Best places in New Holstein
Discover the best places in New Holstein, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. Please note that certain places categories are intentionally excluded to ensure a refined selection. Ratings are based from 18 places in the city.
Sort results by
Best Top rated Most reviewed Hidden gems Worst rated Recently discoveredSearch radius
Categories
1
Schwarz's Supper Club
Steak house
Long-standing, bustling locale for massive steaks & an extensive wine list in nostalgic surrounds.
$$ $$
4.70 (1.7K reviews)
2
Hidden Hollow ART
Art gallery
👍👍 I absolutely love this place. The atmosphere makes me happy. Bought several gifts for my adult children! Unique and thoughtful gifts! And the owner is awesome!
4.90 (240 reviews)
3
Altona Supper Club
Restaurant
😐 We've been here many times before and were always very satisfied. Brought some friends and family from out of town for the seafood buffet and were somewhat disappointed. It would be nice if they had traditional Friday fish fry items...fried cod, lake perch and french fries. While they had many ch...
$$ $$
4.50 (1K reviews)
4
Korner Kitchen
Restaurant
👍👍 Wonderful food. Lots to choose from. All day breakfast. Cozy place. Chicken parm was great. Way too much food, just as good the next day.
$ $$$
4.60 (367 reviews)
5
Honeymoon Acres
Greenhouse
👍👍 Great place for assortment! If you can't find a planter container with great varieties of flowers and greens nor a hanging basket, then I guess you don't need one. FABULOUS PRICES! Will be back next season for my ENTIRE flower needs and probably save 30%. Regretting I DIDN'T get ALL MY PLANTS there.
4.70 (223 reviews)
7
Twisted Tap
Bar & grill
👍👍 I just moved to the state. I don’t know anyone, I went to the twisted tap after work to have a beer. The owner noticed she hadn’t seen me before and instantly started conversation and giving drink suggestions. Like other reviews; management, staff and even the patrons of this place are so welcoming...
$ $$$
4.70 (101 reviews)
8
Blattner's Piggly Wiggly
Supermarket
😐 Pricing higher than other chain grocery stores. You don’t have a lot of options in you live in this community. There is a Walmart in Chilton that would be cheaper but your money won’t stay local. Customer service was good. Store a little cluttered with smaller displays.
4.30 (324 reviews)
9
Dilly’s 7 Corners
Bar & grill
👍 Came here with a friend for a quick bite to eat. Enjoy the small town bar feel where everyone is nice? Then this is a great place to try! A horseshoe bar and a few tvs make for a social experience. There are also pull tabs and four or five gaming machines.
Food was alright, ordered a medium burger,...
$ $$$
4.40 (157 reviews)
10
Kings Korner
Bar & grill
👍👍 I ordered sautéed shrimp with rice. And I’ll tell ya what, I was not disappointed. That shrimp and rice was prime. Cooked with love and butter if that’s not the same thing I’d tell you it was. Juan is the best heartfelt bartender and cook you’d come across at this bar. I felt like I drifted to heave...
$ $$$
4.70 (65 reviews)
11
Civic Park
Park
👍👍 Great fireworks again as usual. This year though, they had some very bright mortars with loud reports... Noise? Fine. But the flash was as bright as a welding arc and fear it may have caused permanent eye damage to some folks. Now, we go to lots of firework shows, so we timed it out to about every 1...
4.50 (77 reviews)
12
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe
Bakery
👍👍 They make the very best glazed doughnut I have ever had. And I've had my share at dozens of places in my life.
I first had it at the Sheboygan Farmer's Market and it was so good, we went directly to their farm shop to buy more.
They have a good variety of baked goods at their Sheboygan Farmer's M...
4.90 (43 reviews)
13
Aquatic Center
Public swimming pool
👍👍 The water in there pool is especially warm. LOVE how many Life guards are on duty.
4.40 (83 reviews)
14
Tabasco’s Mexican Restaurant
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Home visiting my mother coming from the Chicago suburbs, the land of Mexican restaurants. My aunt suggested this place for dinner I have to say I was seriously impressed being in the middle of BFE. Yes the service was a bit slow with limited staff but the food was well worth the wait the margarit...
4.20 (88 reviews)
15
Optimist park
Park
👍👍 Beautiful view. Great view for meditation or just relaxation. Nice covered picnic area for sure.
4.70 (34 reviews)
16
The Laundromat, L.L.C.
Laundromat
👍👍 Do my wash there every 2 weeks prices are high but they have quality machines and fix there machines right away and get your money back to you if you lose it in there machines
4.10 (40 reviews)
17
Christian Center Thrift Store
Discount store
😠 This place used to be fun to shop at. But now the furniture they get for free is starting to be expensive. People don't shop here to buy expensive furniture. You should be selling donated items at low prices. Its not fun going here anymore. Unless you want to buy expensive furniture.
3.90 (31 reviews)
18
Starlite Motel
Motel
👍👍 Stayed recently on a Sat. night. Not sure what to expect but was pleasantly surprised at how clean and cozzy the room was. We didn't need anything fancy just a comfy bed to sleep with a microwave to warm up food. This room was perfect...the heater warmed up the room nicely. The microwave was spotles...
3.40 (45 reviews)