Top rated Italian restaurants in Holtsville, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Holtsville

Experience the best that Holtsville has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 55 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Holtsville

Gino's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Small, spare pizza counter with painted wall murals turns out slices & basic Italian entrees.

$$ $$

4.60 (1.1K reviews) (~5.17 km from centre)

Tony's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 With all the options in the area for Pizza, this is a Wonderful place to get dinner for the family when you know you won't be able to make it yourself! Their pizza is delicious and CONSISTENT! Friday's are great for their once a week Zeppolis. The garlic knots are perfect.

$ $$$

4.60 (489 reviews) (~3.79 km from centre)

Uncle Joe's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Specialty pies, sandwiches & classic Italian entrees served in an easygoing sit-down restaurant.

$ $$$

4.60 (431 reviews) (~7.59 km from centre)

Rocco's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Best pizza ever, this is the trio pie w/ vodka, marinara, pesto and fresh moz. A must stop every time I’m on the island.

$ $$$

4.60 (289 reviews) (~5.42 km from centre)

Mozzafiato Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 I have been looking for a good pizza place in Centereach for quite some time. This one blows away all of the neighboring pizzerias. I felt so comfortable bringing my family in for a few slices of pizza and he had more types of pizza than I could ever hope for. The staff was well versed and how Pizza...

$$ $$

4.60 (284 reviews) (~5.57 km from centre)

Furcis Pizza Inc

Pizza restaurant

🫤 I really can’t rate the atmosphere or service because it’s just a pizza place with a few tables. I haven’t been there in awhile and decided to pick up a veal francese hero. When I got home and opened it, I was shocked. I never had a hero this bad. The veal was cut into strips and there was hardly an...

$$ $$

4.60 (238 reviews) (~7.7 km from centre)

Il Trio

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Very good gluten free pizza and gluten free chicken parm!! Friendly staff who took great care of my husband (who has celiac disease) and I! Will definitely be coming back!

$$ $$

4.60 (224 reviews) (~8.25 km from centre)

La Grova Ristorante

Italian restaurant

Circa-1978 restaurant serving classic Italian cooking in an old-world setting with wood paneling.

$$ $$

4.60 (198 reviews) (~7.44 km from centre)

Sal Anthony's II

Pizza restaurant

😠 -Had to edit the review since last pickup tonight. Guy overcharged me. $23 for a regular pie pickup. Even Grubhub charges $17 for a regular pie. Guy even used my picture for regular pie which I have since removed since being overcharged, it’s my home table. If you’re going to order, do it through gr...

$$ $$

4.60 (128 reviews) (~5.33 km from centre)

La Margherita Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Spacious Italian eatery starring pizza from a wood-burning brick oven & familiar Italian dishes.

$$ $$

4.50 (1K reviews) (~7.67 km from centre)

Butera's

Italian restaurant

Bustling spot with a warm atmosphere serving generous portions of Italian favorites.

$$ $$

4.50 (754 reviews) (~9.33 km from centre)

Satelite Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Awesome food love their Lasagna, their cheese burgers are delicious and very good Sicilian pizza. I’ve been going there for over 30 years one of my favorite restaurants. Finally opened the new side of the restaurant big improvement.

$$ $$

4.50 (628 reviews) (~7.6 km from centre)

Bella Roma Restaurant and Pizzeria

Restaurant

Easygoing option whipping up a variety of pizzas & pastas, along with other Italian fare.

$$ $$

4.50 (387 reviews) (~7.38 km from centre)

Umberto's of Sayville

Pizza restaurant

😠 I just threw out 100.00 worth of food. I will start off with my husband who ordered the pasta puttanesca horrible. I ordered the vegan eggplant Parmigiano the eggplant was raw in the garbage and don't get the plant based stuff peppers. My sister ordered ziti with grilled chicken in a vodka sauce so...

$$ $$

4.50 (359 reviews) (~9.26 km from centre)

La Villetta II

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Arrived at ISP on a Tuesday evening, and was very hungry. Was looking for a local place. No chain. Saw this was right along our route and almost past it If it wasn't for Google maps. It's very quaint, refined. Great customer service (especially for the fact that the two waiters would doubling as ba...

$$ $$

4.50 (316 reviews) (~7.03 km from centre)

Sal's Pizzeria and Catering

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Wow! I called Sals Pizza, placed an order and told him that I really needed the food fast, because we had to go somewhere. They said they would, and they definitely did!! The pizza is delicious, The prices are Great!! They are just amazing people that work there!! Thank you Sals pizzeria, you guys...

$ $$$

4.50 (314 reviews) (~9.05 km from centre)

Giorgios

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 I Reallllllly liked the meatballs in my meatball hero, but the bread wasnt as robust as I would have liked. The taste if a meatball and the consistancy of the meatball along with the gravy are much more important than the bread. I only wish there was a bit more texture and crust on the bread.

$ $$$

4.50 (303 reviews) (~9.06 km from centre)

Villa Sorrento

Italian restaurant

Traditional eatery offering Italian staples & a fixed-price menu in an atmospheric, candlelit room.

$$ $$

4.50 (271 reviews) (~9.99 km from centre)

The Bistro Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 La Mia’s Pizzeria has been amazing in every aspect of their business. They are professional, yet generous and courteous, as well as funny!! Their food is also amazing and they’re willing to make dietary changes without hesitation. I truly don’t go anywhere else because they are my number one. I high...

$$ $$

4.50 (208 reviews) (~7.45 km from centre)

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

Pizza restaurant

😠 Usually an exceptional experience, disappointed in the response to a LOYAL customer. I called ahead and ordered a large amount of food. I arrived when they stated it would be ready. Not only did I wait an additional 25 minutes, but the food was burnt. I understand things happen, so I called to make...

$ $$$

4.40 (857 reviews) (~3.01 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Holtsville, United States