Hidden gems: Restaurants in Key West


  1. 5.00 Mayanjali Organic Cafe   (65 reviews)
  2. 5.00 CAFELITO   (35 reviews)
  3. 4.90 The Garden CafΓ¨ Key West   (33 reviews) Dogs allowed
  4. 4.80 Riviera Coffee & Sandwich Shop   (96 reviews)
  5. 4.80 Taco Grilla   (69 reviews) CLOSED
  6. 4.80 Mile Zero Cafe   (53 reviews) CLOSED
  7. 4.80 CD Anchor Food Truck Sigsbee   (52 reviews)
  8. 4.70 Yahman's Authentic Jamaican Jerk Shack   (95 reviews)
  9. 4.70 Souperhappy Noodle and Sake Bar   (64 reviews)
  10. 4.70 Hangover Hospital   (58 reviews)
  11. 4.70 Henry and Eli's Side Street Pub   (57 reviews) CLOSED
  12. 4.70 Lil’ Lepowski Cafe   (23 reviews) Quick bite
  13. 4.70 Currys Mansion Inn   (19 reviews) Casual
  14. 4.70 Yummy Crab   (16 reviews)
  15. 4.60 Marlin Cafe Key West Fl.   (14 reviews)
  16. 4.50 Bel Mare Restaurant   (93 reviews)
  17. 4.50 AJ DE LUNAS cafe   (61 reviews) CLOSED
  18. 4.50 Key West Taco Dog Food Stand   (26 reviews)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

What's a Hidden gem?

We call places hidden gems that are new, extremely good, but are not that popular yet - you should check them out. The criteria is to have a rating of 4.5 or more and less than 100 reviews.

This page was last updated on Dec 12, 2022.