Top rated Diamond dealers in New York, United States to elevate your visit (Updated December, 2023)

Top rated Diamond dealers in New York

Experience the best that New York has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 553 places from Diamond dealer category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Family & Co. Jewelers

Jeweler

Long-running emporium for fine jewelry, bridal & engagement rings & custom-design pieces.

5.00 (2.5K reviews) (~128.62 km from centre)

SVS Fine Jewelry - Long Island. NY

Jewelry store

Jewelry shop featuring engagement rings with customizable designs, plus watches & other fine pieces.

5.00 (1.6K reviews) (~32.22 km from centre)

Roman Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 My husband and I got our wedding rings here, we absolutely love them! The service here was incredible they took time to get to know us and find out what we both liked - they didn’t make us feel any pressure at all to buy. A nice bonus is that we also were able to get my husbands ring re sized and th...

5.00 (1.3K reviews) (~59.87 km from centre)

Glennpeter Jewelers - The Diamond Centres

Jeweler

👍👍 Thank you Glennpeter!! Our experience with Mary (along with the other staff) was very pleasant. We bought my engagement ring and our wedding bands here. They were very transparent with the process and eager to get us exactly what we wanted (in terms of price and design of the rings). Mary was FANTA...

5.00 (1K reviews) (~214.3 km from centre)

Benari Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 I would give this lovely group of humans 100 stars if I could. They are the most helpful and caring group of sales people I have ever met. Joel is a top tear salesperson and jeweler. Sheila is an expert gemologist and warm soul. And Helen is absolutely phenomenal to cross paths with. You will not be...

5.00 (994 reviews) (~164.95 km from centre)

Koser Jewelers

Jewelry store

Family-owned jewelry store since 1952 with designer watch collections, plus custom pieces & repairs.

5.00 (952 reviews) (~226.59 km from centre)

Eden Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 One of the best jewelry store in the area! They have super gorgeous jewelry collections with reasonable prices! The staffs are knowledgeable about their products and very friendly! My husband got me this beautiful diamond ring from this place! I think I just got super lucky because the diamond is hi...

5.00 (940 reviews) (~210.85 km from centre)

Eric J. Loch Diamond Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 I broke my engagement ring and I was feeling upset and lost looking for a place to help me fix my ring since it was bought in another country. I went to another jewelry store before coming here and they glanced at my ring for a whole 5 seconds and then quotes me $500 from a paper. I felt helpless be...

5.00 (931 reviews) (~131.67 km from centre)

Conti Jewelers

Jewelry store

5.00 (887 reviews) (~226.43 km from centre)

Landsberg Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 Landsberg Jewelers is wonderful family business that we have been going to for many years. They have an amazing selection of beautiful jewelry. They are incredibly talented jewelers, who can also help you design a piece of jewelry that works for you. They are creative and clearly take great pride i...

$$$ $

5.00 (820 reviews) (~33.23 km from centre)

Maaya Fine Jewels

Jewelry store

👍👍 Update 2(7/21/22) We visited them and they were almost closed. They still helped us find an awesome ring for daily use and we were able to find two that we liked and eventually selected one. They shipped the ring to us in Connecticut after resizing and it just arrived today. The ring is eternally be...

5.00 (764 reviews) (~38.95 km from centre)

Casale Jewelers

Jewelry store

Long-running store offering a selection of jewelry & watches, plus jewelry repair services.

5.00 (727 reviews) (~25.19 km from centre)

Lux Bond & Green

Jewelry store

$$$$

5.00 (633 reviews) (~152.42 km from centre)

Van Horn Jewelers

Jewelry store

5.00 (613 reviews) (~241.1 km from centre)

Wilson & Son Jewelers

Watch store

👍👍 The most trustworthy jeweler we have been to. The staff is so nice and caring and makes you feel at home. We were able to get 2 beautiful watches this year. They also repaired my engagement ring really well (a beautiful but old ring) while other stores would not even consider resetting the diamond....

$$$$

5.00 (573 reviews) (~25.68 km from centre)

Gem Boutique

Jewelry store

Store selling fine jewelry made with gemstones & pearls in a historical building since 1991.

5.00 (562 reviews) (~249.52 km from centre)

Ream Jewelers Fine Jewelry

Jeweler

Upscale shop, founded in 1935, providing fashion & wedding jewelry, watches, custom work & repairs.

5.00 (547 reviews) (~215.43 km from centre)

Frank Adams Jewelers

Jewelry store

Circa-1922 jewelry store offering contemporary & classic pieces, plus engagement rings & watches.

5.00 (515 reviews) (~215.01 km from centre)

Kevin's Fine Jewelry

Jewelry store

👍👍 I walked in to Kevin's Fine Jewelry to start my engagement ring shopping towards the end of November, with the goal of finding a ring by Christmas, no easy feat. I wanted a very unique ring for my fiance and had a vision in mind, but had no idea where to start. Kevin was super friendly and explained...

5.00 (485 reviews) (~25 km from centre)

Valentine's Jewelry

Jewelry store

Little, homey boutique offering engagement & wedding jewelry, plus watches & gift items.

5.00 (476 reviews) (~177.98 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Diamond dealers in New York, United States