The pizza was fantastic tasting. It's SO BIG!! My only request would be that the dough would be a little thicker in the center, so when you hold it, it stays firm for eating. Other than that, everything was AWESOME!!

Recently 8/2021 ordered a bunch of pizzas for a rehearsal dinner in Post Falls. Pizza was excellent. I pre-ordered and it was all ready as planned. Guests all enjoyed it. Love that this business is pro law enforcement. Good job New York Pizza Dept.

Im from the east coast, and i know pizza. The pizza here, unfortunately, was like bland paper. The chicken topping was horrid and likely frozen. I couldn't taste any spices or garlic in the sauce, which was also too sweet and more like tomato paste in several places. Even the bacon had no flavor. I hope they make some changes, because I really like this place, and the staff is excellent.

Came in to have some authentic NY pizza by the slice, and was not disappointed! If you want delicious giant pizzas and a fun, laid back atmosphere, look no further than New York Pizza Department. I will definitely be coming back!

Ordered online for take-out. Mess up online and pizza was not yet ready. All sorted and pizza was piping 🔥 hot, aromatic and finally delicious.

Very good pizzas, it’s expensive though: a large pizza is 30 dollars or mor. sauce and cheese are high quality. sometimes not cooked long enough, I’d prefer slightly burnt to slightly doughy. Always have to ask for ‘well done bake’ here.

Love their pizza but the prices went up and they are skimping on the toppings. I bought a medium and it was $28 and there were barely any pepperoni on it.

I thought the pizza was ok, needed to be cooked a little longer. The wings are really good!!! This place is very expensive but worth it for the amount of food you get. The staff are not too chatty but I prefer that. It's very clean inside. The bathrooms are far away in a out of site long hallway so watch your children as always.

We stumbled onto this little gem after viewing the live nativity reenactment at the state line speedway. The service was amazing. The food was even better. We showed up half an hour before closing and the staff was very accommodating and made the best pizza I've had in a long time!

Super thanks to this business as they provided free meals to the group of people with The People's Convoy, pizza, salad and drinks! It was a full house and so appreciated by all that were there. The food tasted great too. I had two different slices of pizza with chicken. Both were wonderful.

First time experience. The employees were very friendly. We got the 18 inch pizza. I really liked the size options! We enjoyed the pizza but noticed something interesting, it tasted even better the next day! The smell of the pizza reminded me of Shakeys pizza of the past, my favorite! I thought the crust could use just a little sweetness but it was good. The texture was perfect and thankfully the crust was not burnt! Good pizza!

Pizza was not very good, I had the lunch special, A pre made cheese pizza that they throw your choice of toppings and then reheat not ideal. I'd prefer they just have a set choice of hot pizzas to choose from but suspect it still would be pretty bland.

Omg I have no picture proof of the food.... But this pizza 🍕 is OVER THE TOP DELICIOUS 😋!! Huge and inexpressive, too!! 5 Stars!! We love their pizzas, their cheese bread, the root beer, their indoor dining, wow!! They are very patriotic, too. Lots of flags with thin lines of color and if you ask what they're for they can give you a handout that describes them all... Support police, military, medics, fire department, etc. If you like alcohol there's no shortage of beverages there in person as well. Please spread the word about this place!! It used to be over on the 41. This is a bit off the beaten path but with enough word of mouth we can support them here too. God bless!! Hubby captured a couple pics of the place as I was checking out. Check it out when you can. Thanks.

Same delicious Nates pizza. Still love the lunch special...giant slice of yum!

We absolutely love and highly recommend this pizza! Hands down the best we have had! We never take home leftovers... it is that good! The staff is friendly and responsive! Very clean and the food is fresh.

If I could give them more stars I would. I didn't realize they were about to close and placed an order. They quickly and happily made it anyway when they had every right to turn me away. I asked for extra cheese and boy did they deliver! Such hard working ladies, I'll definitely go back!

So I was really hoping to find a good pizza place other then wood fire pizzas in town. Someplace where the pizza is smothered with real cheese, a good sauce and a lot of meat. I really really was hoping. When we walked in you would think the fresh smell of pizzas in the oven would smack ya in the face. Didn't happen. What did smack us in the face was the over powering smell of Cigar Smoke from next door. We took a seat closet to the door in hopes to minimize the overpowering smell. We ordered the Wallstreet, couple of beers and a salad. Gotta say the salad was great, beer was great. The pizza was so so. Like I said I really wanted this place to work. Finally found the sausage in the pizza and it was minced and very fine pieces and couldn't really taste it, really lite pizza sauce (couldn't really taste it) salami was awesome and very little pepperoni. For me it was like eating a good pizza dough with little flavor. Took the pizza home, put it in the fridge thinking maybe better cold? NOT Really sorry guys Just being honest. Oh and the wife had a headache all night from the cigar smoke.

We used to get pizza at Nate’s when they were on highway 41. The best pizza!!! I Ordered a mushroom pizza & it was a huge disappointment. The mushrooms were so very scant & the sauce & cheese didn’t taste right, not fresh. Perhaps it was an off day or new owners?

Stopped in for lunch, there was a great special. Slice and a drink for $7! Look at the size of this slice ! With up to 5 added toppings. Also bar and draft beer 🍻

Great pizza place. I’ve been here several times, sometimes with my family as well as co-worker. The only minus is they have been short staffed, but then again who isn’t?

People were great and the pizza was delicious! You can easily feed a family of five with their large pizza and have some left over!

The staff are all great and friendly, they get your food out as quickly as possible. I like how the owner supports the police department.