Very nice patio and great looking donuts. That's about it, we arrived and the staff were a little rude, almost like they'd rather us not be there? The pizza itself was covered in honey, which made it altogether way too sweet. The garlic sauce didn't taste like garlic at all. Was more like watery ranch with way too much thyme in it. We tried 5 different pizzas that day from different places in Toronto and this was agreed by all party members as the least favourite place we visited.

Pizza here is good but there are a few things that could be better. The mushroom garlic pizza was by far the favorite in my group as it was the crispiest with good undercarriage. The dough is very flavorful, chef did a good job cold fermenting. Only feedback is that the flavors need to balance more. The pickled onion and balsamic glaze overwhelmed the essence of mushroom and garlic. Perhaps remove onion in favor of onion jam and the balsamic glaze in favor of black truffle oil. The basil which was visually pleasing has no place on this pie. 7.7/10 The sausage onion pie was the least favorite. Hot honey didn't go well with the other toppings and the pie felt heavy. The bake on the crust was not very crispy and got soggy fast. It looked underbaked compared to the previous. The pepperoni and mushroom pizza was a bit bland. The pepperoni didn't stand out and the tomato sauce was on the sweeter side. Overall, I recommend this place as ambience is top notch and heard the bakery is incredible.

I was surprised to see they had a small donut section available as soon as you walk in! The staff are friendly and local. Sit anywhere and order your food through the QR code, pay with your phone (so no need to wait for server to order) & the food gets brought to your table. I really enjoyed their Caesar salad! The dressing was much lighter & balanced well with the pizza (they are huge).

So excited to finally experience The Fourth Man In The Fire Pizzeria! Does not disappoint:) Service is 10/10 - Staff is friendly, courteous & accommodating. Pizza is great, not the best but great! Pizza is really large & doughy & soft and delicious. (If you like thick crust pizza, definitely for you). Atmosphere is not restaurant type, but more cafeteria-like. Just simple tables with 4 chairs. Not a large space but it gives off a comfortable vibe. Would surely recommend! P.s. No donuts were available at this time.

Amazing place! The service was great, I don't know the name of the lady that helped us, possibly the owner, but she was wonderful and helped us right away if we had any questions! The food, I couldn't take a proper photo because I was too excited and ate half the pizza before i could remember to take a good photo but I had a photo of the freshness of the ingredients used to make the pizza! While you're eating they also tempt you with donuts as they make it in front of you! A little bit on the pricier side but definitely worth the taste, the freshness and the service!! Coming back here soon!

Came here for the second time with friends , great spot for lunch and easy to share! Highly recommend the real American hero sandwich, it’s a big portion but delicious! Fourth man hands down has the best apple fritter in town so you have to finish off your meal with one. Pizza is also decent but again big portion. Short haired lady working at the front is awesome!

I really enjoyed having lunch here. I liked how casual it was and you could tell just from the walk in clientele that it’s a beloved local spot. You can be seated or takeout, but eating in is a hybrid of the server bringing you your drinks/food but you order it all on your phone. We got a pizza and a sandwich, and it was a lot of food for two people. We enjoyed both the items we got, but I preferred the sandwich to the pizza. The fresh bread was incredible, the tang from the balsamic was perfect with the saltiness from the meat. I would go back just for this sandwich. The service was also so friendly and we didn’t feel rushed, very chill.

Good pizza and make sure to check their "dine-in only" specials. Great for groups who just want some pizza and salad. Also it will be hard to leave if they are making donuts while you're dining - it smells so good!

I saw those pizzas being served as I walked back home and well I couldn't resist, I went there for dinner two days later. Aside from the phenomenal staff who provided an exceptional service, the pizza is an absolute must have. The ingredients are fresh and definitely considered quality ingredients given the real flavour you get with every bite. The dough is just right, light and crunchy topped with tasty marinara sauce and cheese. Prices may seem steep but then again this is not fast food, this is the real deal and at 29$, the 18inch freshly made pizza is worth every penny. Unfortunately we were too full to grab a donut and by donut I mean oversized scrumptious sweeet filled donuts!

Would give 4.5 if I could. Wonderful spot, generous portions, lovely service and vibe. Get the donuts on your way out - they don’t disappoint. Pizza here is solid, the zesty-ness of the sauce is great.

Overly hyped & overly priced! It was just O.K. We got half garlic mushroom & margarita. They don’t do different base sauce so we had garlic sauce as the base which was obviously odd for a margarita pizza. The hot honey was meh. One of the serves was kind to take our order on the table. The service was crazy slow, had to ask different servers to get the bill at least 5 times. I had high hopes, maybe I’ll give it another shot sometime in the future.

Pizza was simple yet delicious, the accompanying spicy honey sauce was a perfect addition. Mozzarella sticks were crispy and cheese pull was very satisfying. Service was also fantastic, highly recommend!

This place was amazing! They had the best Caesar salad we have ever had it was made with homemade croutons and real bacon and fresh parmesan. The sauce was so delicious and nothing like I've ever had before. The pizza is Wood fired baked and was so delicious and flavorful the sauce and the cheese was so yummy 🤤. They also make homemade fresh donuts that melt in your mouth. Staff were very friendly and welcoming. We will definitely be back next time at visiting Toronto 🙂