Top rated Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Brooklyn

Experience the best that Brooklyn has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 1.2K places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Brooklyn

Campo di Bella

Italian restaurant

👍👍 We have worked with MaryAnn and Marc for many years planning corporate group events using our cheeses from Roth Cheese. They are incredible people to know and to work with - putting their heart and soul into each group that passes through their doors. Their food is as welcoming and excellent as thei...

5.00 (75 reviews) (~116.62 km from centre)

Ciro

Italian restaurant

5.00 (48 reviews) (~239.81 km from centre)

Sonny's Italian Kitchen

Italian restaurant

👍👍 I stopped by and ordered a breaded steak sandwich with hot peppers and it was sooooo good! I also had a side of their pasta salad, which was delicious as well. Everything is reasonably priced and the portions are good. Everyone was nice and friendly. The establishment was super clean. Give it a try....

5.00 (46 reviews) (~221.75 km from centre)

Q.P. Kitchen & Que

Barbecue restaurant

👍👍 Can’t go wrong with anything on the menu! Always creating delicious eats and serving it up hot and fresh! Also great staff to elevate the whole experience!

5.00 (32 reviews) (~192.8 km from centre)

Gustos Italian Eatery & Pub

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Y'all! I'm 29 years old and Gustos Italian Eatery & Pub made me cry tonight with 1 bite into the Chicken Bacon Flatbread. I had only ever cried over how good food was once before in my life. This. Place. Is. Phenomenal! - We ordered the spinach and artichoke dip for our appetizer. It was to die fo...

4.90 (172 reviews) (~109.26 km from centre)

D'Capos Authentic Italian Cuisine

Italian restaurant

👍 This place is located inside a gas station, that alone will deter most people from giving them a shot. All I have to say is, ignore where it's located and go give them a try. They have lots of delicious Italian pasta dishes, sandwiches and desserts at very reasonable prices. The meatball penne pasta...

4.90 (161 reviews) (~240.97 km from centre)

Piacere Mio Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

👍 So this is a hard one. I went here 2x in 1 week. 2 completely different experiences. My 1st trip a late packed Saturday night. On walking in, it was very smokey from the kitchen. Service was perfect, the food was amazing. Drinks hit the spot. But then I came 4 days later. I grab...

$$ $$

4.90 (128 reviews) (~240.02 km from centre)

Davanti Enoteca

Italian restaurant

$$ $$

4.90 (103 reviews) (~229.25 km from centre)

Cut Stone Foods - Pizzeria and Food Truck

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 It was so easy to order using toast! The crust of their pizza is so delicious. We got a kid’s cheese pizza and a margherita pizza with pepperoni. Excellent! The order was ready exactly when expected and pick up was quick.

$$ $$

4.90 (91 reviews) (~171.04 km from centre)

The Wasted Grain Bar

Cocktail bar

👍👍 They have amazing drinks the bartender was amazing and so were the owners I will definitely be going back!!

4.90 (64 reviews) (~196.79 km from centre)

Cansino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Great pizza, very tasty, fresh toppings. Most places around HP have jalapenos that are not fresh, their's are very tasty. Fries are also really good as is the Italian beef.

4.90 (54 reviews) (~205.78 km from centre)

Common Pasta

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Don’t be fooled by this unassuming food cart as they’ll deliver some of the most amazing pasta dishes which will even rival some of the most established Italian eateries in Madison. Prices are very fair given the generous portions, each dish is prepared to order, and the flavors are always spot on....

4.90 (45 reviews) (~92.01 km from centre)

Wall Street Gallery & Bistro

Italian restaurant

👍👍 What an amazing little restaurant. Everything is made from scratch in-house, so this might be the best pasta I've ever had. The bread is fabulous and the portions are perfect. The atmosphere is unique and private. The one employee, a polite and handsome high school boy, is an absolute delight and ha...

4.90 (39 reviews) (~98.76 km from centre)

Francesca's Famiglia

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Nice place. We were there for a post funeral supper and everything was very nice. Staff were great. Pasta and chicken were very good. Didn't care much for the dessert but it was visibly beautiful. It was a tough day for everyone but no problems from the restaurant. Thanks everyone.

$$ $$

4.80 (1.1K reviews) (~201.9 km from centre)

Santino's Little Italy

Italian restaurant

Traditional Neapolitan pizzas, plus pasta & drinks in a rustic setting with an 1890s Brooklyn vibe.

$$ $$

4.80 (1.1K reviews) (~129.33 km from centre)

Asti Italian Deli

Italian restaurant

No-frills eatery known for Italian standards like antipasto, pizza, sandwiches & desserts.

$$ $$

4.80 (924 reviews) (~226.97 km from centre)

The Original Nottoli & Son

Italian restaurant

Deli with unique homemade sausages, sandwiches & party trays, plus grocery with Italian staples.

$ $$$

4.80 (861 reviews) (~233.93 km from centre)

Euro Crepes and Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Low-key spot with checkered tablecloths for pizzas, pastas & gyros, plus savory & sweet crêpes.

$ $$$

4.80 (621 reviews) (~240.76 km from centre)

Lino Ristorante Italiano

Italian restaurant

Casual eatery with a patio & Sheboygan River views serving Italian seafood, pasta & meat dishes.

$$$ $

4.80 (536 reviews) (~104.79 km from centre)

Riga-Tony's Delicatezzi Italiano

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Riga-Tony’s Deli offers great meat,pastas,salads, pizza varieties, seafood, sauces, desserts, & hot foods to eat in or take out!! The Catering selections are sure to please! We love the helpful Staff. CHECK IT OUT YOU WONT BE DISAPPOINTED🥰

$$ $$

4.80 (506 reviews) (~142.04 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, United States