Top rated Italian restaurants in Islip, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Islip

Experience the best that Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 60 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Islip

il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante

Italian restaurant

👍👍 This place is wonderful. Outstanding service. Staff will make you feel welcome and they will make sure everything is perfect. It’s a small restaurant with a good atmosphere. Food was tasty and cooked to perfection. Highly recommended for any casual dinner or special occasion.

4.90 (331 reviews) (~5.42 km from centre)

Sempre Vivolo

Italian restaurant

Elegant Italian restaurant featuring regional cuisine & a long wine list in sophisticated surrounds.

$$$ $

4.70 (322 reviews) (~9.97 km from centre)

Pastosa Ravioli

Pasta shop

🫤 I called ahead because I was getting there 4 min after closing they said they would stay open. I drove all the way there. And they closed as I was pulling in 3min after closing I told them my order and everything and they said they would wait. So rude. They could have just said no. Waisted my time....

$$ $$

4.70 (210 reviews) (~4.61 km from centre)

Fratelli Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Perennial pizza parlor in a strip mall offering Italian specialties plus wine in cozy, relaxed digs.

$$ $$

4.70 (182 reviews) (~3.23 km from centre)

Francesco's Trattoria

Pizza restaurant

Down-to-earth, brick-lined option for pizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food, plus cocktails.

$$ $$

4.70 (152 reviews) (~7.55 km from centre)

Mezza Luna

Italian restaurant

👍👍 This restaurant is the site of Mario, one of our favorite restaurants. It has been beautifully redesigned and updated. Many of the waitstaff remain: mature, welcoming and professional waiters who deliver excellent service. The food is delicious and many favorites remain on the menu- we enjoyed v...

4.70 (86 reviews) (~9.7 km from centre)

Tony's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

Long-running, family-owned institution with pizza & old-school Italian dishes to eat in or take out.

$$ $$

4.60 (558 reviews) (~8.84 km from centre)

Butera's - Bay Shore

Italian restaurant

Bustling spot with a warm atmosphere serving generous portions of Italian favorites.

$$ $$

4.60 (414 reviews) (~1.7 km from centre)

The Pie at Salvatore's

Pizza restaurant

Hopping pizzeria with classic leather booths serving coal-fired Neapolitan pies & more. Cash only.

$$ $$

4.60 (387 reviews) (~1.93 km from centre)

Da Noi Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Traditional meat, seafood & pasta dishes served in a cozy, refined bistro with an outdoor patio.

$$ $$

4.60 (248 reviews) (~4.19 km from centre)

Mangia Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Hands down best pizza in Babylon or any surrounding town; i dare say best in NY. i must have ordered over 100 pizzas from Mangia and every one is better than the last. on top of that, the owner is such a stand up guy. great pizza, great food, 10/10 service. if i was on my death bed, i would order a...

$$ $$

4.60 (227 reviews) (~4.62 km from centre)

Renzo's

Italian restaurant

👍👍 If you want excellent pizza with competitive pricing this is your pizzeria for the Town of East Islip and surrounding areas. The owner always greets me promptly by name with a smile. Customer experience is excellent here. They have many different types of pizza to choose from and can always make cus...

$$ $$

4.60 (116 reviews) (~7.84 km from centre)

Bambino Ravioli Pastificio

Pasta shop

👍👍 Ate here for lunch while doing some shopping at the Tanger Outlet. Everything is made from scratch. The lobster ravioli is one of the best ravioli we ever had. 9.9/10. Spaghetti hand made 9.5/10, cost an extra 4 bucks “small” with the chicken parm. The dinner for two $17 chicken parm with fresh mozz...

$$ $$

4.60 (113 reviews) (~5.76 km from centre)

Mary's Pizza and Pasta

Pizza restaurant

😠 I was really disappointed in how I was treated at this establishment. last night I placed an order over the phone and when I went to pick it up I was ignored by the cashier. I stood in front of the cash register for five minutes waiting for her to offer me service; the whole time she ignored me whil...

$$ $$

4.50 (1K reviews) (~9.26 km from centre)

Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

Family-run eatery preps Italian staples & a deep lineup of specialty pizzas in a simple space.

$$ $$

4.50 (752 reviews) (~8.12 km from centre)

La Famiglia

Italian restaurant

Local chainlet of warm restaurants with homey Italian food served in portions meant for sharing.

$$ $$

4.50 (460 reviews) (~5.57 km from centre)

Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta

European restaurant

🫤 The food here isn't bad. Ambiance could be much much better especially for a family oriented restaurant/pizza shop. Yankees and Mets both having great seasons with a game on every day yet me or my group is forced to watch Tucker Carlson looking down upon us from the big screen TV every time I try to...

$ $$$

4.50 (429 reviews) (~2.52 km from centre)

Brunello Italian Kitchen

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Our party of six at lunch enjoyed our meal today. We were seated immediately, and asked if we'd like to order a beverage. Water and bread were brought to the table soon after. We each ordered our entrees a glass of wine. Total time sitting at our table: 80 minutes, some of that idly chatting; I supp...

$$ $$

4.50 (425 reviews) (~7.12 km from centre)

Mamma Santina Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Great place for an authentic Italian, family style cuisine. Such good people. My mother is 100% Sicilian, and very hard to impress... she was amazed gave everything a HARD five stars.... do yourself, and your loved ones, a favor.... eat at Mama Santinas!!

$ $$$

4.50 (417 reviews) (~0.1 km from centre)

Spassos Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Ordered the Spasso House Special pizza and had it delivered to Root + Branch Brewery. The pizza came hot, fresh and was delicious. It was enjoyed by many fine people that day!

$$ $$

4.50 (390 reviews) (~9.88 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Islip, United States