Got their “famous” steak and cheese pizza. While I think it does taste great and was super cheesey, we paid $7 for extra meat to be on it and there was honestly almost no meat and 99% mushrooms. Our total bill was almost $70 after tip for a mushroom pizza essentially. I’m really disappointed because we’ve seen lots of pictures and reviews about how great it is but it was just way overpriced for what it was. Overall I won’t be ordering from them again unfortunately.

Finally caved and ordered the Famous Steak Pizza with toppings of plenty (steak, mushrooms, onions and peppers). Crust was cooked to perfection. Staff were very friendly and polite. I would definitely recommend this pizza joint for your next Italian pie :D

Save your hard earned money and go somewhere else. This place is a rip off. I made an order based on a deal I saw advertised on the website and on their physical menu. When I went to pay for my order, it was a different price than advertised. I understand prices are rising but you have to be honest with your customers. Doesn’t help the person working the counter said “our prices are always going up” with a smile on her face. The quality of the pizza does not reflect the price. Go to one of the other places in town with honest prices.

Ordered a half cheese half pepperoni pizza and a steak pizza. There was a mix up and somehow our order was forgotten, but kudos to the owner for fixing it - we did eventually get our order and found that the entire thing had been paid for (we were told we'd only get a discount). The cheese/pepperoni pizza was just ok, and the steak pizza was good although it was barely warm by the time it got to us. If it was fresh I'm sure it would have been amazing. I'd be willing to try the steak pizza again but only for pick up. Impressed with how the owner corrected the issue 😊

We ordered the party tray and wing special, took over an hour to arrive and our pizza was wrong(my kids wouldn’t eat it), my brother in law pulled a long hair off his slice, and we didn’t receive our blue cheese and veggies. Despite all this, when I called to inform them, they were very apologetic and sent us another tray pizza with the correct toppings, and four bags veggies and blue cheese and it arrived in a speedy manner and it was delicious. I also received another call for another apology. Thankful for the correction and the overall actions of the employees and it completely changed my mood from upset to understanding.

What an amazing experience ordering for a basketball team while in town. They were very helpful and friendly and went out of the way to make sure we got our pizza after a late game. So impressed!!!

Ordered the steak pizza in a party tray. Was pretty good Lots of toppings and super thick edge of crust. Was abit to much mushrooms to everything else ratio though. Ill will however order again and the staff was super nice when i picked it up

I have ordered about 20 pies from Angelina's. The quality of the pie has hit an all time low. My last three pies have had almost no cheese or sauce on them and the toppings are non existent. You need a magnifying glass to find them. Not exaggerating at all. When picking up the last few times I notice the individual making my pie was very young. I asked to have the pie well done and it was short of being just regularly done. Very disappointed, the pie was terrible and with that said believe it or not I am holding back from what I want to say.

We were staying two nights in Welland and my wife is gluten free/vegan. I told her I bet there's a good little sleeper pizzeria we can doordash from. My wife said it was the best gluten free pizza she ever had. My pizza was also what I'd expect from a genuine pizzeria. No gimmicks, just great pizza.

I've tried these guys 3 times and haven't been overly impressed. Pizza toppings are good, but crust seems to have no strength to hold it together. It just seems to fold up, which is okay if that's how you like yours. The Cajun wings (I tried only once) were flavourless. I'm not sure if they just forgot the seasoning, but they tasted plain. Hot were okay flavour-wise. They were on the small side each time. I wouldn't order wings there again. Can't imagine returning.

Easily my go to pizzeria in town. We normally get a party tray and poutine for family of 5, always tastes great and made fast! Staffs always super friendly & welcoming 😊

Does anybody remember the steak pizza they used to make? I used to buy one almost weekly. The steak pizza they make now is just nasty. Not at all like the original.

We paid $30..We had ordered 2 steak subs & there was not enough steak for 1 sub let alone two…definitely not like it used to be.. will never order from here again.. very disappointing..

Ill never order from here again!! I have given many many chances. Yes they give me a discount and fix my order but how many times can this happen and it’s honestly every single time I order from here. From being told certain times and go to pick up and have to wait another 30-40 mins because he messed up the pizza cause they are training which I get but can only use this excuse so many times. Last time I had a party I got two pizzas and wings , they messed up the pizzas so sent the wings and said would send the pizzas once they were fixed and done. Then today having my daughters birthday party called at 1:30 to pre order a party tray to be here for 6:30 and they don’t get here until 6:50!!!! And not to mention the holes left throughout the bottom of the pizza. Not impressed at all!!!

First time getting pizza from Angelina's...saw a post on Dain City FB group, and so glad I did! Excellent pizza! The way pizza is supposed to taste! When ordering, it was suggested to me to get a larger pizza with split toppings to save a few bucks, then was given 10% off as a Dain City resident!! Great customer service and well definitely order from here again! Thanks!

I usually love ordering from here! But today, they epically failed. The pizza box still the seal/sticker on it so I know it was an issue with the restaurant and not the delivery driver. But when I opened the box, this is how the pizza looked!! Disgusting.

Im not the one to write a google review nor actually care but I legit almost broke teeth trying to take a bite of the crust, I'm saying no more other than look at the photos and you tell me would you eat there? they do have some decent wing sauce though.