Top rated Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Brooklyn

Experience the best that Brooklyn has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 23 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Brooklyn

Press Pizza and Pasta

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Sweet gem Caesar salad is fresh, crunch, and De--licious!! The Italian sausage pizza is really good as well. The pizza dough is light and airy, there is no extra pizza crust to toss away. Pickle fennel is a perfect match with sausage meat. This is my favorite pizza store in St. Louis now. You have t...

$$ $$

4.90 (128 reviews) (~7.49 km from centre)

The Get Down

Bar

👍👍 This is a cool little corner bar with amazing sandwiches. The chicken Philly is a beast and really enjoyed the meatball sub too. Cool little patio with a disc golf goal and Jenga. A small place but everyone here wants to make sure you have a great experience. We will definitely be back!

4.80 (203 reviews) (~8.34 km from centre)

Riccardo's on Broadway

Italian restaurant

👍👍 The food and service were excellent! The calamari was lightly breaded and perfectly fried. The pasta had a plethora of seafood which was fantastic. The restaurant is off the beaten path. There is a large parking lot out back which felt very safe. There is a biker bar next door; the folks I intera...

4.80 (68 reviews) (~2.56 km from centre)

Sauce on the Side

Restaurant

👍👍 Rating: 4.8 Stars Despite being in St. Louis for years, this was my first time trying Sauce on the Side. Moreover, I have eaten very few calzones in my life. It was a mistake to wait this long on both. I ordered the Meat Me in St. Louie. It was excellent. The outside was cooked perfectly and had a...

$$ $$

4.70 (1.7K reviews) (~8.46 km from centre)

Sauce on the Side

Restaurant

👍👍 Nothing on their IG page looked appetizing, but once I visited this location, I was hooked. Puttanesca mushroom mix, Gonzo mushroom, and Cocoa doodle noodle. If these terms are unfamiliar to you, stop by sauce on the side and become acquainted.

$$ $$

4.60 (2.1K reviews) (~3.75 km from centre)

Guido's Pizzeria & Tapas

Italian restaurant

Mediterranean venue boasts a range of Italian & Spanish fare in a relaxed, welcoming setting.

$$ $$

4.50 (2K reviews) (~10 km from centre)

Lombardo's Trattoria

Italian restaurant

Longstanding, family-owned Italian eatery serving steaks, signature pasta & seafood.

$$$ $

4.50 (941 reviews) (~4.96 km from centre)

Café Piazza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Wonderful. I ordered take out, it was fresh hot delicious and fantastic. I would order from them everyday if I could. The pizza was light, fluffy, SEASONED and full of flavor. The spinach salad was great too. I would recommend this place to everyone hands down, Go and enjoy Cafe Piazza.

$$ $$

4.40 (773 reviews) (~8.01 km from centre)

Katie's Pizza & Pasta at Ballpark Village

Restaurant

👍👍 The place is beautiful. A lot more spacious than the Rock Hill location and the has some pretty badass art work throughout the place as well. They had an old Italian moving playing to set the vibes right! 🙌🏽 The food: everything was excellent, everything. Got two apps and that was enough for four...

$$ $$

4.40 (158 reviews) (~4.32 km from centre)

Pi Pizzeria - Central West End

Pizza restaurant

Hip pizzeria serving a menu of creative deep-dish & thin-crust pies, plus craft beers & cocktails.

$$ $$

4.30 (1.5K reviews) (~8.2 km from centre)

Vito's Sicilian Pizzeria & Ristorante

Italian restaurant

Family-owned Sicilian eatery serves up pizza & pasta, plus happy hour & an airy outdoor patio.

$$ $$

4.30 (840 reviews) (~5.96 km from centre)

Bar Italia

Italian restaurant

Italian menu options including housemade gelato in an airy trattoria with a separate lounge.

$$ $$

4.30 (467 reviews) (~8.36 km from centre)

The Old Spaghetti Factory

Italian restaurant

Family-friendly chain eatery featuring traditional Italian entrees amid turn-of-the-century decor.

$$ $$

4.20 (3.4K reviews) (~3.28 km from centre)

Rigazzi's

Italian restaurant

Clubby Italian-American joint, decked with celebrity memorabilia & known for its pizza & cocktails.

$$ $$

4.20 (2.1K reviews) (~9.9 km from centre)

Imo's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

No-frills chain specializing in St. Louis-style pies with thin crusts & Provel cheese.

$$ $$

4.20 (545 reviews) (~8.1 km from centre)

Pizza World

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 My wife and I absolutely love this place. We go for the buffet once a week. If they don't have what you want on the buffet they'll make what you ask for. Excellent staff, great food. They don't serve alcohol which makes it ideal for families with younger children. Also a great place for birthday pa...

$ $$$

4.20 (503 reviews) (~8.46 km from centre)

Imo's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

No-frills chain specializing in St. Louis-style pies with thin crusts & Provel cheese.

$$ $$

4.10 (1.4K reviews) (~3.98 km from centre)

The Last Hotel STL

Hotel

Upscale quarters, dining & a rooftop pool in a fashionable hotel set in a converted shoe factory.

4.10 (799 reviews) (~3.99 km from centre)

Imo's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

No-frills chain specializing in St. Louis-style pies with thin crusts & Provel cheese.

$$ $$

3.90 (813 reviews) (~4.94 km from centre)

Imo's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

No-frills chain specializing in St. Louis-style pies with thin crusts & Provel cheese.

$$ $$

3.80 (765 reviews) (~8.2 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, United States