I went here twice today, once for lunch and once for dinner. For lunch I had the crafted beer burger and a couple of the dark craft beers on hand. For dinner I had the double deckeroni pizza with Mac and cheese bites to start. Out of any Boston pizza, pizza joint or pizza place I’ve had in Canada and the continental U.S this has to be the finest location to eat at out there. Food had tons of flavour, cooked perfect, homemade tastes and textures. I had Tina for a server and she was 15/10. Thanks to everyone at this Rock springs location it will be my only place to stop when I come through every week.

Pizza is pretty good but pricey in my opinion. Don’t go expecting to get just a pepperoni pizza, it’s a trick to get anything basic. The seating is nice. Service is very good. TVs aplenty showing videos and sports. Good but not great.

The nachos are really good, and the ambience is on point. This is a great place to drink or get a burger. The service was great, and everyone seemed to be doing their best. That being said, the pizza was incredibly disappointing to this midwesterner. It’s not authentic Chicago-style pizza, for sure. I’d recommend getting literally anything else on the menu.

This pizza restaurant is very elegant. It’s like a breath of fresh air, especially from going on a trip in the west parts of America. Keep in mind that the streets are busy with traffic and walking across the street requires skill and effort. Inside the restaurant you will find bright lights, nice shadows, and many strong colors. For my meal, I was starting off with Bavarian pretzel sticks. The Bavarian pretzel sticks are excellent, fine, and savory to respectable texture. It’s one of the best pretzels you can get in America’s west. But for my main meal I was really enjoying myself with their Chicago 7 Stromboli. Consider the Stromboli like it’s a giant pizza sandwich! Very delicious, very savory. My refills of diet cola were helping me for the easy dining experience. There’s a lot of space inside the restaurant. With enough space, I feel more comfortable with the environment after a long trip. The night was a good one for a good dinner. Waiters around the restaurant were pretty friendly and were assistive suggestions of care and help. There are hotels in this area of Wyoming although the streets can be tricky to navigate. The Stromboli was really packed with meat and sauce. It was a crunchy sandwich with a great deal of stuff. The Bavarian pretzel sticks included a rich cheese dip that was convenient for delicate plates. You can’t miss the place! The place is easy to find at night. Most business locations in the area will have glowing lights leading up to Old Chicago Store. The pizza restaurant has a glowing red image. It’s a place that specializes in drinks and finger foods, even if there’s always utensils and easy-going manners. There’s plenty of walking space in the restaurant and it’s close to important options for a road trip. Stromboli really does taste like a pizza. Waffle fries with ranch might as well be separate from the giant pizza sandwich because of the strong ranch flavor and the hot, crispy texture of their own. The pretzel sticks were nice and salty. Everything was looking wonderful on my table. I was feeling quite exhausted from the road trip and I still feel the memory today. The restaurant has a big variety of drinks. I was careful about drinking during the road trip for safety reasons. A lot of people come to this restaurant and that helps with the vibrations of atmosphere and friendly noise. I can’t say enough about this restaurant! It’s a unique location with specific plates of delight.

Enjoyed our dinner with a calzone, pretzel sticks with beer cheese and mushrooms. It was all very tasty, warm and soft. Staff very welcoming and our server, Michelle was great. She made our dinner enjoyable and relaxing. Thank you Michelle for giving us input on portion size and even had the calzone split so we could each have our own piece. We got right in and didn’t wait long for service and food.

Had a lovely waitress (Alyssa) whom we had a good conversation while we dined here. Beer on tap was good.

First time at Old Chicago. The food was very good, prices are decent, the service was a bit slow but we did visit on a Saturday night while there was a soccer tournament in town. The pizza was definetly my favorite...try the Italian grinder pizza 👌🏽

Food was delicious, I stated in the holiday Inn, and this was the only place open at my dinner time. Beer was tasty.

The service was lousy, but the food was great. No refills, never checked to see how everything was and never cleared the dirty dishes. I know service varies and that won't keep me from going back. Awesome pizzas.

Good food and service. More of a nice sports bar than an old pizza place!

Fast and friendly service- wings were crispy and delicious- just the right amount of sauce - Chicago 7 with ale crust was awesome! Plenty servings - spaghetti and huge meatballs, mozzarella sticks, Thai salad was delicious

My husband & I arrived at approximately 2:30 today to a fairly full parking lot. We were greeted immediately and informed we could sit at the bar without a hostess, or a booth with. We chose the bar. Everything was nice and clean and fresh, and the bartender was very nice and was very prompt in assisting us. We ordered a couple beers and 2 individual pizzas. Everything was great! Best pizza around by far and a wonderful selection of beer on tap. We will definitely be back!

Great almost brand new Old Chicago. My favorite sit down pizza and beer place. The food is good, but I varied off my standard and tried the Italian Sandwich, which was good but a little too much for me. The service was good but you could tell they are short handed. Our server appeared to be one of three or four with numerous backups that weren’t actually backing up. I loved the atmosphere though and the feel of the restaurant especially the water feature on the way in. It made the hot Wyoming day feel a little bit cooler. The kids loved the food and the Calzone was perfect.

The food was excellent. I highly recommend Old Chicago. The staff was very professional, courteous and friendly. The restaurant was very clean and presentable. Prices are very fair. If I travel through this area again I will certainly stop and eat here; loved it.

Friendly, laid back place. Nice server. I ate on the flower surrounded patio at a table with a fireplace. I ordered the Old Chicago Chopped Salad. Some of the lettuce was not fresh. I had to pull out a few gone leaves, but all in all it was yummy. 2 hours later my stomach was not well. From what, I'm not sure. I wonder how clean the kitchen is, as the menus were not clean.

You shouldn’t be charging almost $7 for a cheesecake with “fresh berries” if you’re gonna give us just some plain cheesecake. Even cheesecake by itself tastes old.

Requested well done n crispy please, received the soggy doughy not fully cooked pizza. Never or ever recommend this place unless you like wet limp pizza. The pepperoni Boyes contained maybe half a piece of pepperoni.... Not a happy man, will eat it though, spent money and hungry after a hard days work. Should have stuck with plan a, make a couple sandwiches.

Dinner was delicious! We got an OC Chicago 7 pizza with green olives instead of black, manicotti, and artichoke dip. Service on the other hand was quite slow. It took 30 minutes to get our food. I would go back though.

We arrived around 8:00 pm on a Saturday with my family of 5 and they were fairly busy, but we were seated right away. We came here hoping for a deep dish pie, like AJ Barellis style, but for one thing, they were out of deep dish crusts. And for two, I don’t think the deep dish was what we were hoping for. Started with spicy fried pickles, which was basically a Cajun seasoned fried pickle served with ranch. and was really good. Little kick, but not too much. Also had the artichoke dip. Super creamy and delicious, but we kinda missed the flavor you usually get with spinach artichoke dips. It was served with some sliced bell peppers, cucumbers and tortilla chips. Pizza was a good texture and flavor, but nothing to write home about. The kids had Hawaiian, I had the Thai pizza, which had a pretty sweet sauce and some chicken and veggies, including broccoli, which I thought was a little weird, but tasted ok. Not a good leftover morning pizza. All in all, we had a good experience, but was a little annoyed at the music videos playing on a few of the TV’s. I know it’s a sports bar, but my kids were exposed to some artistic choices I’d rather not have them see. Sorry about the pictures. We were hungry.

This place is special. Was very surprised when I found out my hotel had a restaurant attached to it. That meant I didn't have to walk out in the cold to get something to eat. I can honestly say everything I ordered over the course of three days was good. Their specialty was pizza and they did not disappoint. You can actually pick what kind of dough you want with all your topping. The onion rings were fire too along with the chicken wings and the service was great. The atmosphere was livid. Especially on the weekends.

My food wasn't great and the wait was longer than I would prefer. The atmosphere and decor were nice.