1
Vinny & Son Pizza (Andover)
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 One of Sussex County's Best family owned restaurants! Great food from all the varieties of pizza to dinner specials. Frank and his staff are always up beat and very polite. If not just for a slice stop in, you won't be disappointed 👍
$ $$$
4.80 (185 reviews)
(~9.64 km from centre)
2
Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 Please avoid at all costs. I have gone to them several times and their service has usually been excellent. However, I ordered a simple case of 6 fried Oreos today. I have had them several times in the past and they tasted just fine. Today, however, they tasted solely of the peanut oil they are fri...
$$ $$
4.60 (408 reviews)
(~8.45 km from centre)
3
Sal's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 For 29 Years Sals Pizza has been serving Stanhope.with authentic New York style Pizza. Out of the past 50 pizzerias that I have visited over the past 2 months, I have not seen anyone who has the passion for pizza like Sal. He came around the corner and talked the finer details that go into producing...
$ $$$
4.60 (343 reviews)
(~4.98 km from centre)
4
Firehouse Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 Nice place that is tucked away off the main road. Not the best Pizza is you are Hunting the Best Slice for the Pizza Hunters App. Just basic ingredients that are used here to produce mass amount of Pizza at an affordable price. It hits the spot if you are looking to grab a slice on the run. 2.5 . Ne...
$ $$$
4.60 (315 reviews)
(~9.24 km from centre)
5
Branda's Italian Grill
Pizza restaurant
Relaxed bistro providing Italian cuisine such as pizza, pasta & classic entrees, plus a kids' menu.
$$ $$
4.60 (312 reviews)
(~9.24 km from centre)
6
Anthony Francos Pizza Roxbury
Pizza restaurant
Casual, counter-serve eatery with Italian staples, known for its brick-oven pizza.
$ $$$
4.60 (204 reviews)
(~6.89 km from centre)
8
Frank's Pizza (Hopatcong)
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Had my daughters baptism here and service was ridiculously good. Sergio and Lubia really went above and beyond to make this experience as stress free as possible. The food was amazing! I would 100% cater from them again and even have another event here.
$$ $$
4.50 (503 reviews)
(~0.24 km from centre)
9
Carmine's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Perennial, family-owned parlor with basic Italian fare, plus gluten-free & whole wheat pizza crusts.
$$ $$
4.50 (480 reviews)
(~5.51 km from centre)
10
Cambiotti's Tomato Pie Cafe
Italian restaurant
👍 Tomato pie. Best pizza this side of the Delaware. The pizza is for sure the star here. There’s no other like it, Thin crust and crispy. Sauce is a little tangy and sweet and cheese is fresh. The rest is average Italian fare. Wasn’t thrilled with the 2 meatball spaghetti dinner I got, but once again...
$$ $$
4.50 (422 reviews)
(~3.27 km from centre)
11
Joe's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
😐 First time here and it was not a good impression.
I ordered a dinner with the sauce topping on the side.. I do this to better judge the meats quality & age..some restaurants will give you the older meat with freezer burns just to get rid of it and cover it with sauce & melted cheese.
I guess I caugh...
$ $$$
4.50 (244 reviews)
(~6.75 km from centre)
12
Vinny & Son Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant (Lake Hopatcong)
Pizza restaurant
😐 There is a ton of potential with this slice of Pizza, but they need to bring it all together. Once slice all I tasts was the cheese, next slice was all crust and finally slice 3 I got to taste the sauce which was very good. Usually I eat just one slice, so I gave this pizza every opportunity to spe...
$$ $$
4.50 (242 reviews)
(~4.44 km from centre)
13
The Grotto Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Longtime pizzeria featuring assorted pies, plus pasta dishes & sandwiches in a simple setting.
$ $$$
4.50 (205 reviews)
(~1 km from centre)
14
Joe and Anthony's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 A few weeks ago we hired Anthony to cater our backyard wedding at Cranberry Lake and it was one of the best decisions we made!! The level of attention and detail he gave us during the planning of the event was incredible! He met with us on multiple occasions to go over and revise the menu as needed,...
$$ $$
4.50 (188 reviews)
(~6.93 km from centre)
15
The Windlass
Restaurant
Spacious lakeside restaurant serving Italian fare amid nautical accents & a boat-shaped bar.
$$ $$
4.40 (1.8K reviews)
(~3.13 km from centre)
16
Maria's Pizzeria And Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
😐 People were very nice at the counter when we came in to grab a few slices on the run. The Pizza was an average slice, the sauce was tasty, cheese was a little dry and the crust was average. A 3.5 on the Pizza Hunters App. They must be doing something right to be in business for 30 years, an amazing...
$ $$$
4.40 (397 reviews)
(~7.47 km from centre)
17
La Forchetta Pizzeria & Italian Grill
Pizza restaurant
😐 The Morria County Pizza Tour continues at La Forchetta. The Service was good and the lady who was serving the tables was very nice. The pizza was good, solid slice for the area and at $1.85 per slice provides good value. Needed the tast more of the Sauce on the slice. The cheese was good and the sli...
$$ $$
4.40 (203 reviews)
(~7.32 km from centre)
18
Cinders Wood Fire Grill
American restaurant
This upscale, rustic-chic spot serves a menu of steaks, sushi & small plates.
$$$ $
4.30 (801 reviews)
(~7.39 km from centre)
19
Franks Pizza And Restaurant On 15
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 I’m a limo driver from the shore and brought a client up to Jefferson to visit with family. While I had 3 hours to kill I was hungry. I went to Frank’s and OMG it was some of the best Italian food I’ve ever eaten! Service was amazing. I got the chicken parmigiana and it was 🔥🔥🔥. I was literally...
$ $$$
4.30 (338 reviews)
(~6.08 km from centre)
20
Johnny Jr's PIZZA
Pizza restaurant
👍 This pizza is truly defined by its crust. The texture and taste is very good. The $2 slice is big and full of value. Tons of cheese, but could use just a little more sauce. Or maybe that is their intention because the crust is so good? People on the phone were very nice and were very gracious at the...
$ $$$
4.30 (233 reviews)
(~5.25 km from centre)