Best places: Italian restaurants in Islip, United States

👍👍 This place is wonderful. Outstanding service. Staff will make you feel welcome and they will make sure everything is perfect. It’s a small restaurant with a good atmosphere. Food was tasty and cooked to perfection. Highly recommended for any casual dinner or special occasion.

Unassuming mom-&-pop restaurant offering creative thin-crust pizzas & hearty Italian dishes.

Modern Italian fare served in a refined cottage with a fixed-price option. Cash only and BYOB.

Small, spare pizza counter with painted wall murals turns out slices & basic Italian entrees.

Rustic Italian fare with a seasonal twist headlines at this cash-only, simple BYOB.

Mediterranean place with an extensive menu of gyros, panini & Greek, Italian & American entrees.

Elevated & inviting eatery with Tuscan-style decor turning out Sicilian mains & wood-fired pizza.

Classy, intimate American-Italian spot & bar with steak deals & wine dinners from a vast list.

👍👍 Was on the search for gnocchi for my grandpa for takeout. Called about 4 places and then Angelo’s thankfully said they had it! I ordered the lemon fettuccine Alfredo with blackened chicken. Pick up process was smooth . A small cozy restaurant. The Alfredo sauce was DELICIOUS and they gave a generous...

Elegant Italian restaurant featuring regional cuisine & a long wine list in sophisticated surrounds.

Long-running, family-owned institution with pizza & old-school Italian dishes to eat in or take out.

👍👍 Little fast food place on the corner great prices great food I had the short rib Peter Luger taco which was very interesting it was very good My wife had the steak supreme tacos that were excellent according to her I also had the Polo supreme which was very good could have used a little more hot sau...

Italian staples in casual yet stylish surrounds with leather booths plus stone & dark-wood accents.

👍 I ordered penne a la vodka and meatballs.. it was 30 min before closing.. the guy who answered the phone said.. “depends what you want cuz we are about to close” Luckily they made the food... HOWEVER! It was a take out order.. and they did not give me utensils or napkins.. and I was staying at a hot...

Lively Italian eatery with wood-fired oven & deep wine list serves classics in cozy Tuscan environs.

Tiny eatery serving numerous courses of super-inventive eclectic & Italian tasting menus.

👍👍 With all the options in the area for Pizza, this is a Wonderful place to get dinner for the family when you know you won't be able to make it yourself! Their pizza is delicious and CONSISTENT! Friday's are great for their once a week Zeppolis. The garlic knots are perfect.

Casual strip-mall restaurant & pizza parlor attracts crowds with hearty helpings of Italian staples.

👍👍 Best pizza and chicken parmigiana heros for literally miles, no competition, i can down half a pie in less then 10 minutes.

Specialty pies, sandwiches & classic Italian entrees served in an easygoing sit-down restaurant.