The new owners have done an amazing job. The wings are incredible, and the atmosphere is really nice, much better than before. It's definitely worth re visiting.

Update My friend told me to try again and yes they where the jumbo wing with lots of flavour 5 starrs Whent there for wings and they where the smallest wings

Tuesday wing night used to be minimum of 6 at 75c each..now it's 8..i could hardly finish 6 so 8 is too much for me and we are not allowed to take any home..celery and carrot (2 thin slices about 4" long" $1.50 and you have to pay $1.50 for the dip - 1 oz ..quite pricey for 4 thin strips of vegs) previously i got more than 4 strips but this week i got only 4 so $3 for 4 strips??...and you HAVE to purchase a beverage...not suitable for me who is trying to minimize sugar intake and who dies not drink alcohol.

Open late | Tuesday wing specials | Drink specials | Patio seating | ATM | Darts | TVs 3rd update of my review (most recent one was 2018 February) Came in on Tuesday at 11:15pm and they were still opened with wing special available. They said last call at 12:45am. There were only 3 customers left inside. They offered a "late night menu" though. Late night menu include but not limited to: salads, bruschetta, chicken rolls, calamari, potato skins, wings, chicken fingers, poutine, onion rings etc. Tuesday wing specials are 99 cent with minimum order of 6 wings per order. MENU SAYS they come with carrots and celery, and your choice of ranch/ dill/ blue cheese dressing. ... We only got wings and nothing else. BUT maybe that's the regular late night menu and Tuesday wing specials don't include it .... We ordered a ranch sauce after .... Wing sauces: - Wet (BBQ, honey garlic, medium, hot, suicide, sweet chilli, Jamaican jerk, teriyaki, hot-honey) - Dry (Cajun, Juanita, lemon pepper, salt & pepper [Extra sauce $1.00, split flavours $1.00, carrots & celery $3] They have a variety of Molson beers on tap. The overall feel is still the same. My last review said the wings were ok sized but wings were dry and felt refried. A year later, I feel the same. They were about 2" in length and even with wet sauce (I ordered hot honey and medium) they were still dry and hard. They were nice and hot though. The medium was barely spicy though. The dry Cajun was very dry buy barely Cajun .... We were also not given a bucket for bones. With 4 orders of wings our plates were filled with bones and unable to use it without combining the wing baskets so that we can use one for bones. There was only one server for the whole restaurant. She was sweet. Overall I'm a bit disappointed that there's no improvement in wings quality or false advertising of carrots/celery and dressing being included. But happy they stay open late and still offer the special.

Food value and portions are great Taste was amazing Madison what’s a great host for the family Recommend

Been going here for just about ~8 years - it was great back then, and is just about better in every way now. Very great staff, delicious food, decent pricing, ridiculously good wings (go on Tuesdays!). Great music too. Highly recommend coming here. Very likely the best pub in the area.

Firstly, the service was great! The food was well presented and tasted delicious as well, especially the fish and chips. We rented the party hall, which looked fantastic and offered a fulfilling experience. Would definitely recommend!

Love what the new management has done with the place, the wings continue to be the best in Markham, recommend 100%

Great service, cozy atmosphere, good food. Can’t ask for any more than that!

Server was fantastic.. super healthy meal choices with traditional pub fare!! Loved it. Would HIGHLY RECOMMEND a stop here for yummy eats!!

Great and friendly staff, amazing wings. Wild wing has nothing on col's. We're here every Thursday after hockey and will keep coming back!

It was an amazing experience and I would recommend it to anyone to sit relax and enjoy their food

We had such a good time at Col. Mustard. The service was excellent, and the food was absolutely delicious. Will recommend this place to everyone. Keep up the good work!

A solid pub with great wing deals on Tuesday. Food is good, and tv's are set up well for games etc

The waitress was very good. Quick to take our order. The food was delicious. We found the water they served had a strong strange taste and also the cleaners they used had a very strong smell.

Good family restaurant. Chicken wings are plump and done well. A variety of items available on the menu. Band plays on certain days. Parking available on site.

The Mustards team made my day last week. They were the ONLY restaurant in the area willing to being my order out to my car. The big establishment chains refused to do so. The service here is exceptional!!!

Food was excellent and lots of it. Service was very good. Been a while since I was there, but will be back soon due to this positive experience.

Fast customer service of the highest quality. Was pleasantly surprised by the food, particularly the Chicken Parmesan and the Mediterranean Zucchini Noodle Pasta. Pricing for a 2 person meal was same as other restaurants one person meal. Kyla also did a good job in terms of the speed the food was prepared at and served. Definitely recommend!

Recently stopped in as we use to come all the time but hadn't been in awhile. The new menu is great! I had the salmon dinner the portion was big and very tasty. Our server Vanessa was a pleasure and very attentive. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back

Very nice staff and great drink options

The kitchen took longer than I would have liked, but Col. Mustard's delivered a reasonable seafood pasta to me. The place had a nice neighborhoodsy feel, which in my books is a plus.

Good quesidilla

Great food and great staffs 👍

Wings and service were great! Menus need to be clean.

Typical pub ....dirty table after being seated and menu well falling apart and dirty and probably from the day they opened cmon ......if I'm every thay way again I'd go elsewhere to eat ....

At the first moment you come to this place the stuff gives you an enjoyable feeling. Very congenial team, it is a good restaurant to pass time with friends or with your date. very good meals, experienced chef de cuisine, modest price and attentive service. Highly recommended.

Very nice staff Friendly and warm a went there on a Tuesday For the jumbo wing day special did not disappoint hope the have more great cold beer