Top rated American restaurants in Newburgh

Experience the best that Newburgh has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 329 places from American restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Dave’s Cucina image
1
Dave’s Cucina
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This small pizzeria was recommended to me by a friend and they spoke about this place like it was the best pizzeria in the world. Usually when someone overly recommends a place I tend to be disappointed. I was somewhat reluctant to come because it is over an hour drive from NYC but I decided to make...
$$ $$
4.90 (170 reviews) (~24.54 km from centre)
Creek Bar Catskills image
2
Creek Bar Catskills
American restaurant
👍👍 Love this place. If you love drinking beer in the back yard by a creek with great music hanging with friends check out this hidden gem. Yes there is an inside bar but follow the path to the back bar and just enjoy the scenery.
4.90 (147 reviews) (~48.03 km from centre)
Blooming Hill Farm image
3
Blooming Hill Farm
Farm
👍👍 Large selection of organic produce. I adore this lettuce. Once summer really gets going there will be all kinds of goodies. I do miss the old setup and am praying that the farm store will not get swallowed up by the restaurant and weddings. 🙏❤️🍀
4.80 (727 reviews) (~19.25 km from centre)
Artemio’s Prime and Proper image
4
Artemio’s Prime and Proper
Fine dining restaurant
Enduring bar/eatery serving refined Northern Italian dishes & homemade pasta in warm, cozy environs.
$$ $$
4.80 (340 reviews) (~47.86 km from centre)
The Arch Restaurant image
5
The Arch Restaurant
American restaurant
French-American picks served in a country setting with old-world charm. Jackets are suggested.
$$$ $
4.80 (168 reviews) (~37.5 km from centre)
Harbors Cafe image
6
Harbors Cafe
American restaurant
😠 I asked for no mayo and they put it on anyway. And then she argued with me on the phone saying I didn’t say it that when I know for a fact I did. And then she said, are you allergic, as if I should just eat something I hate anyway. It was a 30 drive there and it’s not like I’m goi g to go back and g...
4.80 (59 reviews) (~35.04 km from centre)
The Lunchbox image
7
The Lunchbox
American restaurant
Sandwiches with carefully sourced ingredients are served at this snug take-out with sidewalk tables.
4.80 (54 reviews) (~47.85 km from centre)
Blue Hill At Stone Barns image
8
Blue Hill At Stone Barns
Restaurant
High-end farm-to-table restaurant serving tasting menus in a refurbished barn on gorgeous grounds.
$$$$
4.70 (1.1K reviews) (~46.92 km from centre)
Countryside Kitchen image
9
Countryside Kitchen
American restaurant
Relaxed breakfast & lunch fixture featuring a variety of pancakes, hearty servings & a wooded deck.
$$ $$
4.70 (755 reviews) (~27.16 km from centre)
The Roost image
10
The Roost
American restaurant
👍👍 Fantastic breakfast and lunch. Simple fresh ingredients, prepared to perfection. We have been back three days in a row! The green shakshuka, grit cake platter... Try it with fresh vegetables, avocado skillet, pastrami hash, beet salad... Try the shakshuka over a grit cake... Wow! Outdoor and...
$$ $$
4.70 (734 reviews) (~40.33 km from centre)
Orange Hill Restaurant, Newburgh, NY image
11
Orange Hill Restaurant, Newburgh, NY
American restaurant
👍👍 My favorite restaurant in Newburgh! Service is amazing. Food is great from appetizers to dessert!
4.70 (725 reviews) (~5.05 km from centre)
Main Course Marketplace image
12
Main Course Marketplace
American restaurant
Local caterer's casual counter-service cafe & takeaway serving farm-to-table American eats.
$$ $$
4.70 (717 reviews) (~27.64 km from centre)
Lola's Cafe image
13
Lola's Cafe
American restaurant
Informal, daytime cafe offering inventive sandwiches, salads & soups for dine-in or takeout.
$$ $$
4.70 (643 reviews) (~24.06 km from centre)
Cafe Mio image
14
Cafe Mio
American restaurant
From eggs to burgers, this casual American cafe whips up breakfast & lunch using local ingredients.
$$ $$
4.70 (610 reviews) (~22.71 km from centre)
George's Place image
15
George's Place
American restaurant
👍👍 Breakfast or lunch, you can't go wrong! Karen and staff are like family. The Carmel Big Apple Waffle is AHHH-MAZING and the Big Greek Gus is even better (beta with feta)! I love that they are so involved with the community too!
$ $$$
4.70 (559 reviews) (~28.97 km from centre)
Ship Lantern Inn image
16
Ship Lantern Inn
American restaurant
Upscale, circa-1925 New American eatery housed in a historic nautical-themed building.
$$$ $
4.70 (527 reviews) (~16.35 km from centre)
Sissy's Cafe image
17
Sissy's Cafe
Cafe
Local, daytime cafe serving up breakfast & lunch plates with vegan options in a comfortable setting.
$$ $$
4.70 (457 reviews) (~47.97 km from centre)
Lynch's on the Green image
18
Lynch's on the Green
American restaurant
Casual bar & grill with a convivial vibe serving an ample selection of burgers, salads & pasta.
$$ $$
4.70 (395 reviews) (~33.69 km from centre)
Dallas Hot Weiners II image
19
Dallas Hot Weiners II
Hot dog restaurant
🫤 The staff was very nice, and welcoming, but the food is no good. The hot dog had no taste, and the bun feels like it was heated in a microwave similar to a movie theater hot dog, except even a movie theater hot dog has more taste. The fries also tasted very cheap. This chain has been around since 19...
$ $$$
4.70 (383 reviews) (~47.19 km from centre)
Dallas Hot Weiners image
20
Dallas Hot Weiners
American restaurant
👍👍 Dallas Hot Wiener's has been a staple of Kingston for at least 50 decades. The sauce is iconic and one that tries to be duplicated. Every time I come back to visit my home state, it's not complete without a trip to the original Dallas Hot Weiner location. I love that they maintain the nostalgic appe...
$ $$$
4.70 (371 reviews) (~48.02 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Newburgh

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )