Top rated Pet stores in Islip

Experience the best that Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 44 places from Pet store category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Treat Your Pet image
1
Treat Your Pet
Pet supply store
👍👍 Very helpful over the phone. Stock checks over the phone can be a handful when you’re working retails, to the point where other chain pet stores have begun to forbid it. But that’s where a more boutique local store helps in getting down and dirty into inventory. Even willing to check/place shipments...
5.00 (83 reviews) (~39.69 km from centre)
Maximum K9 Service image
2
Maximum K9 Service
Dog trainer
👍👍 If you’re searching around for training for your pup, you may as well stop your search here and look no further. Maximum k9 is an incredibly fantastic facility, to say the least. I put my Doberman, Reina, up for a month stay for their board and train program and from start to finish everyone was ver...
4.90 (1K reviews) (~16.57 km from centre)
Westhampton Pet image
3
Westhampton Pet
Pet store
4.80 (68 reviews) (~49.84 km from centre)
Lucky Paws Pet Grooming & Doggy Day Care image
4
Lucky Paws Pet Grooming & Doggy Day Care
Dog day care center
👍👍 I am a fairly new Long Beach resident, and became a fur-mom during the pandemic. I started taking my Ellie Jo to Beach Buds last summer, and was completely impressed with the business. The owner, Derek, is very kind, and patiently answered all of my first-time-dog-mom questions! He truly put all my...
4.80 (38 reviews) (~40.47 km from centre)
Animal Pantry image
5
Animal Pantry
Pet store
👍👍 Cats walking around so you can really interact with them if you are looking to adopt. If you're not careful they are so cute :) They have a wide choice of American made food and healthier choices. Food that you can find online if you really search but now you can find it all in one place here.
4.70 (302 reviews) (~16.02 km from centre)
Brian's Tropical Aquarium & Pets image
6
Brian's Tropical Aquarium & Pets
Pet store
👍👍 Very helpful. My tank was so green i could barely see my fish. They told me exactly what i needed to do and now my tank is crystal clear. The prices are not bad either. Definitely my go to place for my fish tank stuff. Not going anywhere else!! Thanks Brian!
4.70 (272 reviews) (~39.62 km from centre)
Repxotica, Inc image
7
Repxotica, Inc
Reptile store
👍👍 Bought my female Ultramel named sol from here. Extremely informative, and kept a log tracking its feeding ( helpful ) . I nornally ask a ton of question and they were answered kindly and patiently . Im now a frequent visitor and buyer now for my supplies . Thank you wonderful staff !
4.70 (222 reviews) (~12.99 km from centre)
The Wellwood Pigeon Store image
8
The Wellwood Pigeon Store
Pet store
😠 The phone person was very rude and hung upon me. I called back and goes, "Welcome to good burger may I take your order"
4.70 (101 reviews) (~16.36 km from centre)
Pet Supplies Plus Valley Stream image
9
Pet Supplies Plus Valley Stream
Pet supply store
Chain carrying natural & U.S.-made pet supplies, plus services such as grooming & adoption.
$ $$$
4.60 (596 reviews) (~44.06 km from centre)
Pet Supplies Plus Central Islip image
10
Pet Supplies Plus Central Islip
Pet supply store
Chain carrying natural & U.S.-made pet supplies, plus services such as grooming & adoption.
$ $$$
4.60 (486 reviews) (~14.95 km from centre)
Mutts & Butts image
11
Mutts & Butts
Pet store
4.60 (473 reviews) (~30.69 km from centre)
Pet Supplies Plus Deer Park image
12
Pet Supplies Plus Deer Park
Pet supply store
Chain carrying natural & U.S.-made pet supplies, plus services such as grooming & adoption.
$ $$$
4.60 (268 reviews) (~17.35 km from centre)
Tractor Supply Co. image
13
Tractor Supply Co.
Animal feed store
Chain with a wide variety of agricultural & livestock supplies, plus tools, workwear & boots.
4.60 (264 reviews) (~47.1 km from centre)
Tropical Island Aquarium Salt Water Fish Store Long Island image
14
Tropical Island Aquarium Salt Water Fish Store Long Island
Pet store
👍👍 Extremely friendly & very knowledgeable staff. They take there time to explain any questions you may have. Great prices with a lot of selections of corals/fishes. Highly recommended to everyone looking for a caring store. We’ve been to different places & nothing compares to them!
4.60 (154 reviews) (~19.53 km from centre)
First Flight Exotic Birds image
15
First Flight Exotic Birds
Pet store
👍👍 Clean, Personable and Reasonably Priced. I went to many bird/pet specialty stores on Long Island before I came here. How I wish I would have just come here first! But then I wouldn't realize how great they are compared to other shops. Nice bird selection.. I got a Green Cheek Conure for at least $15...
4.60 (99 reviews) (~29.41 km from centre)
Parrots of the World image
16
Parrots of the World
Pet store
Pet shop specializing in hand-fed parrots, plus other exotic mammals, reptiles & related supplies.
4.50 (990 reviews) (~38.71 km from centre)
Country Critters Ltd image
17
Country Critters Ltd
Pet supply store
🫤 This could be a thriving store, but the owner is not a nice guy. I have been in the pet industry for 40 years. The positive is that it's a beautiful store and maintained, Too often understocked and overpriced. I understand how expensive it is to stay open, and that all prices to do so have increased...
4.50 (900 reviews) (~20.94 km from centre)
PetSmart image
18
PetSmart
Pet supply store
Chain featuring a range of pets, supplies & food (most offer grooming, boarding & other services).
4.50 (739 reviews) (~14.36 km from centre)
Pet Supplies Plus Smithtown image
19
Pet Supplies Plus Smithtown
Pet supply store
Chain carrying natural & U.S.-made pet supplies, plus services such as grooming & adoption.
$ $$$
4.50 (284 reviews) (~23.98 km from centre)
Tropical Showcase image
20
Tropical Showcase
Tropical fish store
Strip-mall stop for live fish & aquarium equipment for both fresh- & saltwater setups.
4.50 (246 reviews) (~32.74 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Islip

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )