Top rated Pizza restaurants in Newmarket, Canada to elevate your visit (Updated July, 2023)

Top rated Pizza restaurants in Newmarket

Experience the best that Newmarket has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 145 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Newmarket

Pizza Hut

Pizza restaurant

Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.

$$ $$

4.90 (2.2K reviews) (~21.02 km from centre)

Pizza Break

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Pizza Break has the best pizza in the area! It’s way better than any of the popular pizza chains. The pizza dough is light and ingredients are fresh. A must try!

4.80 (516 reviews) (~26.32 km from centre)

Taste of Naples Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Taste of Naples Pizzeria is hugely popular for locals here with many Italians in the area. The 16” pizza yielded 8 large tasty slices with a soft light pizza crust, fresh tomato sauce & good topping ingredients. Crisp thin crust bottom gave a nice finish. This is a real Neopolitan pizza that’s a to...

$ $$$

4.80 (283 reviews) (~26.31 km from centre)

Belsito Trattoria

Restaurant

Comfortable, contemporary restaurant with a patio serving traditional Italian dishes & wine.

$$$ $

4.70 (659 reviews) (~27.18 km from centre)

Il Bistro Cafe & Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Modest strip-mall cafe featuring Italian fare such as pies, sandwiches & pasta plus take-out.

$ $$$

4.70 (272 reviews) (~2.1 km from centre)

Santino Pizza & Pasta

Italian restaurant

😐 Despite the sandwich tasting great I'd rather go somewhere that I'd feel welcomed. Staff need to work on their customer service skills and be a bit friendlier. The woman behind the till looks miserable as if she hates her job. Would not visit again.

4.70 (179 reviews) (~28.39 km from centre)

SOI Snacks

Thai restaurant

👍 SOI Snacks is an improved Thai fast food restaurant. I ordered a pizza with two toppings, since the Warriors lost yesterday, I decided to try green curry and Thai Northern sausage and egg. It was not very spicy but had a unique flavor that is definitely worth trying. For soup, I tried the creamy sou...

4.70 (118 reviews) (~21.92 km from centre)

Grill Gate

Hamburger restaurant

😐 I used to adore this restaurant, and it was almost my go-to place, visiting at least every other week since their first branch on Sheppard Street West. However, I'm disappointed to say that the quality of their food has declined. They even seem to skimp on the filling for their Philly steak sandwich...

$$ $$

4.60 (1.2K reviews) (~20.16 km from centre)

Ciao Roma Inc

Italian restaurant

Pies & slices of traditional Italian pizza are sold by their weight at this cozy option.

4.60 (652 reviews) (~28.95 km from centre)

Regino's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Tiny, no-frills outpost of a local chain dishing up wings & whole wheat, thick- & thin-crust pizzas.

$ $$$

4.60 (341 reviews) (~11.4 km from centre)

Cream n Sugar Cafe and Bistro

Cafe

😠 At the beginning I like this place. We ordered pizza, shawarma and the famous ice cream but there was a very bad issue when I ask for a cup of just hot water and the owner charge me $2.10 just for hot water, I’m very disappointed they lost a good costumer with this miserable detail.

4.60 (331 reviews) (~23.62 km from centre)

Palace Pizza & Spaghetti House

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 This place is GREAT!!!! We ordered food and it was like a little taste of Italy. Even the owners are super kind and authentic 😁. Sending a big wonderful shout out to Tola and George ! You guys are AWESOME 👌👏😎

$ $$$

4.60 (312 reviews) (~1.32 km from centre)

Quick Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 Not very quick and overpriced. If you are looking for cold pizza that takes over 1.5 hours to be delivered after it's been sitting in a car being driven around who knows where, this is the place to go. Sloppy delivery, dropped the dipping sauces which exploded in the bag. Terrible customer service,...

4.60 (196 reviews) (~18.61 km from centre)

Papillon Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Dine-in · Takeaway · No-contact delivery

4.60 (177 reviews) (~2.15 km from centre)

Slice Of Delight pizza & wings

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Came to this spot during my stay in Markham. Absolute banger. The owner was so sweet and the food was very tasty. They have a wide range of options for any dietary restrictions. 100% recommend if you're in the GTA area.

4.60 (124 reviews) (~29.22 km from centre)

Papa D's Pizza & Variety

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 The best, most delicious pizza I’ve ever tried since the time I moved to Canada. Their food and service was amazing. I love their pizza 🍕

$$ $$

4.60 (117 reviews) (~5.39 km from centre)

Ricci's Pizzeria & Sandwich Shoppe

Pizza restaurant

Generous portions of Italian comfort food in a strip-mall counter-serve with takeout & delivery.

$$ $$

4.50 (2.8K reviews) (~28.52 km from centre)

Slice of Fire Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Staff are very nice and patient. The Nutella is good. The cheese pizza is very good. The Hawaiian is excellent, full of toppings. Our family love everything. My kids don’t like the crust elsewhere, but they finished all. We will come back when we are craving for yummy pizza.

$$ $$

4.50 (746 reviews) (~25.65 km from centre)

Reginos Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Tiny, no-frills outpost of a local chain dishing up wings & whole wheat, thick- & thin-crust pizzas.

$ $$$

4.50 (744 reviews) (~27.68 km from centre)

Brick N Fire

Restaurant

👍👍 I have been here a number of times. I have referred and brought people here for dinner, and we have all loved it. Every time I go, I am always extremely pleased with the food and service. The portions are large, and the food is always served at the perfect temperature.

$$ $$

4.50 (588 reviews) (~10.98 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Pizza restaurants in Newmarket, Canada