly. We asked about the potato croquettes but didn’t end up getting them, but at the end they ended up giving it to us for free!! So nice of them to do that. The pizza and garlic k...
$$ $$
4.90 (56 reviews)
Sbarro image
8
Sbarro
Pizza restaurant
Italian fast-food chain offering thin-crust pizza by the slice, plus pastas & salads.
$ $$$
4.80 (119 reviews)
GG's Pizza image
9
GG's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
4.80 (106 reviews)
Purple Monster Pizza image
10
Purple Monster Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Gluten free delight! My daughter is gluten free and Purple Monster made her day. Not just the best best GF pizza we’ve ever had, but also had fantastic fried GF breadsticks! Also got the wings with a few different sauces, and they were delightfully crisp. Thank you! 👍🏼
$ $$$
4.80 (81 reviews)
Sapori's Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen image
11
Sapori's Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen
Restaurant
😠 I wish you could leave 0 stars. We ordered an $88.00 dinner for my family Slice delivers our order. The girl spills the 2 Linguine & clam sauce all over everything, comes to our door tells us she spilled it. We refuse it because everything is covered in clam sauce she gets nasty. long story sho...
$$ $$
4.80 (51 reviews)
Wegmans Meals 2GO image
12
Wegmans Meals 2GO
Delivery Restaurant
4.80 (12 reviews)
Carmine & Sons image
13
Carmine & Sons
Sports bar
Relaxed sports bar (est. 1979) for wood-fired pizza with varied toppings, with pints, wine & TVs.
4.70 (123 reviews)
Village Pizza & Pasta image
14
Village Pizza & Pasta
Pizza restaurant
😐 Great tasting pizza!!! Just wish there Sicilian slices were bigger. ( They are on the very small side, but taste delicious ) My 5yr old can eat 2 of them, anywhere else he can't even finish one Sicilian slice!! ****please make them bigger 🤗
$$ $$
4.70 (121 reviews)
Fratelli Pizza & Pasta image
15
Fratelli Pizza & Pasta
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great pizza as well as dishes. My favorite is the cajun chicken pie and their chicken francese is excellent. Great owners and staff.. Sadly the owner past away but his son is a chip off the old block and is super appreciative of his customers. Highly recommend.
4.70 (117 reviews)
Mezzaluna Pizzeria & Restaurant image
16
Mezzaluna Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great food. Service is top notch. They are so friendly. I highly recommend this place. The owner is one of the nicest people I ever met. No matter what you order you will not be disappointed
$ $$$
4.70 (79 reviews)
Fire on Main Brick Oven Kitchen image
17
Fire on Main Brick Oven Kitchen
Restaurant
4.70 (78 reviews)
Nelly’s Chicken & Pizza image
18
Nelly’s Chicken & Pizza
Fried chicken takeaway
$ $$$
4.70 (62 reviews)
Classico Pizzeria image
19
Classico Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Excellent Pizza and really nice staff. The Tri-color grandma pie might be my new favorite slice of pizza anywhere. Will definitely be returning!
$$ $$
4.70 (58 reviews)
Teal Kitchen & Cafe image
20
Teal Kitchen & Cafe
Brunch restaurant
👍👍 We almost didn't find this little eatery because it's tucked away inside an office building, and that would have been a shame because the food was delicious and reasonably priced, and the people were absolutely lovely. Highly recommended!
$ $$$
4.70 (33 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities in New York

Last updated: