Been going here for years. Although their pizzas aren't as good as they used to be, they're still a good choice. Great gyros, the people are always nice. Very disappointed that they no longer have delivery available. I know this has to be bad for business. Also try the subs, they never disappoint. I'd for sure give them a 5 star if they'd bring back the delivery service for those of us who have no cars.

Pizza is not as good as it was in the late 90 to early 2000. Under cooked just not good. I’m not sure how they don’t understand what a cooked pizza looks like. Ordered a sub that was cold which was cooked also not enough. $20 for an extra large pizza is a rip off for the poor quality you get. Store bought pizza was better than this one.

Probably the worst pizza on the South in of Columbus. No taste, under cooked and hardly any pepperoni. $15.99 for a soggy piece of cardboard. Never again

Last night we placed an orderThat was delivered by Uber We received the wrong order. Apparently the driver had two orders From Stoney's to deliver and mixed them up..Tried contacting the driver immediately Could not so Called Stoney's And they informed me about the driver and the two orders and that I needed to call Uber because they handed off the correct orderOf course I tried but the 1-800 number for Uber which was in "no communication mode" Whatever that means..so no help from either side and we were left high&dry..we were missing our pizza sub &salad And the pizza was not only dry(no sauce basically) the lid was stuck in cheese&pep..I think that when a driver has two orders from the same place they shud mark the box& bag with the house number..and since Stoneys does receive the $they shud find a way to help customers. Part 2 Last Saturday evening was Slammin...tonight OMG! AWFUL WE PICKED THIS TIME 1ST TIME THERE..We ordered our usual Pizza sub, which was not cooked all the way an very dry, steak sub,an meatball sub, which was mostly bread very few meatballs. Their pizza subs are open face He had made a closed Big difference I told him it should have been open face like always and he said he does not make him like that I told him but Stoneys does And I told him I didn't want it So he took the sub back and slammed it in the trash made a new one open faced but it sucked i had to put in my oven finish to cooking still not good cuz I asked for extra sauce ,my favorite thing about Stoney's, the reason I order..was so dry..I feel I'm wasting $ they have nvr offer to fix anything just wasted $

I have never had a Pizza as bad as this pizza! First time ever getting pizza here ,i get it home and its not even cut!!!! No sauce,,soggy,paid for extra toppings barley any,NO taste at all, 20 freaking dollars and cant even eat it...I have had frozen pizza from Family Dollar taste better....I even ask them if it was frozen they said no!! I like the store and people but do better on the pizza,I cant see me buying any more from here.

Love the carry out and drive through. Cigs are cheaper and they have some basic things you need. The food you can order I'm not a big fan of, but some people really love it so probably a taste thing.

Great store that's been there forever. Haven't had the food for a while but the pizza subs were amazing back when I worked close. Good selection of items in store too!

We tried Stoney’s for the first time tonight. Pizza was very good; a little thicker crust than I normally prefer, but still quite good. Also tried the wings and fried mushrooms. Both were very good. We will definitely return!

They have Code Red Mt. Dew ZERO. I'm a happy (slightly diabetic) cherry soda person now.

Been Alive 34 years and always remember my Grandma Jenny Lymn Paugh working for Victor, making pizzas in the kitchen, oh and the best gravy and biscuits in town. Miss then days.