Top rated Bagel shops in Islip, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Bagel shops in Islip

Experience the best that Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 48 places from Bagel shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Islip

Wally's Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 Awesome place to get bagels and much more!!! I always go to Wally’s Bagels before work to grab myself some breakfast!!! The staff is super helpful and friendly!!! They always get my order exactly how I like it!!! I’m a regular at this place!!!

$ $$$

4.60 (960 reviews) (~4.71 km from centre)

Railroad Bagel Express

Bagel shop

👍👍 Bagels and sandwiches are worth the wait in the long line. Staff was very friendly and made our orders exactly as requested. Wish I lived closer to go back!

$ $$$

4.60 (285 reviews) (~5.44 km from centre)

West Islip Bagel

Bagel shop

👍👍 Just got bagels from here for the first time and was very happy with the service and food. Bagels were fresh and the Puerto Rican woman at the counter was wonderful even though she wasn't helping me both her and the other woman helping put a smile on my face. If I'm in the area I will definitely be...

$ $$$

4.60 (171 reviews) (~2.76 km from centre)

Grandpa J's Bagel and Deli

Bagel shop

👍👍 good food and fair prices ! will be back soon !

$ $$$

4.50 (177 reviews) (~6.62 km from centre)

Avenue Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 Avenue Bagels is a treasure of a store with wonderful staff and outstanding bagels and breakfast fare. It's my to-go spot for an authentic breakfast. The breakfast bagel special is my favorite, substitutions gladly accommodated.

$ $$$

4.40 (229 reviews) (~6.57 km from centre)

N & B Bagels

Bagel shop

😠 Not enforcing masks properly at all. Manager and employees let 3 teen boys inside all without masks, took their order and everything. It wasn’t even that they weren’t wearing the mask properly, they all had NO MASKS, at all. No one did anything about it until I made a comment that they need to be en...

$ $$$

4.40 (122 reviews) (~4.66 km from centre)

First Class Bagels Deer Park

Bagel shop

👍👍 My go to bagel spot! I’ve tried many and coming from queens I still loved this place for bagels! I’ve tried Wally’s bagels and still come to this place. I’m not a huge fan of their pastries, they’re ok, and other menu items but they do bagels well! Not only is the variety insane for bagels, but the...

$$ $$

4.30 (444 reviews) (~7.31 km from centre)

Bagel Factory

Bagel shop

😠 The ratings are True : Teenage workers there are making a bad name for this place. They don’t know how to take orders and multitask. The management needs to hire better employees. Experience: order 3 coffees, 2 ice teas, 3 bagels … and the teenage girl ran to the manager… the order made her feel...

$ $$$

4.30 (346 reviews) (~7.58 km from centre)

West Babylon Bagels & Deli

Bagel shop

🫤 I have visited this bagel shop many times over the years because the egg sandwiches are delicious when they get the order correct. On my last 6 visits, 3 of the orders have been wrong which we don't know until we drive away. On my visit last week, I called in 2 egg sandwiches and I hadn't check th...

$ $$$

4.30 (291 reviews) (~9.09 km from centre)

Higbie Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 Not only are the Bagels fantastic but the assortment of cream cheese choices are amazing. Love the West Islip colors on the special bagels. I really enjoyed the taste, texture and flavors of these bagels and had the opportunity to try the organic chicken soup that the chef made and it was incredible...

$ $$$

4.30 (171 reviews) (~3.55 km from centre)

East Neck Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 always great service! also big selection 👌 👏 🙌🍻

$ $$$

4.30 (112 reviews) (~7.69 km from centre)

Steve's Hot Bagels & Bakery

Bakery

😠 I purchased a cake this morning for a client and completely mortified and embarrassed to have found mold surrounding the bottom layer of the cake. I asked before I purchased the cake, when was the cake baked and I was told last night. Mold does not develop overnight. I have been to Steve’s a few ti...

$ $$$

4.30 (108 reviews) (~8.16 km from centre)

Bagel Buzz

Bagel shop

🫤 Bagels are good. Some staff not so customer service friendly. One staff always looks annoyed as if you are an inconvenience for coming in to order bagels. If it wasn’t for convenience of the store location I would go elsewhere. I get people can have bad days but I would like a positive experienc...

$ $$$

4.20 (221 reviews) (~2.83 km from centre)

Dooley's Bagel & Deli

Bagel shop

😠 Staff are decent I guess but the food quality is not plus they charge extra for credit without telling you and when you ask why they didn't tell you they point at a small sign that mentions it. Since they are priced like they are a normal decent bagel place you expect that yet unfortunately it isn't...

$ $$$

4.20 (87 reviews) (~9.26 km from centre)

Bagel & Bakery

Bagel shop

👍👍 I just left this deli 10 mins ago and my sandwich is PERFECT. Thank you Sam! He told me to tel him how I want it and he’ll make it. Couldn’t ask for better.

$ $$$

4.20 (61 reviews) (~5.88 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

4.10 (452 reviews) (~8.29 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

4.10 (444 reviews) (~6.96 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

4.10 (371 reviews) (~6.23 km from centre)

Sunrise Bagel

Bagel shop

😐 Lox bagel should have red onions always. My omelette no cheese and damn near burnt. Bagel not toasted but i guest that’s a New York thing to do cold bagels and cold butter. This has potential but omelettes should have cheese always a fact. Some meals people should just know how to cook

$ $$$

4.10 (135 reviews) (~3.93 km from centre)

Bagel & Deli Creations

Bagel shop

🫤 I come here pretty often and usually satisfied with the food and service. However, when I pay almost 10 dollars for a hero, I expect it to have at least close to a pound of meat in it and not two to three slices of each. I did go back to let them know it wasn’t acceptable. At first they were a bit a...

$ $$$

4.00 (504 reviews) (~9.66 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Bagel shops in Islip, United States